Computation of yield gradients from statistical timing analysis.

Computation of Yield Gradients from
Statistical Timing Analysis
Vladimir Zolotov
Jinjun Xiong
University of California
Los Angeles, CA
IBM Watson Research Center
Yorktown Heights, NY
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
!#"%$&'
()"*++"%,
-. "++0/1 . 23
"4051, . - . $6" . +7!)
8:9";/4 .=<
" - >+
1#? . ,1
3 . "[email protected]+ . -. "[email protected] - 3+B6C3+D)E
. !F5+,G3AH
614)8JI . 51
"4
6! < K6
(AH3
L +M,+$6,1 L "4AN$O" . P6=1EQ"%RS5N" -1. "/
51F5K4E
"4
+&$O" . " - 6
>T6"=8UI . 35T"4HV5T%"%
[email protected],3AWA
"4"4X"4$YY,16Z),; . ) - AX" . GK3' ["C
"%4 .
L J,+573B+ . +B"0%,65J" - >"4\
FA -1. +1+J"=$
/1 . 2 L 2!8UI?A - - .Y-1. ++W"/4+H5+
)Y+A1")5
"X+"4 - ,CTA1 . 5
+;"4$ - . + . C!)+
5(]TA . + - +;K"
AJ51+KT!#"4$Y3AFV^" . ] . 8;I]A1 . ,
. 5)
L . 1')E_" . 5 . +5($O" . 56 . C" - K6
>T6"=#P - A)!6)`!E
A+W+
1 < " . $O+50"(@1"=1
. " - >+ . $6" . +"%)
,"%,
" - >"4a"4$]54 - . 3+ . X,3AM3J . 1" . >++ <
A,?+ L 6$O" . 3`A+U!)+
5#" - T
>3T"4H8
1.
Chandu Visweswariah
IBM Watson Research Center
Yorktown Heights, NY
INTRODUCTION
I?
1" - >3T"4
G . 35T6"=6
!#"=15,1+5 L ! - A!)
3
!)A+(
bF L . . !E L 5Mc"=d" . . 1
" . >+
17
b
. " . E_
/4+,T"%e514FTA1"5"%
"4%!)8BI]A1^" - 6>)E
"400+A . 3B
@%,
51+5 L ![5+ . TB[JT3'X" .
F . 4
18gfh0A1 -. +1B"=$ -. "++&/ . 2
"%1 < A?%"V31
@K"
6"=G
1^
AG) . -. ")+W - 8UI . 35
"=31+ . '4(5+ . [
(233'i$;" -1. "/
51+" .. +[4,
5+#K"
" - >+ . =8
Ig"^A+ - " - >6"= < ]+"4+ - @6
+5ijklOmQlOjn%[email protected] -. "4E
- "4+5(
ar
s3t < L ,[email protected]"[email protected]+"% - ,1+5+" .. +
!05,G"[ . 3
(" . E
. 2"41 L +
1
41" . +5H8;u . +235F+"4+ - B6
+5vjklwm_lwjn%oplwm_q
lwx1y%z{ J^,1=%++5a6*A+"4+DJ"4$^|~} 1Ib2;" . '#r€tK8
f2Mrt < ^+A1")5iJ -. " - "4+5i"\+"= - ,0A0 . 51
+ "=$
AC#"4$g+ . ,]51+2T!?A . + - ++?T"[A1C)3#52!"=$
)33AF514J"%$AJ6
0 . - A < ?A6AF -. "/=+5F" L J,E
[ . )!JA]3^Y . 3
K!8`9G"@+/4 .< AY;" . 'J51
51"=
"% - ,0A10
/
K!"%[email protected]/ . 2+"4$]+ . +,J5+2!80fh$
,3A( . 35+)^ . C,+5#T"[" - >+?+ . ,
< " - F`
. +,
;51+2! L G" L 3
+5 < L ,1;/ . 2+15a+,H‚!)65
?
L , -. +51
+ L 8
f2ƒTA
- - .< @ -. " - "%7"/4+[5ƒ+[+
+0+A1")5
"4$g+"= - ,[!)+
5( . 51
+^^ - "4TE -. ")+6[T - $w .
VT
1 A L +0+"4 - T5H8g„…?"4 - ,BTAB . E
5
+"=$&†n)k2n%‡[zm_klOjmQlO‡^lOxˆq4l6zopy‰w
+6,51
0"41
5 . 3T"4F"=$
/1 . 23ŠYB
A . + - +"()33A
1+548GI]A[!)+
5… . E
5
+^‰w(+"4‹w,1+
"4(]
A#
3‚23')]" . 1[F . E
I]A1
;" . 'JC51"=1;?A6
;A
B,1A" . C3BXT . #3Hf+Œ;
+ . 3AH8
44Š;5 . +
!…g L 60/ . 6"=,1JK! - +J"%[email protected]" - >"4a,AŽ
- . 3+ . ^!5D[6>
"%F" .G- "=W . [6>
"%F, L E
‹O+]"!65*15(
6 . +Z, . +8
fK["%, . --. "‚3A0W,?AB3[B+"=1+ - W"=$‚ . - A+,1
#r
3t < L ,[email protected]"F"4^,i! - . , . L 6"=*"4$]
F514
|&W‘0" . "%)/%"4
,"4H8*fK5 < W#51 . /4#+D - 6
+H
!
E
3Y+D -. +
"% $w" . 3
Y"4 - "=1+)J"[email protected]!
+65… . 51
+ < ]AA
'%+G"=, . -1-. "‚3A+8;’1
'%(r6[email protected]^51"1"=,\)!
A
E . ,J" [email protected] " - ‚
"%0"4$`+
/
@A . "4,1=AA[E
1B . - A < ]AAJ6JT, . J . !C - 6
“+g"%, . +"= - ,3
"48
I]A1#" . ~3>
"%v"%$CTA . 0"4$GA - - . i$w"4
"]8
+
"%: - "4)G"4,1A1^6
6"=1G"4$ L "4A… . 351
"4H3H51E
. …K3'”15M
G2'•3 . +#"P4,5
" - 6>)
"%g8•++
"%”– . +/)+]i( . 2!7+"% - ,"4
-1. ")5, . C51+ . L +5(
PB"= - 1
"4 - - .< , - "%(]A1
3A(A
-1. " - "4+5v+A"5:
L ,1
687I]A#A1) . 0"4$TA1(51 . /"4v"4$
!
+
5N . 35
+T() L $6"4,15ĥ++
"%ƒ— < ')P,F"4$
$O" . X,K 51 . /45a
au -1- +51
Du[8\|1"4+2 -- "4 "4$
A1 !)6+
5( . 5X . 51+ . L +5#*+"4P€%8
I]A1
(6*F"41 - - - .(. -. ++)7;" . 'ƒ -1. "4 . + <
5A1++G5"+;1"[email protected]+"4)3
, . . ,8g9"@+/= .< A
,A1" . L +
+/%?A6&@" . 'XT" L ?/1,H L ? -1. "/
51
1 =A
5#+
1 . + . A#5 . +
"%18
2. SLACK IS A POOR METRIC
I?
1v+
"4, . i
˜A -. +++a"=$ -. "++#/ . 23T"4#P
1
=AF . 8‚I . 351
"4H3%
1 . ++4[6
. ,[email protected]"%+
-1. ")&" . . T" =,1
51]A]" - [>)3
"4 < L ,&K6
C6=1EQ"%R
. +Z, . + A . ^,TEQ" . 1 . 6[#" . )Y6[~8 fK$
41EQ"4Rv
1F
^1"%(3A6+/=+5 < A" - K6
>T6"=P+"4
,
?
A#"%1"%
"%?$ . "4™KA1 41EQ"4RF[63?T"0]AA
+"%+"=$1
"4%
W1++5^
-1. "/=+)8`[email protected] . "4, L @
HAH?""4
K6
(
C+"45: -1. ")+G+" . . š< /)"423
"4 . X++
-. "++?+" . .?›(< 15/
