Paper: PDF

Critical Power Slope: Understanding the Runtime Effects
of Frequency Scaling
Akihiko Miyoshi Charles Lefurgy
Eric Van Hensbergen
Ram Rajamony Raj Rajkumar
Real-Time and Multimedia Systems Lab
Austin Research Laboratory
Dept. of Electrical and Computer Engineering
IBM
Carnegie Mellon University
ABSTRACT
!"#$"&%'()
"
*+
%'"
,-.0/1,2,+)3!%4
5
627+7"
8
9:7";!
$
</(/5"
=/5*0/+>!(?@A52$"
%'("
*+
B"
,0C"B!+
6=D/E!
$!#"
:!2$"
F?;,,-(
G*/BD!(?HI50$"J2
K"
,8ILF(?@6M(NCO+D7"
!(?HA5$"AD
K"
,HD!D"
K5*;"
,0C"AC?H
!%4
5-!2$"
PC
Q
R
SD="T"
,0U,2,
!%4
5V!2$"
8XW>*P!K
(Y
6"
210/(C"
"
,";%4<5$57+7"
N"
,;*!+"
2P;";62DD/Z8
[V1="
=/+*R\?]2!"T(D/_^`a4bcac^#degf+hiHj`1k#ehfj
"
lO+!DQ/-(!"
*+
"
,!(?@)3!%'
5.#,0C#"
7)
"
>%g77"
<?;K"
,R!(?@502$";%4"
*
8B[\Y6K)
*"
1"
,
177"
5)\$#mn"
,+
""
(/SoI$"
*pD!+"
2!qN<
%r
(s$*t(D/uoI(?@#ogvw!D"%4
PNA0/x-6M2K"#21(D/
7+7"
X"
-/7"#C"
5"
,5y"
%F*.!!+
M,q8\W>*+
62D*"
2zY0(/V\!K
(g(*
="
%@"
,.y
7"
"{?@F77"
N20/Y!*KY(62DD;/C"#;%'&"
,G"
,K#/q8}|>
"
(!C?HB!2NZ?@EO+!D1?;,$121"
,EoI$"
*.)3(/
7+7"
PN0">B
1.$">"
*1KR"F"
,Y,,7"B%r
)
s$*$N?;,;2."
,<oI(?@#oHvg)30(/7+7"
PNMK"gDg
.%')
y$"H"
*5C"H"
,<(?@7"@%'
(s$*!2$"(8&[\;y
~2*+
*K"
Y=P(*+
Dl"
,,C6=Y%A5?@Q
6=D:,+)
5C
m8*"
,
NM?@BO+"
0/"
,F
K"
(Z!(?@@D!B)
!"&"
F*0/+
7"#/Y"
,Hy"
}%6MK"#2A>?;,.)
(/?;K"
,%'
s=*(+8&[\g,(?z"
,0C"&@(NMK"
5Y@
$";€hb$"
>
/*@6M2K"#2A(?F"#
!="(8
Categories and Subject Descriptors
vF8 ‚$8 ƒ…„ †Y‡ZˆQ‰&Š}‹Œ+ŽqJ‘‹Œˆ“’ˆQ‰&”'ŒˆQŒ+•Z‹–‹—'‡•J˜š™œ›>#c
vF8 ž1„ ŸFŒ=C 3‡0ˆQ–0•I¡Œ-‡ ŽqJ‘‹ŒˆV‘˜š™
General Terms
9:*
$"(N0oI%'
52N¢B
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for
personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are
not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies
bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific
permission and/or a fee.
ICS’02, June 22-26, 2002, New York, New York, USA.
Copyright 2002 ACM 1-58113-483-5/02/0006 ... £ 5.00.
Keywords
P?AC
Y2!*"
1. INTRODUCTION
\DVDERz
(2Kz!"#="
%4"
*
G%4"
,Y2Dg77"
H„K¤C¥(˜0/
6M&7+7"
(„ ¥=Nž˜š8
9:27";!+
$
F/+2(/5"
=/5D*0/+>!(?@;502$"
%4"
*
N*,TH%'
(s$*.(l„ ‚(˜Z;/=+0A%'
s=*
/6MK"#2R(DS„ ¥ƒ˜š8¦@,1%'("
*+
l!+
C6+D/+1V#,2
%<!+
$1hfj`dbca'€=§:f+ha4€bck#NG?;,#,z(t5*/tz!(?@
5$";
K"
,8
¦@,G!0!H!+
$"
gBC6M+"
,Ds$*@%'A/+"
>"
,
2!#"
1!D$"
Y%<l!
$"
,"Y,*D/€0hbH2D/=)
(/t$tQ!(?H5$"D
K"
,P8x¨=!Ky0($Ng"
,
2!#"
Y!2$"
D/$"
Ky0(/=2*+"
,Ds$*@?;0?@g(2/
"
V
(/+*/n
n.$8u©(?;V"
,1/5%+)
t$"52!#"
Q!2$"
.D!"#$".(*PO+7")
5!(?@>52$"<2
"
,„ ¥ƒ=Nqª+N&¤«+NI¤¬˜!K"
K
*."
,0C"YD(?H!%4
5!="
YC
5
.
-%r)
y0D="Y"
,\,D,!%'
5!2$"
81­<E?H,(?®DC"
(N
"
,A*!+"
D:/+$A";K?@(+A,2D/qN/."
,
FO+D7";(?@
!%'
52!#"
!D$"
@"
,"F
"<
T$"(8
I2*+
T¤0/V¥lD*7"#"
"
,mM-2!+"%;V
=)
D=">2!#C"
T!2$"(8B¯H"
,1y02*+
B/+!"<"
,E2!#"
2
%}7+7"
~?;,5K"@O+*+"
g"
,Ekd°jGM/5?;K"
,D"
,Ekd°j
!
=/R%H"
Y±BC"Y/K²Z
=">2!#C"
:!="
8Y³{-ID*
:¤N
"
,7+7"
´!#"
YC"Yl(?µ!%'
5¶M!C?HY=/E%4
"
,1="
K
R/+*#"
S/x2*5
x·;¸¹7º4»D¼½#¾¿ À#Ág8…³Â
I2*+
Y¥=N+"
,F77"
®2!#C"
<"<E,2,T!%4
5¶$!(?H
=/T0/\!"
Y"
,Ã7tDt1,"
.2*$"%;"
D8
¢B*+
D:"
,."
"
,"Y"
,!+
$.O*"
l"
,.?@
m$)
M/qN0"
,77"
Ä2*;
:·<¸¹7º4»D¼½¾Å(»DÆÅ8A­;%'"
F2.)
!"
-"
,EÃÂ2JNg"
,T7+7"
Ç$.$"
VD/l7"#"
2NG?;,
K"B*F
R·F»È¿K½¾ZÅ(»ÆÅ8>¦@,Y"
"#I
1*(/
n"
,(P·<¸¹7º4»D¼½¾Å(»DÆÅɜ·F»È¿K½¾ZÅ(»ÆÅ8n"
,D77"
PN
"
,
:.$"F!#"
1!2$">/+!/A2l"
,B
D"
6M
6*;%·<¸¹7º4»D¼½¾0¿ À#Áz0/l·<¸¹7º4»D¼½¾Å(»DÆÅFÉt·<»DÈ¿K½¾ZÅ(»ÆÅ8
W>Y(RD$mR"F"
,BM/-B0/+D6=D/*}"#m=>1"
,E2+)
"
O="%>
()š"
:7+7"
?;,
T±
!+
$"
5R!
=/q8³Â
6M.7+7"
N&±E
!20/+"
1"
,5"
"
R
!20/V"
-
(s$*7"?;K"
,z"
,T
6M(8zvH*7"
5¨=
6=D:Êq6MA­<
)
$"
Ë>M¨-
(s$*K
$"
!rT:!#"
(g*!!Y2*0/
2±8…¦@,
%4
RK"T:!!
!
D"
P"
Q"
,mt%±.lV%r")
/2/E1
6M>7+7"
>F?H3„ Ì=NG¤«˜š8B¨+Y7">!(?@
5$"Y"
,Ds$*YO+!DK""
,%4""
,0"E"
,5M/zD.)
Í<—rΊ}CŒ\Ï0ЎqJ‘‹ŒˆÑ–‹”'‡+ÒӉŒ= 3‡0ˆQ–•I¡2ŒR‰‡—4•Z‹
Í;—'Î0Š}CŒVÔZЎqJ‘‹ŒˆÕ–‹.ÖI—'ÎÖx‰Œ=C {‡2ˆ-–0•I¡2Œ-‰‡—4•Z‹
!(/lT"
,>7+7"
×DA(?U2*,T"
E
*T"<Y(?@;!%')
57"#"
?;K"
,2*"Y
Ky0:"
,62#"
,
2*2,!*"(N?H
5mM>"
,D<*!"
P+8
›>6MzP7+7"
Ø?;"
,tP"%;2!#C"
DR!2$"
N&"
,
K")
(@!(?@2!5(z5*(/V"
R"#z?;,,z!#"
!="
>*7"E€hbD/
(/-$R5!(?@B502="BK)
K"
,P8LF2N*A"
#,Ds=*B!$"
HO7"
!C?H
502$""
#,Ds=*N}0/-(V*(/R"
1/"
D
!"
5g%'
(s$*Q%4-/+6=T?;K"
,PyO+(/V%'
s=*\K)
2!
$T?;,#,."5:"
-(P"
,T%'
(s$*z0/
622K"#/=+0($8
+
(s$*:Nq$#m:"
,
""
DNq0/R/++06M2K"#
ÙEC
"
,
!
$Y!(?@Y502="F"
#,Ds$*
(6DD<2O7"
Y!+
$
F„ Ú=N¤2N¤(ƒ˜š8&[V<62D*"
A"
,
7+7"
Y*DP"
,
K"
(@!(?@2!5"
,=/+22V"
1/+)
"
D"
,E#2%@2!#C"
DP!2$"
B"
,0C"Y!(?@Y50)
="A2
"
,;,2*D/:2D/(8g¦@,Fy
7";7+7"
Ä<¢B
³{!
u¬ƒ2ƒ2ƒ\D!"
2!n?;K"
,SVoI$"
*dz³³!+
$T?;,
!%4
5Y*D/:$#ml"
,+
""
(/l%r
2ؤ(ƒž:9:LFÛB"
5¬M‚ƒ
9:LFÛ28G¦@,;20/.7+7"
_?H<2D/+@gY2F2#/..)
!*"
g?;K"
,:EoI(?@#ogvxžMƒ2‚2›Bo
!
$A"
,0C"@*D/5
%r
(s$*T((/P"Â?@PÌÌ9:L>ÛY0/P¥Ì2Ì59:LFÛ28G¦@,B"
,#/
7+7"
Ä*<./++>6MK"#2(/1¨$"
22­FÜ>9ب­;)#¤¤(ƒƒ
!+
$?;,256M2K"#25/-%r
(s$*-(Q62C
D/-%'
‚ªM9:LFÛC݃=8 ÚªÞß"
¥2‚$¤C9:L>Û(Ý=¤28 Ì2‚Þ8@"
,Fy
7"@"Â?H7+7"
N
?H;/K
"
K(*+
(/E"
,@0;/C"#>
E%4g*DC"
D
"
,A
K"
(!C?HG2!28&[V@*;/"#>!*,/?;,
<"
/+"
@"
,A
K"
(!(?@H2!;%4g"
,A"
,K#/7+7"
P8W>*+
y0/+D2&C
@*$"
7¶$$"
*K"
6M28&W>E"
,H¢BD$7+7"
PNC?HH%4*0/
"
,"G"
,;,,7"G%'
(s$*!2$"g?;&d2e igdàk&A"
,;7"g)
P$"<2!#C"
D!2$"(8AW>T"
,YoI(?@#oHvU77"
PN+?H
y0/"
,0C"A"
,B(?@7";%r
(s$*T!2$"A?;DqB27";
l%')
y$"(N&!