+ /= . < 35#AC . % . +
+,
/4)8
I . 51
6"=U
1 -1. "/[email protected]"
- " . 3)]5234"4
+œ
 8&I]A1C
51K6h!"4$gAC . 3 - 3A < ]A1
A(]TAC
")"4
"4$`A"4ž L ^$w" . A L ,3')Ÿ^5, . ^" - [>)3
"48
48&I]6
233'" . F . %
8
’G$O" . ,1g3+
! < A -. ++"%$ -. "[email protected]/1 . 23
"4 < A .
"4$^TA+…5234"4+#
#,+$O,T8”}G3A - "4)#
MA1 -. "+
- ?30AT/=;,1Z),1B . )3 - 3A < "J
. K!XTA1 . B
]"%$H . - A1 < A\"=$H?A3A(A[G"%E_>+ . " -. " L L E
K!"%$ L +0 . K8Y‘V" . 6, . "% - , .- "= < ‘~8  A"]
#EQ51
+6"=Y - [?
A -1. "++ - . 3 . J ¡^35* ]¢ <
"4?
A^+"4"4, . H"4$+Z,H -1. " L L K!8WY)
;
,H
"%
£¤
£¤
S1
S2
0.04
©
ª«
ª«
Probability density
©
0.03
Ø
0.02
0.01
Õ
0.00
-100
¥
¨§
¥p¦§
¬?­O®~¯g°±#²V³´°­Qµ+­Q¶%·¸O­Qµ¹PºV»?·…¶4°=­Oµ­w¶)·1¸@¼g·1µ+½:­O¾•¿2·À[·ÁÂ*·¸O¸
°±)®~­OºV¾Pº~»Wµ+½H±¼H°ºU¶4±ÁÁ Á¼g·1¶)±)ÃG¿2ÄHÀJ·\¸O·°=®V±°±®V­Oº~¾PºV»Wµ+½H±
¼g°=º`¶%±)ÁÁ0Á¼H·¶%±Å
?
WAgT/%JX,3AiA4A . 561
"%g3
2!8^I]A0ÆÇ
aA“4E
, . [A"?CA -. "++C+" . 1 . C]A1
AiK6
(
+"=15,1++5
a" . 5 . "\4,50" - >3T"4 < 3 ?AAM - . +,K .J- A
^$O"4,15PT" L TA1"4X . 28\uG^A"SP‘
‚8  < A
- A! L X . …"=1
!7 3
- " . "=…"4$WA -. "++
- 3+# . "%,15…Æ < " . GF! L [ . 3g^,A"4$&TA1^A1
%AE
-. " L L K! -. ")++[ - 3+a3[A"=]7v‘
‚8  L 8…IBA),
[
,1+
. $ . "4È5+ . 0
6\?A1A . " . "% 6J
E
- " . 3)?"
-1. "/= A1C
1Ag . + . 6
+?"%$HKA1
- AH8
É@CZ,6')
!0"4+]"XTA1G+"4+
,1"[email protected]"% . +Z, . +]+
E
A . ^,1
Eh" . . 23' " . 3K6
32'J"C4,5;" - 6>)E
"4H8J[,1
Eh" . . K'B"4 L ^" L 1+5F . ++)3
!
5:3FD - "=1+2), L . "4$&+" . . C
A1 -1. ")+ - 3
F3'4+ A -1. "++5, . -1. "4A L /%8CfK35 < 6
32'
?" . "415,6/= "
1 . +[+`" - . "%("4$HA .< 3
5+ . L +5[
\r6stK8`9G"@+/4 .< K'("CAH -1. " L # . /
X%")"5(+ . $O" . " - T
>3
"4H8
‘1" . "%&TA < T4K3'[email protected] . L ,6"= < 15 -. ++)E
5HT!*" - [>)3
"47")"%
[2! - !a51""4['"ÊA"Ë"53
?
A#5
. L ,
"%8‘1" . "4A1 .< 3
`K' . 3A . $O" . T6"=F+"4+)BAvG51
. L ,"4\+J
2! - 3
!
- . 3[+ . >+5 L !0AC"=, . +]"4$g/ . T"4*‰w8 V8 < ]“ . E_" . 5 .
)31"=1
g$O" . Çr
s3t2Š8XÉ@FAX"4^A15 < A1
G" - +1, -F- "4
E
L 6
+&"%$~,
1 KA1
- . 3[+ . >+5"5+1"jÌ)ÍÍ4ÎzA1?h! - "[email protected]" - 6>)"[email protected]"4,1
5 L + -1. "/%
\3Ag . + . E
+ < L ,1 < "%(A1 "4A .< ?'%+?
?+/%+(" . +"= - +5
$w" . A " - >+ . T", 3
`T3'iX[+ . 6)8
É@ - "= L K!X6W"X,0]ςEh - 5/,"4$`A1BT3'F3
^+ . < )8 V8 < AÐiÑN–Ïv/3
,1["%[email protected]'U8XI]A
^Ag3 A
5/13=C"4$U+1, . 1F51+Z,g3 - . [+ . C!5(]A1+
E
[]+
"%+5 < 15 L +6F?4
C, L . Ag3 . -1. ++)]A
. -1. ")X - +8’G1$6" . T,6! < A1
X[+ . 60AH -1. " L E
+ < T""~8X‘
‚8YXA"]^h;"(T3'56 . L ,"41(Ò  15Nҏ
?A6A#AHT/% AJ(ÑC–Ï/1,8HfK\AJ "4$BÒ  < A 51
E
. L ,1
"4P -. +K!…4A\15P
-. "/=+)#‰w28 8 < "/4+
"[A . 4AŠg
L ^"4 - A+5 L !0"/)6A +) . C51
E
. L ,1
"4H8;"/
10+) . ?5 . L ,1
"402! - ![+"= . )
5 - "@ . [
GC"4$w+:33A+/4+5 L !F
1 . L ,R~ . G" .
, - EQ
>+
1i~48ŽÉ@vA#"4A . A15 < ҏ L (6 -. "/4+5
L ! . 51,J6W
/
2!" -. "++ < 28 )8 < 4A)1
1^
;51
E
. L ,1
"4H8’G$O" . ,H+
! < ςE_3 - +5233'#5"+C"4%
/4[,
A
B2! - "4$H
=A8
Ó "d;]
G+"=15 . "%T(+DU - "P51+["% . A -1. " L 6?
AF3
H23'`8JÔH"41
5 . C
,"4F
Ö
-50
Õ
0
50
Slack (ps)
×
Õ
100
Ö
150
¬?­O®V¯°±JÙV³CÚHµ·1µ­OÁµ­O¶4·1¸~Á¸O·¶=ÛºV»`µ3ÜJº¼H·µ½HÁ]Ü­Oµ½Fµ+½H±JÁ+·1Âa±
ÝÞ ÏMß ·1¸O¯H±Å
[email protected]"^ςEQ= - 5 - 3A0K' . BE3sà(35E€3à - <=. - +E
/%+
!8PI . 35
6"=?]51"=Ç=T!)0"a
-1. "/=\A#“ . - A
6Y
2' . )A1+JE€3à - < 35iA… . !T"\
-. "/= L "%Ag8
W - 156("=A1^ -. 5:15+" .. +23
"=…"4$WTA[h;"5 . E
L ,"41 < [email protected]!01"4 L G"X?
8gf2$gAC -. 5("=$gAC23')
X2 . =…35*[email protected]"F23')\ . ,1" .. +2+5 < A1*TA10+E
"45 - 3TA*T! L …
"4#JX,3Aa"4$JX!
+5a
. JA
“ . 8‚fK$A1+!0 . @
%A)
! +" .. +T+5 < A"@+/4 .< A1^ . 5
"4
?
51"4™
?"%,15H8
"% "4$gA1C5+ . 5#$O, . +?"=$?%")"5#52%"4
. œ
á#-1. +$6 . L 6! < 14 ), L .â
á#-1. +$6 . L 6 ! < ], L . ]
A…;“1D)+5 . 3%?,A…3&àJ"  â
0), L . AH[
+T . - . "+ +? - +
)
1
,
. T A??
L
á
á ),1 L . TA?
á
6
! . -1. +)X . 6h!aPA
â
- +
!(" .. +K
"%E3 . â 5
L G+"% - ,1+5(+
+
!8
3. CRITICALITY PROBABILITIES
Ô . )3
2! -. " L L 6h!#
G+ . ^Ag3B3T“1+BA1 . +Z, . E
+&3+5… L "/48UI?AB . 2! -1. " L L K!X"4$W0+5%?
- ![5+“1+5…@A1 -. " L L 2!["=$`F,$+, . (]A - ?AA(AC . T - A(,5]A]5%)8]Ô . 3
K! -. " L E
L 6
[email protected] . F“ . -. " - "%+5:”r
s3t < A"4,%Av:AH0;" . '