$"
D1!(?@52$"E2
"
,E?;K"
,\"
,
K"Â"
"#2/+F²1O+*+"
D"
DA%'@
(/+*/5
*
228
Ù ³Â"
,&!0!(N?@H
%'&"
F"
,HD"
2E%6M2K"#2@(D
0/5%'
(s$*T(Dáh2e b3d(§$jk^#de a4€=§/l!*
>%r
(s$*
>?;K"
,*"&=/+Ky0(C"
DE"
F6M2K"#22N2Zâ`jãä0j€0^àk^#de a4€=§8
W>"
,H¢<Þ¨7+7"
PN"
,H!*,//C"#F(/*I"
F2*0/
"
,0C"Y2!#C"
P"
,77"
ØDV:6M"#2¶M((/z=/+.(?
ڞ:9:L>ÛY?;;€0hb&E
1.$">%'
Ó57+7"
]!=">%
6=?8
W>*y0/+D25C
1D!"#$"5(*1O+7"
z2
K"
,
*r/T*!l!+
$F!(?@;502$"@"
,Ds$*@$1a4°å
fe aš^a'bše à*D@"
,0C"}!#"
<C"I@(?@I!%4
5G!="
(6M@
$8GW>*@y0/+D2g,(?u"
,0C"@"
,H*!+"
25A"
K?@(+B"
*28*+"
,
2N?@!
="B5"
,Ds$*"
,0C"B+)
T"
,1D="l2!#"
z!D$"
5"
\RD/$"
Ky0(/ZNA+)
D:!(?@52$"
K"
,B"
T
"
K1%4*"
2
$5"#2/.²-!%'
5>%'FD
((/:
l
(6+28
¦@,Y
7"%g"
,>!0!BB
MÛ(/QF%'2(?;8³{R"
2
«+NJ?@.!+
C6+D/+!%'
52N}!C?H(N}0/-
-,#"
7)
"
Y%@:oI$"
*.)30(/-ÊJ=*OR7+7"
P8E[\!+
C6+D/+.DDC
6*0C"
2
*K"
%'HBoI(?@#ogvg)30(/ÊJ=*OY7+7"
_)
"
25ž8G¦@,5T"
2:‚=N$?@F!
C6=D/<E#Û("
2l%q"
,
"Â?Hl7+7"
F/1D$"
=/+*2!"F?@E(<^`#a4bcaš^
d2e0f+hiHj`
k#ehfj8H¨+"
DTÌ/+(H?;K"
,T!%4
5>0/
."#/²
*R"
,2$"
O="B%@6MK"#2(l77"
8Y³Â-"
2
Ú=N?Hy
]*>y0/+D2F2-.
(7"
?@
m+22/q8IDK$N
?@l/*E
rC"
(/\?@
mVz"
2n¬10/V"
,\2*0/+l
"
Rª+8
2. POWER MANAGEMENT
2.1 Frequency Scaling

(s$*B(B;"
,Ds$*G?;,
H"
,H!+
$G$#m
.
(/*(/t$t2:*K"
!:%>"
,:5O+*PN!
K""
"
,5!+
$"
12*!C?HC""
,O+!5%<
)
/*(/V!%4
581
(s$*Q(D/\!
$
(z,0(6M
$=?;,
-%r
2æ"{?@t2!#"
n!2$"
l"
t6M#2!#"
!2$"
8
2.2 Clock Throttling
¦@,5­F/6(/\vHy2*#C"
2z0/\oI(?@³{="
%c!K)
y0"
2J皭Fv@o³èY„K¤˜<"
,E*Y%>^eh(^#éTb'ê=`7hbcbše a4€=§"
T/=+)
0(K=/+K%'Y"
,@!%4
5H%q"
6MA!+
$(8³Â
="#7"B?;K"
,-%r
(s$*1(Dl?;,
"
,%'
s=*P%g"
,
!
$$m-E"
*KV=/+y(/qNq$#m-"
,+
""
Pm2!
"
,5$#mV
*P""
,5
20@%'
(s$*$8PL>(?@62(N&"
,
$#m-0gE§Mdb{jë5E/
(/-%'E2+*>%AD
"
2*DCYD$"
68¦@,(?;/+(?;Q"
,.v@oG|~"
)
6M;%'?@>$#ml0<!<*";%&"
28
2.3 Dynamic Voltage Scaling (DVS)
¢>+0l6MK"#21uçc¢<Þ¨èY
(/+*"
,P!(?@52+)
*/R$PT!+
$E$P(?@
DPK"
B2!#"
T6M2K"#228­
(/+*"
25T2!#C"
D6MK"#2F2#KTE
(s$*K
AY!
)
!"
0q
(/*"
2P:%r
(s$*-„K¤(Ì+N}¤CÚC˜š8gÞgK"#2Y(D
2/+62$"#22*>(*"
,
R2*(/1$15!
$
/K
"
KE!
!"
2="
BìEíN?;,
;ìuI"
,g2!#C"
B6MK")
28Y¯gR6+."
,622K"#2T?;K"
,1"
,Y%'
s=*$NZ">
!2DF"
2+"#ls$*0/+#"
<
(/*"
2TDT!(?@@2*!)
"
2q8H¦q#"#+î Bvg
*$Y!
$C„ ÚC˜0/:³{="
šî <oI$"
*
?;K"
,R¨+!(/0¨$"
!}„K¤(ƒC˜IC
O!DA%!
$
;?;K"
,P¢FÞB¨Z8
3. LINUX ON PENTIUM
­FgO!A%q,D,!%4
5;77"
PN2?@;#,$>
D!+"
2!tçc¢BI³{!K
R¬2ƒ2ƒƒMèF?;K"
,-¬M‚ƒM9:L>ÛoI$"
*w³³³A!
)
Y?;"
,\‚=¤(¥29P¯_%HÜ>­>9ï
*lÊJ=*O=)Â¥=8 ž8 ÌC){!+
(Ì+8[\
*/R"
,.$m1"
,+
""
:!0K"
DE!+
C6+D/+(/-$-­<v@o³<"
¡M”'‡q¡ðŠI•}Ö}–0”'‹Œñ_òÂóßô:õ+ö
¬ž2¬+8 ƒ2ƒ
Ú2¥Ú=8 ÌM‚
ÌM¥«+8 Ì+¤
‚=¤ª+8 «2«
ž¤(‚=8 «2«
«+¤¤28 ¥ž
¥ƒ2Ú=8¤(«
¤(ƒ«+8 ‚Ì
‘(”'‡+Òñ}‡+ҕ
¤28 ƒƒ
¤28¤(Ú
¤28 «Ì
¤28 Ì«
¥=8 ƒž
¥=8 Ú¥
ž8 ƒª
¬+8¤ª
ø –ù&”'Œ:ÏÐ<ŸFŒ=C {‡0ˆQ–•I¡2Œ¡Ö}–•}Î0ŒñIŠJŒ.‹‡l¡M”'‡q¡ð1‹(ÖJ‡‹‹(”4—4•JÎ
# ,0"
,E!
$Y!%'
57"#"
8W>1*¢BD&D!)
"
!JN@"
,P!
$T
*5"l¬V/+²Z
$"5!%4
517"#"
8
¦@,A2,$"7"#"
G!#"
@"
,@!
$H"A¤ƒ2ƒM÷5N=¬MÚ$8 ‚÷TN+ڂ2÷TN
Ì2¥=8 ‚2÷5N0‚ƒM÷TN«2Ú=8 ‚2÷TN¥‚2÷TN/:¤C¥$8 ‚÷úí;%Z"
,<5O+*ß!)
%'
5281[u,V"
,577"
ØDD/2N&"
,lv@o|®?;DH2R="
!17"#"
Y/:/+$;"<O+*"
B7"
*"
28
3.1 Effects of Clock Throttling using ACPI
IK
7"(N?@g62*0"
/"
,H"
*0=²Z"}2Y"
,G!
$&?;,
"
,+
""
-"
,:D$#m8[V:
6M/t"
,1v@o|´(?</(?;u$
#/+Dx"
,ä+€=êd2e b{jëS^à2^eDjk:62$"12œ"
,zoI$"
*æ!)
%'
51*$"
8…¦@,5
"
*
."
,1=*%*,0K"
(/
çc*2"
(/èF+Y2
6M(/R$1"
,!+
$(85­FB="
(/
(N$?@<
<A"
B(*+
@"
,;"
*0$#m+<çc
2K)
0D$#m%r
(s$*è*DB"
,<oI$"
*_"
;7"#!*$"
(8
¯G2!
B"
,;
20$m%'
(s$*.M7"@"
,<=*.)
%;*,0K"
(/Q+NI?@"*+#"
5%'
5"
\%A"
,
(?</(?;0Ý!(/+*!1%&"
,B!+
$(8
­@"5¤(ƒƒM÷Ó!%'
557"#"
2N&"
,$mQE
*1"¬ž2¬
9:LFÛ28I[S,"
,@!%'
5@7"#C"
AD""
>¬MÚ=8 ‚÷TNM"
,H$m
I*,K"
(/YÚ2¥Ú=8 ÌM‚<D2"
I;0/Z8&¦@,I*27"
}"
,0C"
"
,R!
$1(?@(/œ/(?;S$…¤8¤CÚ\"
D8ú¦@,R2!D"
*K"
<%'<(,P!%4
57"#C"
Y
,C?;:DP¦ID.¤8
3.2 Pentium Micro Benchmark: Performance
¦Jl!0C
"
,"
*0&!%4
5E?;K"
,-"
,$#m1D(?A)
/+(?;2
6M(/YE"
,H!+
6=D*I"
2JN?@H#6M#=,+)
5C
m=B/-*
/1"
,E
*DT"
>"Y/+K²Z
$"B!%')
5>7"#"
8H¦@,B
#,5C
m+g?@*/P
2™
û\üGýýþÿÂÿrþ ÿ
7þ vH$"
D=*2*KT!@"
,>2$"
$"
@%
7"
F"
."
,;
7"
(8
û>ýýþrþ vH="
=**K.
(/g=="
&%r
2®¤©Y¯
/C"#7"
*"
*
>"
,";y"
A:"
,ÊG¤#,28
ûAýýþ þ vH="
=**KY?A
K"
&$+"
I="
>Y¤©Y¯
/C"#7"
*"
*
>"
,";y"
A:"
,ÊG¤#,28
û\üGýýþÿÂÿ
!Fþ#"$'þ vH$"
D=*2*KU
(/1$="
%'
ï1«M¥19P¯_R
2zz:?AVP"
,0"E(,
(/:(*F¢>)3(#,>D8
û\üGýýþÿÂÿ%&Fþ'"() 7þ* vH2$"
=**KP?A
K"
5$+"
$"
V-«M¥-9P¯úV
DR?@t-"
,"(,
?A
K"
Y(*<¢>)3(#,>D8
û+, ÿ-.rþ/ vH="
=**KV
2/Y"
,5$"
$"
%>1?