m_lwˆÌ)mQxzÎ3Î]†‚kKÍ4ã3n%ãlwo lOmQlOzÎ@; . [
1+" .. +
!73,+5" L X651E
- +5)05, . 1*AF+"= - ,
"%g8Mud+"4 - "% - - . 3
A1
+"%$O . ++\r
ä3tg51+ . L A"åA+ -. " L L C L +"% - ,+5+++)
!735:3++, . +!8BI?AXA1")56 L . +c!
. +/
+;+5^
[TA
+
"4[]
A . +$w . +;"‘
‚8– < 15^+"%
"4$KA1 $w"4
"]
1 - 8
ÚHµ+±¼æ² I?A[[# . - A…
,4++5…]ANaž_"4, . ++Ÿ
5çžO6'Ÿi")51 < 5v/ . ,]54++"%1+
1…A1#"4, . +
1")5G"\
-. . !0
- ,J35(AG'0")51G"#3
-. . !
"4, - ,15XT
1G"51+8`I]A1;5+2! "%$A[
- ,514
[TAi‰w)32ŠX . +5Ž .. /[email protected]
"%$]A" .. + - "45E
1 -1. . !0 - ,1 < 5#TAC51K!0"4$gA#"=,1 - ,]+54C]A
1~3
/4G"%$gA‰w
KŠ . +Z),1 . +5* .. /3‚[C"4$HAC" . E
. + - "%51
-. . !i"4,1 - ,^" . + - "%
8#f2PA")5“+5
. - A < AG+4A"%$`A1G
"%%+ - ATG"50‰w28 )8 < 23T
"5 .. /1~G"=$gAC
1'"5Š`;Z,6 - !0A1=E
/4^"4$YAX2^")5XK'#"=$&AX5
% < ]A1
6JAX
+4A
"4$JA…A" . + - Ab‰wK8 8 < . !:["5: .. /1C
…"4$JA
'0"5Šg
]A1 . !0"5CT3'0"4$gAC51+
%g8H„ƒAGA
. - Aa,1=+
"% - ]1"[email protected]++TT‚ -1. ++ < ;[E
- “1GA1^+D - T
"% L !(+"%)/% . a6g[ . - AC
)"
9): <;= ý ý?> @A!BCDEGF IH Edges for complement slack computation
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
êëëê
ëë
ëë
ëë
ëë
ëë
ëë
ëë
ëë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
a
é
é
é
é
é
é
é
éèéè
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
ëêëê
èéèé
èé
è
è
è
è
è
è
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
é
é
é
é
é
é
éèéè
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ëêëê
è
è
è
è
è
è
è
éè
b
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
èéèé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
é
é
é
é
é
é
é
éèéè
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ëêëê
è
è
è
è
è
è
è
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
éè
é
é
é
é
é
é
éèéè
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ëêëê
èéèé
èé
è
è
è
è
è
è
é
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
c
Cutset
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
é
é
é
é
é
é
éèéè
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ëêëê
è
è
è
è
è
è
è
éè
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ë
èéèé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
é
é
é
é
é
é
é
éèéè
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
êë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ë
ëê
è
è
è
è
è
è
è
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ê
ë
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
èé
éè
ê êë të
ê ë
ê ë
ê ë
ê ë
ê ë
ê ëêëê
ë
è é
è é
è é
è é
è é
è é
è é
è éèéè i
é
e
]%
+E_"=, . +4+EQ
1'[5 . +T5…3+!+
G . - A8;ÔH"4 L HE
"4H%
"" - ]15 "" - U"4$ . 3 - . )g23A+; . & - ++23%
AH . +Z), . ]D)+1"4&"=$VA+ . 5+ . ;"=,1) .- . E
4" . A1Y" L ]Ag351
5[" .. ++
!8UI?A]$O"4
"]6CD - 23g3T"4
?
)$O"),H"%[email protected]["[email protected]
< L ,1;H3
"4%"=,1? . 4,1[+H
L F51 $6" . . !"5 . 6
6
2!"4 - ,1
"%=8
Úgµ±)¼ƒÙ ‘V" . 4/4+(+51=Jí "4$H
. + < 51+
$w!i3)!+,+
"%)3
1
1í,3ATAH3GA["%, . +\15'#1"5\ . X" - E
- "4 - . T"48Xui+
+CJT!"[email protected]+)
$O!)\,1+ ,%4K5#
Prät28
Úgµ±)¼ Þ ÔH"4 - ,^Fzy)ˆzÎopn4jî$6" . 3A[5%@6XTA1]+,8
I?A+51%02'a"=$^3*+54X
- !…A16
3W
"414+
- ATA . "4,%[email protected]%8g‘" . 51%íC$ . "%b1"5CïH"Xð < A
51%C2'6?
- !
‰  Š
1 šGòó]. -. +)TA1\T
"%%+ - Aƒ$ . "4ùA
"=, . +^1"5["ïJ5NÑ@÷ šòø GA1^3
"4%+ - A
$ . "4çðW"[A1C
1'"58
Úgµ±)¼bú Ôg"= - ,0A1ijÍ%‡B†‚opz‡Xzx1mCzy%ˆz(Îopn4jîJ$O" . 514í8
I?A+"% - 6+)^+51=23'…^
- !…A10
WD
E
^,1Ë"%$HA +51= T3'"%$?6‚5%+?
#A +,+]D - ?í8
Úgµ±)¼Nû ÔH"4 - , A -. " L L 6
K!TAH3]A1 +54 K'"%$í
G
!#K . 4 . AH
C+"4 - +)+51%^K'g8?I?A
?TA1 . h! -. " L L K!"%$í8
I?A . "%6 L +A1
5\A1( L "/4(3
=" . A1ç
G . 4A)$w" . E
. 58`}W/% . ! - "=6)&
-1. "++& - [email protected]%
? . - A
GAg3 - "4 < "i3
H;^1+5T"(5"G"“5AX"= . E
6
K! -1. " L L 2!a"4$X6 - AXAH - 3^A . "=,1%AaA154
"4$B) . 8}@/4 . ! - Av"=$A(
i . - A7%")XA . "=,14A
-. +++
!"%05140"=$;A1[,+8[‘1" . A1
J+5%" L 0 . E
)3 < A1^zxÎ3z‡XãopzGopÍ%xˆzÎm†n%m_Ì@A . "%,%AX6B‰wK8 8 < &514]2'UŠ
^,1 L J2 . % . Ag373
gAJ"4A1 . +54JK'8&IBA),AJ"4E
)3
6+5FmQlOˆÌ%m_x1zÎÎg†`kKÍ4ã3n%ãlwo lOmQqW"=$~A1]3
D
X,•"4$~A
51%;23'5[+"= - +[)+51=;K3'J=/4+,1A; . 6h!
-. " L L K!"%$`A1+51=8gI?A1
;+A1
Z),1G6+V3)
!0"/% . +"=