/:/+²Z
$"E¤©Y¯uÛBy0B%'
w/m8
í ³ÂT2*Ay2*+
N=?@B%'"
:/"
>"
,>!%'
5B7"#C"
B?;"
,
P$"
E+*/*."
:!0DK"#"
8\çc8:¬MÚ=8 ‚1÷´
/+"
(/:>¬2Ú2÷.è
10
Time normalized to 100% performance state
‘‹–‹Œ
¤(ƒ2ƒ=8 ƒ5÷
¬MÚ$8 ‚÷
Ú2‚$8 ƒ5÷
ÌM¥$8 ‚÷
‚ƒ=8 ƒ5÷
«MÚ$8 ‚÷
¥2‚$8 ƒ5÷
¤C¥$8 ‚÷
Clock slowdown
Access to register
L1 cache (read)
L1 cache (write)
Access to memory (read)
Access to memory (write)
Disk read
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
12
25
37
50
62
75
CPU performance state (% of max)
87
100
Í;—'Ί}CŒ(0qÐ>óߗ4¡2C‡-ùGŒ+•I¡Ö&ˆQ–ð-‰Œ=C {‡0ˆQ–•I¡2ŒVò7ŸFŒ+•Z‹(—4Š&ˆzö
¦@,A
*K"
HC
<,(?;D.ID*
<«+8G¦@,Fv@oG|u!%4
5
7"#"
BD7"
/-R"
,21~CONJ/P"
,E
5DÛ(/1D(?</+C?;
%A"
,.,5
m=>
D"
6M"
:"
,:¤(ƒƒM÷Ó!%'
57"#"
,(?;n2t"
,4
3ÓCO
8 576 =ý -lÿ 6 *89*: ,(?;."
,Qašë$jd2e
(?</(?;P%}"
,B!+
$<*227"
(/:$"
,B*
/T$#m
%'
s=*D5
!"
(/xx¦ID\¤\ç4?;,,Q^eh(^#ékšfj
jë ;^eh(^#é
ä=€+êde b{j
ëè8:[\O+!"
(/Q"
,.,5
m= ýýþÿ7<
ÿ ='>þ ÿ 7þ N
Tý ý (
þ 'þ NI0/ ?Tý ý @
þ þ N}"
P!%4
X25"
:"
,
D/(}(?</(?;R"
,:/+."B<$8L>(?@62(N
"
,
F27"
$"
C6M;"
,<r/+((?</(?;T0/(C"
(/5=
ý 6 =ý -5ÿ 6 *9*: 8QO!DTC"l¤(¥=8 ‚2÷X!%4
5l7"#C"
2N
Z"
,
>#,5C
m+g,(?œ(?</(?;P%ª+8¤(ÚE?;,
Y@"
,
$#mV(?</(?;zK\¬=8¤(ª+8l[\.O!"
(/\:(?Ä/+(?;\%
¬+8¤ªz%'5"
,1#,5C
m+8…­<"
,2*2,?HR
R"lP"
O+!DDS"
,Q(*-%E"
,:!,22qNA?@VD62-"
,Dl
/*<"
2F
#,K"
"
*+#
7"
"
2l2T,(?u"
,>oI$"
*×
!$"
(/Z8@çšAO!2N+TC6M
,2/5D*
/T$!,0
$mt$2!0è8U¯H*+"TD/:%r
2 "
,"(NA<"
,+
Rv@o|´$"
6M
,5
m=@,(?…(s$*0q(?</(?;q8
 ýýþÿ77
ÿ AFþ#"Brþ N2?@<7"#"@"
<"
,;5"
#,
"{?@1!+
$B!(/:0/P5!(/P,(?;DTP%r)
%4"(8G­@"F¤(¥=8 ‚2÷µ!%4
5F7"#C"
2N$"
,;,5
mED(?</+C?;
>2,$"
K1(?@F"
,0Pª+8¤CÚ$8B¯g:C?H
5"
,!%'
5E%
"
,G!
$(N"
,;`
jedbca4áj}F!(/YD
(8¦@,g!
)
?A7"
G+I?@K"
>%'G$8JLF2N2g(
"
,"&"
,H
2*+
g
A*+"
DÛ(/D>
H$"G5
?;,5"
,F!+
$;Dg
*Y"@E(?@A!%4
5>7"#C"
28
 ýýþÿ7@
ÿ CFþ#"D) 7þ* #,5
mN?@lPR2y)
(="By"B!0C
(/P"
T"
,D/C?~/+(?;J8Y¦@,D/+*
"
"
,B7,+
22*H0"
*+
>%}?A
K"
;*E"
,<?A
"
>*²Z(8
¦@,Y!+
$>/P"<7"#DJ?AK"
%'>"
,B?A
K"
E*²Z;"
!+"Â$8q³ÂY"
,G(H%0B
(/N"
,gD$"
#"
2"Â?H
"
,F/5"
,F!+
$;DA
F7+,+
2*8LFN
"
,>!%4
5y"
;
Y"<;D
28
G"
, ? ÿ -)rþ ,5
mNC"
,&"
0/2&7"
2(8
6M?;,"
,H!
$@&"
,
""
D/./(?;"
.¤(¥=8 ‚÷!%4)
52N"
,!
#](?;B/+C?;1$lF"
,R¥"
8;¦@,
0/+D"
}"
,"J"
,!
$&?AI*/
*+"
DÛ/>?;,YK"}?@&C"
Y,2,@!%'
5<7"#"
2N0/."
,
;?@
>2!!"
*K"
g"
(?@A"
,>!
$<!(/?;K"
,*";
y*;!
6M(/
!%'
528A[VEO!"F"
,Y#=*rC
K"Â1%gD$#ml"
,+
""
"
,0(6MYP²Z">1,(?œ$"
K:"
,T<"
,Y/+m
B*"
Û(/Z8O!DNK%g"
,$#mPBMC"
(/1%4¤©úD
6Mx¬©Ø+#"
,"
,0x6MS¤1+16Mn¬Q+N
†Ïtò
Fߖ‹‹(‘ö
¤(¥=8 ƒ2«
¤(¥=8¤(ƒ
¤(¥=8 ƒ2Ì
¤(¥=8 ƒž
¤(¥=8 ƒM¥
¤(¥=8 ƒ+¤
¤(¥=8 ƒ2ƒ
¤¤28 ª2ª
†Ônò
Fߖ‹‹(‘ö
¤C¥$8 ƒ2‚
¤C¥$8 ƒ2¥
¤2¤8 ªª
¤2¤8 ªž
¤2¤8 ª«
¤2¤8 ªƒ
¤2¤8 ¬ª
¤2¤8 ª2Ú
Clock Throttling to 8 Performance States
power
30
25
K
Watts
†EŸ<E ‰Œ= 3‡0ˆQ–•I¡2Œ-‘‹–‹Œ
¤(ƒƒ+8 ƒT÷
¬MÚ$8 ‚÷
Ú2‚$8 ƒ5÷
ÌM¥$8 ‚÷
‚ƒ=8 ƒ5÷
«MÚ$8 ‚÷
¥2‚$8 ƒ5÷
¤C¥$8 ‚÷
20
15
10
ø –ù&”'Œ-ÔZÐYŸF‡+Ҍ=5ŠI‘–Î0ŒR—4•u—'ñI”'ŒVˆQ‡qñ}Œtò7ŸFŒ+•Z‹(—4Š&ˆ\ö
"
,²Z"B%HD$#m:"
,+
""
52R!%'
5E,2*D/R">
B7"
28F­F"
,>2D*2-2Y(-/+#?%r
2w"
,Y
)
*K"
><"
,"<%4Yv@o|~$"
D62#,5C
m+N"
,B
*="
%
"
,5#,5C
mV0/V"
,5%'
s=*V%F"
,T!+
$,0.
!!+
CO+5"
>D=6M
B
D"
2,!J8
3.3 Pentium: Power Measurements
[V1/"
(/z"
,P
2*(/t=z"
,P7+7"
p$
*
T"
,./+#?;-6M2K"#20/1*
="(8[u,?@2*r/
/+K
"
Ku(*
P622K"#NF?HR*(/uQ1
7"
:u)
<?;K"
,P(#,17+7"
Ä"
.(*
"
,*+
$"(8A¨=20F%'
"
,
7"
?@
5yK"
(/Q?;K"
,zV¤ƒm=L>Û(?ú!Yy0K)
"
(N}2(/R"
:?;K"
,DH
G¤(ƒÞú*D:*7"
2Ó
*K"$NJ0/
"
,n!0/n"
\QoHvH³3){Ì2ƒMÚ$¤(®­;)š"
)3¢]2#/t%'
2J
I>"
2
³{7"
*$"
8@G#,P#,0q?AF
!(/PC"¤N ƒƒ2ƒ"
;!
2/qN+/.*7"
×%'"{?A
<?AH?A
K""
."
YM"
,A0/.!+
)
E"
,5/C"#+8T[\.7"
5C"
."
,5*#V%;2*+E%4K"Â\"
<?;K"
,PÉF)Â¥E÷TN$?;K"
,:F
7"
<*+#l0/5!DKy
622K"#²Z"B"
,/+20$">*
E%g
8>B2*+
oI="
*.){(/r!"
!JN$?@;?@
FK<"
Y(*
A"
,b3h2å
b3de77"
Ó!(?@Y*!"
2q8¦@,"YNq?AG!(?@E/=#(?;
$5"
,D!"
2!PF?;,D8@³ÂT"
,=*
H?HY
!"(N!C?H
*(/z$V!2$"
*,tv@o|N&$N&"Â?@
mNG0/
/+m+<C
Y}D*/(/Z8G¦@,YÊ}vH¢ß?AA"
*+
(/T²&8
¦}:¥:,(?;"
,577"
ï!(?H2*!"
2Q?;,T"
,
!#"
.7+7"
úAlD/+DF=/28G¦@,BÊqD=*+O,(/*A!*+"
"
,A!
$gD$"
YvF¤;HvA¥>D!.7"#"
</+y0(/$E­<v@oG³I0/
?@K"
>*$"
D"
,
F*%4*q?H
ml"
./8H¦@,D/+D7+7"
Ä*
C
2*0/T¤(¥<[zC""
&K"
,g!.7"#"
8I³7/@!(?HG2*(/
z(,z!%4
557"#C"
:/+
(."
,!%4
55
(?@
(/*+"&"&2y($"
K$8¦@,
%4
2NM?H@(2D/&"
,
D/+D7"#C"
Y!C?H;"
.27"#$"(8
IFO="(N>?HQ#…!D-,5
mçc2$"
+*2*U
)
="
Y
27"
è"
,"gO+
H"
,Fv@oG|œ/.,2(/"
,
!%4
5l7"#"
l/++0(K\%'
椃2ƒM÷Ø"
z¤C¥=8 ‚÷ï?;,
"
,1!