-. +/
"4,1 -1. " L +;]
AAg35
6X"=$‚" .. +K
"[email protected], . 1J . E
6
K!i3
!)
8Y9"W+/% .< A1
-1. " L L 2!
g5"+?1"4?+
,UA"aA - . [+ . 6Y!)+
5 "%$)A1YA1 - g
- ++5 L !3AH4E
0AJ5+TT!3Ag . + . "=$B\+54 "%$gA1 0 . - A
‰ L !
>
1" . L ,1R~ . < $O" . +D` - Š8
4.
YIELD GRADIENTS
')(+*-,
/
¬?­O®~¯g°± Þ ³ ´°=­wµ­O¶%·1¸Q­Qµ¹F¼H°ºVÄ·ÄH­O¸Q­Oµ¹F¶)ºVÂ*¼H¯gµ+·1µ­Oº1¾aÄ`¹Fµ+½H±
¶)¯gµ+Á±µ[Â*±µ+½Hº`ìHÅ
šGòóVôõ`ö ÑF÷ šGòø
.
'32435$687
Input cone of edge e Edge e of interestOutput cone of edge e
}W54]T3'#ñ
JH "H # !K
É@, . 4"~W
^"\“15*A0 . 5J"=$;A1 - . 3 . 0!
+
5*"=$
AA - "*3
Y+"% - "41+) "%$WA[51+2!F"4$JJ%
+54"=$
A\
* . - A8:I]A -. " L Ç L \51
/)55v6)"iKW"
- . =8ËÉ@F;F'1"eA1F3
T3'v"%$ TA3A - 3
#5 . L ,"4 < A1 - . . F!)6+
5N
3
!7+D -. +5ƒ
0
1
L MNCJ ýOPRQS
JQ T& UQV# &W
X ÿ=Yý0ÿ`ý ZA\[ ]Z
?
] T! "]M# !^
üJý=þVÿ ý
! "$# &%
¬B­Q®1¯H°±Fú~³`#
_ ±°­ ß ·1µ+­Oº~¾:ºV»B¹U­O±¸O샮V°=·ìH­O±¾‚µÁÅ
. 0"=$GTAPÔ?W‘”"=$GA\
?K'U8˜"a
[email protected]#"=,1
5
"423TA51 - +5+1"4$WA1
&2'"4…A152T!
"4$HH
4
@+54 < @W+"4,
5X56R1 . +)23WAH . K"=XK"" L 3
A1G1++ . !!)+
5# . 51
+8
b…8(‘
~8‚—…=
/%+^,1#[+"4E
a X,X$w")+,1^"%Ž[4+54c
/4+)X L . +
"4\$6" . A1 5 . /16"=8gf2#A1 “%, . <› . - E
b 5+"4 -. CA
. ++)CA[+"= - +[+G2'F"4$&+51=d
++ L G"%[email protected]
- 3KA1;"%$`A1 . - [email protected]"^1"4 - ;A . "4,4A
b…8ƒI?A17 .. /1B
f
e TA1F$ . "=E_"5F"%$C+54f
b . - E
. ++) A51KT!F"%$&A1X+ L 6X"%$ - A $ . "%dA"4, . +
1")5"F5%c
b8P[K . ! < TA . +Z,1 . +5˜ .. /;
c
gç"4$
A1X"4E_"5["[email protected]+54h
b . -1. +)CA[+‚
/%X"4$WA52T!
"4$`A++ L "=$ - [email protected]$ . "=S514
bS"JA
1'X"58UI?A
- AP"4, . +iE e +E bjE gCE']AC++ L "4$? - A?"=$HA
. - APAg3 - XA . "4,4G
A b…8#I?A),1\ - A1X"4$?A
. - AAT/4+"% - ,
! L ++ - @
"[email protected]" L ,3'=+3
k^A1"4
A - A . "4,4l
A b 35*TA"4AHJ5"#1"48[„…0AT/=0"=E
23+5A? - W"=$`A?+51=m
bS"40KA1?3T
31K'^"%$~A
A1 - 8
Ó D) < W # . A1 K6U23'"4$HA 3A - 3?A
4A#"4$gA1 "44+ - A##‘
‚8)—
ÔHA - 23'<nUoƒñ*D`‰ ›<p
e
ô
bËÑgŠ
‰T%Š
?A . …)AN"%$ ›< e < b 35qgÈD -. +5N
N“ . EQ" . 5 .
3"%6)Y$O" . A1"]i…A1X“1=, . 8JI]A1[4" L 3
!F+" .. E
23+5 -. "++?/ . 2 L +X . . -. +T5 L ! . 15"%Ê/ . K L Æ ó p ï^ñ  p  prSrSrsp+t 5a5 - +15)
! . 315"% / . 23
"4 L !
Æ u pf
f
Æ v p
Æ w”15iÆx8 fKC
/4 . !F - " . ) "1"=AH ›
51")]"%W51 - 15"%A151+2T!0"4$`A1+51=G"%$`
. +;+6
. -. +) A11+ L 0"4$ - 3KA1 Ay%Íx1Í)m†n%ÎÎ?A . "4,4A
b…8 2 . ! < e 3f
5 g 51"0"45 - 15F"4FAJ51+2T!#"%$514
bd+XA+! . -1. ++BA1J51K!#"=$YA^
"%4+ - 3TA
FA
$1
P+"%*57$1"%,["41"4m
$ b <g. - ++
/%!)8I]A . +$O" . <
@P5RV . +)Ki‰4Š]"F" L 3
PTA1 . 51
+^"4$]A1A1 K'…K"\A[+"% - "=1+) "%)
$ b…8^I]A1 . +C6 - !ƒ6= L . =8
IH"0 . )5 L 2!("=$YTA1
- - .< A1 5R~ . )K"=F"4$
A1JD#" - . 3T" . L !#,
1…ÔH2 . s
' y G$w" . X,Tr– <  tgAH3 L ++
"/%+5["Cu -- +15
DXu[8U’G
TA1]$O" . X,23Y[A1]u -1- +5D <
!
+
5\ . 35+)X . 51 . /4+5 L +
"Ž(KW"51
R~ . )?++H . "48
4.1 Performance maximization at a given yield
I?A6,g3T"4ƒu0fÔgE_
'4FNAHWv3,1[v . +Z, . +5
!
+
5…AH L ++ - ++“5 < [email protected]^+'#"+"4 - ,XAXDE
X, - . $w" . +‰w+
"3'$ . Z,+! < " .< Z),
/1
! < 2'gŠ
B?A1
AFTA1JA1 - 3\=$O+
! L ^" - . [email protected],1[^AHBA
z < J+"=13)8?I?AX"4%G51E
. +Z, . +5 - . [ . 6^!
+65F{
2!("4$YAX
1 . - AFF‘
‚8—
0C
HZ,H3)
2G
! o
?A6A#W3,CA^#/3
,1}|~J15P?315g . 5(5+/
E
"=…€
Ï U8;I?A1+FAX" .. + - "%51
1 - . [ . 6^
"44+ - A
5+2!^AW[+WA?!)6+
5 . +Z, . +)
z &51+"4+5 L ! |~‰Tz~Š8
[email protected]
. A1&/1,W"4
$ o < KA1 L T . 8`I]A - . . W51+2T!
?A6A#[++?A1 . Z), . ++] L +D -1. 5P3
¡
|~T‰ z~ŠYU
ñ ‚ƒ T‰ zVŠOÏ  ô | ~ p
‰–=Š
¡
?A . d
‚ ƒ ‰ŠU
;AG)/4 . 0Ô]&‘*"[email protected]?15H . 51" . F28gI?A
Z,H
"%i - !!)JAg3 A . Z, . +5a!)+
5a L . 1E
K5\6)"… . Z), . +5F),1 L . "%$4"%#A1 "41=+ - A
5+2!F5
. L ,1
"4H8#É@, . %"~Y1" "(" L iA[ . 51
+
"43
$ |~T‰ z~Š@]
A . + - ++ " õ ~ <Uõ ó p ïJñ  p  pSrrr„p+t 15 †
õ … 8XI?A
]3
!i++"4 - A1+5 L !
- !5
R~ . +2‰–=Šg?A . +E
- ]"3A#"=$HA1+ Z,g3)
68
‡ ~| ‰Tz1Š U
‡ Ï 
¡
‡ õ ó ñ ‚ˆƒ ‰Tz~Š ‡ õ ó
[email protected]@" - " L 3
+57$ .
‰–à~Š < ‰–  Š <
ô
‡ | ~ ï@ñPà 
p p rSrSrsp+tp+‰
Š
‡ õ óp
. 25 . /16/=+H"%JA . 4AHAg35X
51C . . 51
!
"% A1 L "=D)5:+Z),H
"%[vA#u -- 151
DŽ‰—‚Š <
‰–4–4Š < ‰–=€4Š?5P‰–44Š8
4.2 Yield maximization at a given performance
Š
ñ

¢
Ï 

ï@ñPà
‘
~
 ’G”
“
p  pSrrSr„pjt3p+‰ZŠ
ò
Ï
Ñ|
Ñ@Ï
 ‡‡ | ~
õ~ó
ô
‰ò
Ñ|
~ Š ‡ ‡ Ï  ‰€=p Š
õVó–•
u
A"%,4AFTAJ$O" . ^,12 . J+4A)! < A!* . J
!(+")51+5
$w" . +
+X/1,H
"%P"=˜0"4 - ,1 . 8#f2P . ["=$? - +E
[+
"% < ]A1+a . )3
6h! -. " L L 6
K!^"4 - ,1+5i$O" . 51% < W3
3D)6^,•" - . "4X
- . $w" . 5 L [email protected]++
&+54B23'#350"4 - ) . !X+51=BK'U8Uu]&AH3 - "%
<
A^ L "/4?$w" . X,TC
6"v,&" +"4 - ,1]!
+
5 . 51
+&]A
. - +]"5/
51,g3`+51= 52T!8
5.
APPLICATIONS OF YIELD GRADIENTS
É@ 6[+5T# -1- 6
T6"=\"%$H!
+5\ . 5+)BB
7G$O" . 3
. " . E_>+
1[" - >"4(+"4TD)],3A*}—=˜ ™Mšœ›=M™
žŸ@r —4tK8
u - "% L B$6" . ^,123
"40"=$~A1?" - >3
"4 -. " L 6+ "/4 . A
- 3+ "=$H . 6" . ]5A1`
X?$w"%
"]48
D¡
Š Š
Š Š
- . [+ . 6]!
+5hzV‰ ò Š
- . $6" . 1+ . Z), . + ò
. p +•15"=A1 . "4 . )
Š
Š Š
Š Š
‰w—VŠ
I?A6T,6"=N
. " -1. ")+" . E_
6'=FƒAH3Wv,[v
. 4+$ . +Z),+1+!vA L +M - ++
“1+5b15MWƒ . … . !)
vK"
F3D)6[>GA1!)
5"%$`A1 - ;Ag3WB
&A1
+/%TA1
]$ . +Z,+!8
u,1GTA;A1 . [email protected]$ . +Z),11+!0 . 123+;)"F . +Z,1 . +5
"44+ - A51+2T!0"%$ ò " . +=8gf2(TA1
] < "%, .]- . + . !
+q
5 za
- !7TA1 -. " L L 2!7A0A1F
"44 - I
A o
AHG/V,JAB ò " . [email protected]]A^!
+5\A . +$O" . zV‰ ò Š;ñ
‚<‹=‰ ò f
Ñ |~Š Œ3Ï Ž 8UI]A
H6 - @+Z),H
"%J3 L W51
R~ . +TK+5
?
A#KA1CA+ - "4$gAC$w" . ^,123]
#A -- 5
D"X" L (A
+++ . !(!)
5# . 51
+
‡ ~z ‰ ò
‡ õ~ó
É@$?"4, . < 3AH1=6ƒ0 . " . >+(]6
;2! - !aA14
A105+K!…"4$?J,1
- 05%+^"4$]A1
1F . - A˜^@
$1
a+5%+ 5,1K"\
"‚5#+R~+35a$"%,C+5%+ 51,"
+ƒ+R1+8UuG
V"=$‚A+?6
/
@ L BA6E . ,1
+5…15
1+,51+5(6* . 4A$w" . . 5# . 8
I]A1]" L ‹6+T/4]$6,11"=["=,1
5[! L ]A4+5X$ . "4 - . E
+ . X!
+5"(†~kKÍ ¢[email protected]‰w" . !#"4A1 . )+ . [3, . ^"%$&A
51
. L ,
"%P"%$?A13A - 23'UŠB
7A(("%$X0" . +5æ15
- +5E L +5…3A - 8(" . 1(
- CAC51
R~ . ) . 34+ "4$
- +5 L . 1BX5R~ . +?"4,"4$ -. "=“18UI]A;!)
5X"=$1A
$ | ~ 5X
Ï ? L "/%G35^A+
L J3 L W+D -1. 5^
J . g"[email protected]
A1[@+4A+5…,È"=$;TA1 -1. "4“ "=/= . 3
L J56R1 . +)T+5
"" L #A 1++ . ! . 51
+8
uå"415 - "4 L $w" . X,T
"%#
?A1"? L +
"^8
‰=Š
f2AG < @^1+5…" -. "/)5X"A^1"=1
. " - 6> .
^)33Aa . "4*A0!
+5Ž^A . Z),1 . +5 - . $O" . + ò^<
5FAJ . 5?"%$Ag3?!
+65#]6A . - ++B"…g . K" .
>++=8 IBA#$O" . X,K
"%Ž“\W+C?A
ËF . K" . EQ6/4
,1
1(+"4+D) +A1[ . 5
) "[email protected]!)
5i?
A . - +
"(3051%B5TT![)3 L A6E . ,1
+5]
AAB . 5
+W"%$‚A
51% 5+K!?
A . + - +B"[A 5
/
5,` . 36" . B
5A=8
I?A23 . "% - ,1"4 < L !FAF35‹O"=6)C[TA1"5 < 3 . 35!
- . ["%$GA\ . 3" . >6*$w" . X,23
"4ƒ,+5 -1. +)
!8
¡
5+2!|~‰Tz~Š
. Z, . +5!)+
5hz
. p +•5"4A . +"=1 . 3
)
Š
‰Ts%Š
fKJA$6" . ^,123
"4 < . +Z, . +5J!
5^H - +6“5 < [email protected]++5
" -. "/)65"#A"41
) . " - 6[> . 3A… . "%…A
$+ - . $O" . +A L 3A/=+5ƒ315…A[ . 5
"4$KA - . $6" . 1+ ]TA . + - +?"
` . 3
" . ?
51TA8
}&/4\
FTA^"4+D?"4$Y5 . +J" - >
"% < !)
5\ . 5
E
+C L X,1+5…" . 1'\" . 5 .C- " . "41 "=$WA[+ . +,GAH3
"=W5…3T+
"%0
" . 5 . "J6 . GTA!
+50"%$‚A+ . E
+,G"(TA[++ . !#/1, < " . K"( . )[A - . $O" . +
( . +Z,1 . +5a!)+
58^90T/#Z,g3)
3
/40 . 5+)J]
6Y51E
. aAa4,[email protected]" . '•15Ž . !)E_+/3
,+E_,51"v
")" - AH3(
+"%["4\ - A!)
U!)A
B51, . 6023 1" .. ++"4
5# . !EQ"5 - 5151
~8
uB6A"%,%AaA…+,[email protected]" - >3
"=Ž -- "4^5+ . L +5
\A1
?+T"4#AH/4 "4 L ++\
- +++5 < A3,A1" . B$w+
AG!
+5… . 5)?H+H L - "@ . $w,H1” T!C"4$&" - E
>
1 . ,1
?#TA1 -. ++1 "4$H/ . 2 L 6
K!)8
6. CONCLUSIONS
I?
1[6"=, . C
#KA1 -. ++1C"4$H/ . T L 6h! - ]+
"4, . . "=FA1i) . . +6/1 -1. "++F - + < ]A1
3Aæ
v˜+DE
. +6!\Ag3
%
1'U8I . 35
"4H5123=1"=6+015E
. '=\ . - 3A…15v51+ . 1
6(
6aK')… . 51+Z,J$O" . A^" - [6>
"%F'U8;I]A1
- - . 5 . L #"=/=+GA"5ƒ$w" . +"4 - , - . + . F!)65ƒ . 356)
, . 3!F150[+
+! < 15 -. " - "4;/ . "4,1C -- 6)
"%
A](3'451/4C"%$H!)+
5# . 51
+8
7. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I?AN,A" . (;"4,
5˜
'4…":Ag3'•3
+ L . ("%$JA1…+DE
+55fŒ]£—s˜ ™
š¥¤@¦+§?¦35G¨©-¤C$O" . ,1$O,1H5
,
"%
5#"4$w2J . , -- " . 8
8.
REFERENCES
r tC9[8UÔgAH33578`18`
- ' . 8`
K6U
!
?+"%1
5 . 1 - K`+" .. +2"4?,F4
|~}C1I?EQ
'4 . T/% . T8sª¥«€««¬ªTx1mQzkx1n4mQlOÍ%x1n)o)­UÍ)xV®zkKzxj3zXÍ%x
­UÍ)‡]s† ¯mQzk °j±]lOy%zc
y ²GzÎlwˆx <%- 4+X4  k‚=4€ < Ó "/4 L .
à4à‚–=8Ul
³"= < Ôgu8
r
3t{´8`ÔHA" -. < 8UAA < u[8` . /3T/V < C8‚Œg2%,) < 5
8U!)6/=+ . 8‚|& . . 6 !)
5#D)[6>
"%#,~
>+ L +5("4\+
+]
T6) - "@ . 35\52T!
. 51
)?+"= - ,3T"4H„
8 ª¥«€«€«¬ªTxVmQzkxn%m_lwÍ%xn)3
o ­gÍ4?
x ®zk2zx1jz
Í%\
x ­gÍ4‡B=
† ¯m_zk °j±]lOy%zc
y ²GzÎlOˆx <)- %+  à~4– k  à‚=ä <
³"4 < ÔHu08
Ó "/%+ L . 3à4à~€48`1µ