#Ñ5
*8…I2*+
1žz,(?;T!C?Hl"T"
,(3
CO+DY0/R"
,!%4
57"#"
C""
,@
1×O+8[V(?@
/
"
,5v@o|×!%'
5.7"#C"
.6MQ‚T0/+NI7"#"
l%'
¤ƒ2ƒ2÷T8g,-0/qN}¥ƒ2ƒl
!B%g"
,!(?@*(/1$P"
,
7+7"
×H
#/(/Z8&[S,"
,Bv@o|…H
*DY"A5CO+D*
!%4
5Nq"
,7+7"
]*!!+
CO+5"
1«2ƒ[z""
8E­<
"
,!%4
5.7"#"
EC?H
(/ZN&!(?@/
(8:­@""
,
(?@7".!%'
57"#"
Rç7¤(¥=8 ‚2÷.èN"
,77"
Ø*
*0/
¤Ì[zC""
A21(6M#228
+
2ß"
,@
*K"
NM?HAA"
,0"D$#m"
,+
""
B,&"
,A%')
%'"H%Z2*0/+DB!(m!(?@g*!+"
2G?Hg(6M#
!(?HE2*!"
J8[\.1."
,0C"Y!(?@E*/Q$
"
,577"
ï,1D(
D"
2,!z?;"
,\"
,5!%4
5
7"#C"
Y%I"
,!
$(8A­<@"
,!%'
5%&"
,B!
$
<C?H
(/ZN7+7"
Ä!(?@F*
/+
(<D(
K$8
5
0
100
87
75
62
50
37
Performance state (% of max)
25
12
Í;—'Ί}CŒMLJÐ~ŸF‡+Ҍ=¡2‡•I‘(Š&ˆ-‰I‹(—'‡• –‹ñI—ONgŒ=Œ+•Z‹t‰GŒ=C 3‡0*P
ˆQ–•I¡2ŒR‘‹–‹Œ+‘
3.4 Pentium Micro Benchmark: Energy
consumption
¦}t*/
7"#0/"
,R²Z":%E$m"
,
""
tœ
$N
?@P
6+K"T"
,P
\#,5
m=.*(/xu"
DS«+8 ¥$8_­F
,(?;lD:I2*
B¤Y/:¥$N?HBDK%'l
T*
2B$"
"{?@
!0C"
8
(s$*K
(/Y"
2!"
@"
,@#,5
m™}· ¸¹7º4»D¼½ N
/x
t
(s$*K
(/t"
\1uD/17"#"
™V·<»È¿K½C8ßW>*+522
:"
t2!
R"
,-
S*(/x"
O*"
1"
,tkd°5jTD22/
"F/+²Z
$"F!#"
!2$"
F/+*
"
,kd°jA"
B$"
6c8
¦@,A"
;="
620/$g"g0/C"@· ¸¹7º'»r¼½ (*;"
,;
6M
5";>!K"
*+
(/5²RC%'"
;
!0/+D"
E
(s$*7"(8
³{"g*7"H<mM!+"G25<"
,<
60"
;%Z"
,<O="G
(s$*7"
;*m=C?;q8
¦@,*$"F%g
P*(/\皷 ¸¹7º4»D¼½ èA?;,DE
*
"
,:#,5C
mzD5(*
(/Z8…¨+*K"#2*K$Ng"
,:"
:"
*l"
,Y#,5C
m5DF
#/(/Z8@[\Y!0C
B"
,<"
27":"
,1"
P"
,R#,5C
mn"#mMl"l"
,RC?H7"P!)
%4
57"#C"
28¦@,./+K²Z
>"
,1j Qbc`d"
Y"
,
7+7"
ÓVD/.7"#C"
285¨=?H.m=(?µ,(?µ*#,-!(?HY
*/"
,PD/P7"#"
NA?@P!*+"
l"
,P2*$"%
*/?;,DFT"
,DHO="#ED/<"
DE皷<»DÈ¿K½è8I*
<‚$NÌ=N
/:ÚD*7"#"
A"
,<
*K"
S
R8³Â5"
,>I2*
N+"
,B2*$"
%JO="#Yr/+F"
Y皷F»È¿K½èg@!*+"HT"
!5%J
.
(s$*K
(/."
*1"
,E#,5
mQ皷 ¸¹7º4»D¼½ èY8B¦@,*]%g"
,Y"Â?@T=*.)
;,(?œ*@?;,"
,FK";;
l$"A"
*l"
,Ä"<
"#P!%4
57"#"
28
¦}
* ý ý @
þ rþ #,5C
m1çšI2*
E‚èA"A"
,>D(?H7"
!%'
5:7"#C"
2Ng""#mMl¤Cڞ+8 «Q0/+/t*5¥‚ª+¤8 ‚
T2*85­@".¤ƒ2ƒM÷ !%4
5.7"#"
2NJ"
,77"
Ó*YÌ2¥=¤8 ‚
T2*."
Q
*z"
,:#,5
mQœ¤¬+8 ª2ªV2/8x¦@,t"
,
7+7"
Ä?;D&YRO="#.D/7"#C"
Y*$"
g¤CÚCž8 «l2/8<¢B*)
1"
,EO="#PD/l7"#C"
2N"
,57+7"
ï"l¤(ƒ2ƒ2÷X!%4
5
7"#"
2*Y¤(¬Ì2¬=8 U
Ú T22*8Y¦@,B;"
,0C">"
,E7+7"
*Y¥ž2ª2ƒ+8 .
¥ T2*5ç7¤(¬Ì2¬=8 Ú1É×ÌM¥=¤8 ‚2è"¤ƒ2ƒM÷]"
l
6M
"
,E
E,5
m5?;,,R¤ƒ+@
¤ T22*DBB"
,0P
*
"
,>
,5
m5";"
,BC?H7"F!%4
528
­F2*
*K"
g,C?n"
,0C"g"
,@"
"#7+7"
µ
E
(s$*K
(/
"
A
*"
,G,5
mE皷 ¸¹Âº4»D¼½ èJ/
(}"
,G!%4
5
7"#"
Fg#(/Z8g¦@,@H*<"
,<#,5C
mE"#mMg,"
"
P"
\!"