r–t0Ô]8}G8UÔH2 . '`8)I]A1 . 3+?"4$]“16G]"%$ . 51"=
/1 . T L +=8)¶~†zkKn)mQlOÍ4x1Î{·&zÎz3n%k2jÌ <- 3=+  —~€k  % <
F . 3AE_u -. M
 ¸   8
r —4tGu8`8`Ôg"% < f8‚8}&
$5+ < „•8„ 8`["%
>++ < ³ . 8 < |‚8U?8
É y6Œ . 6+ < |`8 Ó 8` . +1' < Ô?M
{
8 ¹G
@J . KA < 15PÔ]8`Œ]8
„NAHHs
8 º . 51
+E L +5#" - >
"%("4$H,1"%Ê . +,
,
1B
EQ
6$O" . X,23T"4s
8 »&kKÍV
j ¼½M¾M¾M¾c²GzÎlwˆx
±-¯mQÍ)‡^n)mQlOÍ%\
x ­gÍ4$
x ®zkTzxj3z <)- 34+?—‚€= k%—V€ ¸ < ³3,1 Z
 ¸$¸M¸ 8
Ó +ËÉ . < a u08
r€t0Œ;8U&")51
75P8}W
%A . L !8%u --. "D)
1[A
. 6h!651
+?"4$gA13/
+?6*|‚}G1I˜[email protected]" . ')=8
¿ n%x1n4ˆz‡^zx1m À1jlOzxjz < –  ‰%Šœ
à‚s k~%=– < ‘ L . ,H . ! M ¸ ä%€48
rˆ
t Á8 a < ³48 a < F8`ÔH+
6' < 5 a 8IX8`|‚
+4%28`&“1
1
)3‚1
/
2!$w" . T
1" - >3
"4#"4$H"4=6
+ . +,1
??A(2 . 4+E_ -. ")++X5#+/) . "%+
/1 . T
"%=s
8 ª¥«€««¬ªTxm_zkx1n4mQlOÍ%x1n43
o ­gÍ)V
x ®zkTzxj3z^Í)x
­gÍ%‡B=† ¯mQzk °+±?lwy4z3Â
y ²GzÎlwˆx <- 34[ä—4Z
— k~ä4€  < Ó "/=+ L .
à%àV€48`1l
³3"4 < Ôgu08
rst0Ô]
8 ¹@+ . 23A < ´8U?/)65 . < ´
8 ´K$K < 1=
8 ºJ8
„N3
'= .< 15P8 Ó . !~H8)‘ . EQ" . 5 . . +)3
8 »WkTÍj ¼ÃMÄ
ÄZÅ
L ")3'E L +5#
U
1F!)
s
²GzÎlOˆf
x ±-¯mQÍ)‡Xn)mQlOÍ4\
x ­gÍ%$
x ®zkKzx1jz <- 34[–4–  k~–4–% < ³3,1
à%à=—~8`1P&+4" < ÔHu08
räh
t ³%
8 Á
"41 < ¹„
8 Æ)"4"4"/ < Ô]
8 ¹@+ . 2A < 15
8 ¹Y'1+ . H8UÔ . 3
K!+"% - ,
"%#
Ó 8 »Wk2Í?
j ¼ÃMÄZÄMǵÈN±ÊÉ
- . + . >++5(3
6)`[6‚s
Ë ±Ê­ ¿ÊÌ ªœ««€«qÍYÍ%k3îÎÌ4͆aÍ)xFm_l6‡[lwxˆ[lO΍Π¯zÎClwxmQÌ)z
ÎQ†zjl ¢Hjn4mhl6Í%xn%x1yÎq4xmQÌ%zÎlwÎGÍ ®y%lwˆl6mhn4oUÎqÎ3mQz‡^iÎ Î < ‘V L . ,g . !
à%àV48`1l
³3"4 < Ôgu < , L T5#$6" .]. /)
^8
"% $ . Z,)
!Eh,5#Z,g3
"4X . 65 L +"^8
¢

‰‰ ×
Š n
í ÚÛz~‰Ñ ‰ Š
Ø C Ù


‚]‰ ‰ ×
Š n
‡
‰
‡ ‰
‰
‡ ]
‚ ‰‰
‡ ‰
Š
‰T1
Þ Šõ Þ
ƒ¢ Ý  ¢
¡¥á¢
‰OÏ Ñ ô Ï u Ñ7 Ô Õ$Ö ‰ š`p2› ŠŠ
¢

Ñ ‰
í?Ú@~
z
‰Ñ ‰ ŠYñæÑ ‰ ‰ ‰
Ø Ù


ñ
Š
…
Ü
ßàn
‰  –%Š
‰  —‚Š
‰  €%Š
Š
‰  %Š
‰ Š
 ‰ Š
ñ
‰  %
s Š
a oƒñ*3D`‰ šhph› Š8gI?A #"4$moP6?4
/% L !
Ò~
Ï ~ ÑfÒ ~
Ï ~ ÑfÒ ~
| ~ ñ ‚]‰ Ï ~ Ñ<
ß ŠTÏ ~ ôã⠝ ÑG‚]‰ ß ŠjäÒ ~ ô ß  ‰ ß Š
ñ
‚Ï=~ ô ‰  Ñ\‚]ŠTÒ$~ ô ß Š
‰  ä%Š

‘V" . - 62! < @CAg/4C,+5µM
‚ 15 " . -. +å‚]‰æ¥ç ƒsé è ç Š

5
‰ æ ç ƒsè ç Š8YI]A1
"46"=\]6
L ,1+5\?A . +/4 . A . J
é
1"F  L 4,2!8
I]A1 / . T1+ "=$m7
o ¢
¢
¢
¢
¢
Ï  ñŽ‰OÏ Ñ ô Ï ~ Š¥‚ ô ‰OÏ u ô Ò ~ Š‰  Ñê]
‚ Š ô ‰TÏ ~ ô Ò ~ ŠTß Ñ| ~ ¢ Š ‰ Z¸ Š

„a# . ^
. ++5
FA1^+1T/)6h!\"=$| ~ 35iÏ  "A`Ï óh<
Ò ó < Ï … 5ÂÒ Y… - . + . =8;Œ`+,B"4$~A1?!+ . ! L [email protected]++
š 5 ›(< @ ]`"4
!$w"),?"%(A 5 . /V"4#"4$1
6/)
2!
?
A . + - +]"dÏs~ < Ï ó 15êÏ … 8
A.2 Sensitivity of mean
A.2.1
APPENDIX
A.
DIFFERENTIATION OF THE STATISTICAL MAXIMUM OPERATOR
I?A6(u -- +5
DN51 . /%\$w" . ^,T\$w" . 51
R~ . +TK
"%Ž"=$XA
UD(" - . " . B
A . + - +]"
X . 4,+)8
a
A.1
+ š
‡ |~
‡ Ï ~
‡ ß
‡ Ï ~
‡ ‚
‡ Ï ~
‡
‡ ϐ~
L CKW"“ . E_" . 51 . 1"4
`$w" . ñ
š
›
ñ
Ï ~ ô\Ð
Ò ~ ôÓÐ
Ï
Ï … Æ<Ñ p
Ò …Æ u p
Ò
óÆ ó ô
ó Æ óVô
?A . Æ ó . FAF" .. +K+5:,1ECº ,12 . 151"=
"4 < Æ Ñ 15aÆ u . 0,1+" .. K+5a,1
EºJ,T
/1 . 23
"=1 < Ï ó 35lÒ ó . 0+6K6/)T+J"\+" .. 2+5
/1 . 23
"=1 < 15ÊÏ … 5Ò … . @[email protected]
/
+H"B,11"
. 5"4È/1 . 23
"4 <U. + - ++/4!8I]A0/1 . K1+0"4$ š
5\A+ . +"/1 . T1+ . Ñ
Ï
Ï
ÔÕ?Ö ‰ šhp2›
u
¢
Ï
Ð
ñ
¢
Š
¢
ñ
Ð
ñ
Ð
Ò
¢
ó ô
ó ô
Ï ó Ò ó+Š
¢
Ï …p
Ò …¢ p
‰ä=Š
‰ ¸ Š
/ . 2E
. 5"4
. 5"4
.. +K+5
35 ›
‡ ‚
‡ Ï ~ φ~
ñ
‚aÑ ‡ ‡ Ï ‚ ~ ÒZ~
ô
‡ ß
‡ Ï ~ 
ô
ô
ß ‡‡ Ï  ~ Š
‰à‚Š
fK]
?3!"A"˜AH?A $w"%
"]+Z,"4?A1"=65g8
Preliminaries
35 ›
With respect to mean
„aG“ . ?5 . /= A1C+
/
K!"%$|
~;?
A . - +]"hÏ=~8
ñ
à
p
‰  Š
Ï ~ Ñ<Ò ~ Š  ñ
ß
ß
ß  p 15

Ï ~ ÑfÒ ~ ‰ Ï ~ ÑÒ ~ Š 
Ñ
ß 
ß
ß
ñ
‰
ñ
‰4%Š
Ï ~ ÑfÒ ~
ß ¢  Š
ñ˜Ñ
‰4–%Š
I]A1 . + $O" . < ;GAT/%
‡ |~
‡ Ï ~
A.2.2
‰Tφ[email protected]ÑfÒ$~Š
ñ
ߐ
ô
‚aÑ Ï ~ ß Ñf¢ Ò ~ ß ñ"‚ Š

‰3—~Š
With respect to correlated sensitivity
Ó D) < ;…5 . 6/=iA1
/
2!ƒ"%$Ê|
+" .. KT5#+6K6/)2!T . ëÏ ó 8
‡ |~
‡ Ï ó
ñ
‡ ‚
‡ Ï óÏ ~
Ñ
‡ ‚
‡ Ï óÒ~
ô
~
]TA
‡ ß
‡ Ï ó
ô
. + - +#"7A
ß ‡‡ Ï  Š
ó
‰4€%Š
fK]
?3!"A"˜AH?A $w"%
"]+Z,"4?A1"=65g8
‰  àVŠ
‰ % Š
‰  =Š
‡ ‚
‡ Ï ó
‡
‡ ϐ ó
ñ
ñ
‡ ‰ æ ç ƒsé è ç Š
Ï ~ Ñ<Ò ~ ‡ ß 35
ñ˜Ñ
 ‡ Ï ó
 ß ¢ ‡ Ï óp
Ï ~ ÑÒ ~ ‡ ‰ æ ç ƒ=é è ç Š ñ ‰TÏ ~ ÑÒ ~ Š ¢ ‡ ß
Ñ
ß  ‡ Ï ó
Ûß ì
 ‡ Ï óŠ
‰4%Š
‰4s%Š
I?A . $w" . < W AH/4
‡ |~
‡ Ï ó
Ï ~ ÑÒ ~ ‡ ß ‰TÏ ~ Ñ<Ò ~ Š ‡ ß
‰TÏ ~ ÑÒ ~
ô ‡ Ï
ô ß
ß ì
 ß ¢ ‡ Ï¢ ó
ó 
¢
‡
‰TÏ ~ ÑfÒ ~ Š
‰TÏ ~ ÑfÒ ~ Š
ß
ñ
ô  ô ß
” Ñ
ß ¢
ß ì
•  ‡ Ï ó
‡
ß
ñ
 ‡ Ï óŠ
„iC1+5\T""= - ,ãí é < ]A
3A(6?4
/% L !
í æî
¢
‡ ß ñ ‡ ‰OÏ Ñ ô Ï u¢ Ñ7 ÔÕ?Ö ‰ šdpK› ŠŠ ¡œá¢
‡ Ï ó
‡ Ï ó
¢
¢
 ‡ ‰OÏ Ñ ô Ï u Ñv ÔÕ?Ö ‰ šhp2› ŠŠ
ñ
‡ Ï ó
ß
¢
¢
‡
‡
‡ ÔÕZÖ ‰ šhp2› Š
Ï Ñ
Ï u

ñ
ô
‡ Ï ó Ñv
‡ Ï ó
ß ” ‡ Ï ó
•

ñ
‰Ï ó ô àXÑ7CÒ ó Š
ß
ñ
Ñ

‰TÏ ó ÑÒ ó Š
ñ
Š
¢
ß Š
‡ ß
 ‡ Ï
A.3.2
ó
ñ
ñ
A.2.3
¸
Š
‰–3à~Š
With respect to uncorrelated sensitivity
~
Π!v
2 . 1 - ,K
"% < KA1\+
/
K!P"%$ˆ|
`
- ]"A1C,1+" .. +K+5(1
/
2! . PÏ … ‡ |~
‡ Ï …
A.3
Ï … ߐ Š
ñ
]A
ñ
. +E
‰–  Š
‡ Ï 
‡ Ï ó
ñ
ñ
ñ
‡ Ï 
‡ Ï=~
‘ ‡ Ï Ñ ¢ ‡ Ï ~¢
¢
¢ ‡ ‚
¢
¢ ‡ ‚
‡ Ï ~ ô ‡ Ï ~ ’ ‚ ô ‰wÏ Ñ ô Ï ~ Š ‡ Ï ~ ÑP‰OÏ u ô Ò ~ Š ‡ Ï ~
‰Tφ~ ô $
Ò ~Š ‡ ‡ Ï ß ~ ô ‰Tφ~ ô ZÒ ~+ŠTß ‡ ‡ Ï  ~ Ñv|
~ ‡‡ Ï| ~ ~
ô ß
 ô

¢
¢
¢
¢
Ï ~ ‚ ô ‰OÏ Ñ ô Ï ~ Š  Ñv‰OÏ u ô Ò ~ Š  ô ß
ß
ß

~
~
~
~
~
ÑC‰TÏ ô Ò ŠT1
ß ‰TÏ ÑÒ Š ß  ¢ ÑP| ‚
ñ
~ Ñ | ~ œŠ ‚
%‰TÏ
~ Ñ | ~ œŠ ‚
%‰TÏ
ô
ô
Ñ¢
‰OÏ
‰OÏ
Ñ
¢
Ï ~¢
ô
ÑFÏ
¢
Ñ Ò ~ Š 
u¢ ß
¢
u Š ߐ ô ß Š

Ñ\Ï
¢
Ñ Ò ~ Š 
~¢ f
ß
Ñv‰TÏ
A.3.3
ñ

3Ï
~ Ñ | ~ ¥Š ‚
l” =‰TÏ ô
‰OÏ
Ñ¢
ÑÏ
‡ Ï 
‡ Ï …
ô
ß ì
Ï
u¢
Š
ô
ó
‡ ß Ñv|N~ ‡ | ~
‡ Ï ó
 ‡ Ï ó
¢ Ï ~ ÑfÒ ~
Ò~Š ß ¢
‡ ß
 ‡ Ï ó
¢
¢
Ï u ô Ò ~
ß
~
ÑfÒ
¢
¢ Ï ~ ÑÒ ~
Ï ~¢ Ñ Ò ~ Š
ß ¢
ô
Ï ~
ô
ß
 • Š
ô
u¢
‰OÏ
”
Ñ¢
Ñ\Ï
 â Ï ó ‚aÑf| ~ T‰ Ï ó ÑÒ ó Š ß
ô
Ò~
~ f
Ñ Ò ~
‰TÏ
ô
Š
Ï
Ï ~ Ñ<Ò ~
ß ¢
Š
ô
u¢
ÑFÏ
¢
ß
ô
Ò~
íï ñ
íæî
φ~ ô Ò$~
ô
‰TÏ ó ÑfÒ ó Š
¢
Ñ
‡ ß ‰–—‚Š
•  ‡ Ï óŠ
‡ ß
 ‡ Ï ä
ó
•
‰–=€%Š
 ä
• ß Š
With respect to uncorrelated sensitivity

ñ
Ï
ô
ô
ß

‰–44Š
u ¢ Š ߐ
~
ÑÒ
¢
‡ Ò ~¢ ‰  G
‡ Ï ó ’ Ñ ‚]Š
ÒZ~Š ‡ ‡ Ï ß
ó 
Π!6[2 . 1 - U
, 23T"41 < @J5 . /=JAJ+6T/)2!"%$π
?
A . + - +]"[A , 1+" .. +T+5# . P
Ï … I?A . $w" . < (,1 . ! < W AH/4
‡ Ï
‡ Ï ~
Ï
” Ï ~
Ï€
ñ

ñ
~ 8 í ïCð ñ
í æç
?A . + - +]"hÏ

‡ |~
â Ï ó ‚iÑ|N~ ‡ Ï ó

π
ñ
With respect to mean
„i 5 . 6 /= A +
/
K!"4$HÏ
Ï ~ ÑfÒ ~ ‡ ß
 ß ¢ ‡ Ï
Š
ô
‰TÏs~ ô
ô
I]A1 . + $O" . < A +1
/)2!3 L "4 - ,+5P
Sensitivity of sigma
A.3.1
~¢
Ò$~Š ‡ ‡ Ï ß ô ‰Tφ~ ô ÒZ~ŠTß ‰TÏ ~
ó 
‡
~
|
¢
¢
Ï ó ‚iÑv| ~
‡ Ï ó ô ” ‰Ñ@Ï Ñ ÑÏ ~ ô
¢
¢
‰TÏ ~ ÑÒ ~ Š‰TÏ ~ ÑÒ ~ Š
ô Ï=~ ô Ò$~ ô
ß ¢
•
~
‡
|
¢
¢
Ï ó ‚iÑv| ~
‡ Ï ó ô ” ‰Ñ@Ï Ñ ÑÏ ~ ô
‡ ß
ô Ï=~ ô Ò$~ Ž ‡ Ï
 ó
‡ |~
¢
¢ Ï ~
Ï ó ‚iÑv| ~
‡ Ï ó ô ” ‰OÏ u ÑFÏ Ñ Š
ñ
‘ ‡ Ï u¢
‡ Ï ó
Ï ~¢ Š ‡ ‡ Ï ‚ ô
ó
‡ Ò~ ß
‡ Ï ó’ 
ô ‰TÏ=~ ô
ñ
ߐ
B
A . + - ++g"[email protected]" .. +T+5
íï ð ñ
í æCî
Ï
‰=ä%Š
‰
‰TÏ ó ÑÒ ó Š
ñ

 ‡‡ ÏÏ 
ó
‘ ‡ Ï Ñ ¢ ‡ Ï ~¢
¢
‡ Ï ó ô ‡ Ï ó ’ ‚ ô ‰OÏ Ñ ô
‘ ‡ Ï ~
¢
¢ ‡ ‚
ÑC‰OÏ u ô Ò ~ Š
‡ Ï ó ô ‡ Ï ó ô
‡
‡ |
~
ô ‰TÏ ~ ô Ò ~ ŠTß ‡ Ï  Ñv| ~ ‡ Ï
ó
ó
¢
¢
¢
Ï ó i
‚ Ñv‰OÏ Ñ ô Ï ~ ÑFÏ u Ñ<Ò
ñ
I?A . $w" . < (,1 . ! < W AH/4
‡ |~
‡ Ï ó
With respect to correlated sensitivity
„aW5 . 6 /[email protected]+1
/)6h! 4
" $Ï
/
K! . ë
Ï ó 8H„i AH /4
‰–4–4Š
 â Ï … ‚*Ñ| ~ Ï … ߐ
Ï … ” Ï ~
ô
Ò~
ô
‰–%4Š
‰TÏ
~ <
Ñ Ò ~
Š
Ï
u¢
ÑÏ
ß ¢
Ñ¢
 ä
• ß Š