28¯H*"l2"
,1"
,T,00/qNA"
,1O="#V+)
R[V.2K""
,
*K"
B%r
2Ø"
,E#,5C
m=B/*"
:!
"#C"
2>*";"
,P,C?…
*K"
B27"
$"F?;"
,R*C
2*+)
$"(8
2000
Eactive: Energy used by benchmark
Eidle: Extra energy required to be in idle mode
Eactive: Energy used by benchmark
Eidle: Extra energy required to be in idle mode
2500
1500
2000
V
Joules
Joules
V
1500
1000
1000
500
500
0
0
12
25
37
50
62
75
Performance state (% of max)
87
100
12
Í;—'ΊJŒ=WqÐ<X<ÏR¡2–¡ÖJŒtòCŒ+–ñö
3500
25
37
50
62
75
Performance state (% of max)
87
100
Í;—'Ί}CŒHZZÐ\[l—4‘(ðzŒ=–ñ
Eactive: Energy used by benchmark
Eidle: Extra energy required to be in idle mode
3000
5
Frequency slowdown
Access to register
L1 cache (read)
L1 cache (write)
Access to memory (read)
Access to memory (write)
Joules
V
2000
1500
Time normalized to 100% performance state
2500
]
1000
500
0
12
25
37
50
62
75
Performance state (% of max)
87
100
Í;—'ΊJŒ=YqÐ󏌈Q‡0CœòCŒ+–ñö
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
66
t
(s$*K
(/\"
Vln"
,:D/P7"#C"
1%r"
"
,l#,5C
m
2!"
l皷<»DÈ¿K½èB
(8-¦@,5*X%<· ¸¹7º'»r¼½ /z·F»È¿K½
/+
(&2,$"
KY}"
,g!%4
5G7"#"
g}
(/Z8¦@,
"
,0C"HK%Z?@;!2A"
,<
;D22/.5"
,A7+7"
~"A/+K%')
%'
$"G!%4
5A7"#"
N"
,A7+7"
_C"G,2,G!%4
5
7"#C"
*;<
$8
A,5
m=&"
,0C"@2E"
Y:ç4?A
"
#èH/T/+mZN+)
"
*A
V
(s$*K
(/\"
-
*z"
,T#,5C
mx皷 ¸¹7º4»D¼½ è/+$
">/
(F*#,:1,D,1!%4
5Y7"#"
<2!
(/
"
R"
,#,5C
m+8-¦@,*5"
,TQ"
,
/+mE2&"
,@""
mN2/E"
,g
*$"
@/
(G8
+
2…<!%'
5G!
!"
6MN"
,&
(/*"
2Y%0v@oG|t7"#D
/+*H"
>D(?HH!+
$H7"#C"
D2/"
<5GC?</+(?;J8g­@"
,2,l!%4
517"#C"
N<!%4
5R/$5"T
(
s=*KV?;K"
,\"
,
(/\$m-#"
T/*."
P"
,!
$
?@K"
z%4:n/u/m=8
2Õx
x!
!)
"
6MNG",2,.!%'
557"#"
Ng
\!$"Y%4"
,
v@o|ú7"#DP?;,
*5"
,#,5C
mZ8¨=D.K""#m2
2A"
!"
;"
,>#,5
m2!
(/."
v@oG|…D$"
+)
6MNJ"
,
DY"
/Q
-!$"YVO+"#TD/
7"#C"
28¦@,1"Â?H\²Z"
5(>(,u"
,T*"(N</xu2*+
*
$"
NI"
,5C6M#Dg
*K"
/D/\"#,0281[\5O=)
!""
,.
*"55t#,02:%>"
,P!(?@52*(/z?;,
7"#D.%4<</+m5?@;*7"#$"
DKl/K²Z
$"A%'
"
,!(?@Y
(s$*K
(/R"
P\D/7"#"
8l³{V*5$NZ?;,
?H:D/"
,5"
"#@7+7"
ï
S皷 ¸¹7º4»D¼½ ɜ·<»DÈ¿K½èN"
,
#,5
m=F*27"B"
,"B?H,*D/1
*1"
,B7+7"
´"B"
,
,2,7"F!%4
57"#C"
!228
4.
LINUX ON POWERPC
IFO="(N>?HzK+Û\/K²Z
$"P7+7"
PNF?;,#,…R2
133
200
CPU Frequency (MHz)
266
Í;—'Î0Š}CŒH^ZÐYóߗ4¡2C‡zùŒ+•I¡Ö&ˆQ–ðz‰Œ= 3‡0ˆQ–•I¡2Œò7ŸŸE†.ö
MC#/:!*"
;0/l2PoIC?H#ogvUž2ƒM‚2›Bou
!
$(8
¦@,G!
$,I¬©Y¯Q%¢>)3(,G0/.¤Ì©Y¯Q%³3)3(#,28}¦@,
MC#/,0H«2¥29P¯t%/$=/+K%'+>"
,@7"#!!
2\"
,5M#/ZN?@5(t#,02"
,5%r
(s$*Q%;"
,5!
$7)
E0/P"
,!
$E$(*.çšoGÊ}¯Aè<"
,"Y/+K
"
K-²Z"
1!(/Z8[V*/VÊJ=*OR¥=8 ž8 ƒ1*!#"
P7+7)
"
P8GW>."
,H7+7"
PNM?H>C
B<"
E,2;"
,<"
*$#m
%'
s=*$8IO!DN?;,Y"
,H!+
$g$(*@çšoGÊ}¯@è
H"g"
EÌ2ÌM9:LFÛ2N$"
,;$#m%'
s=*.%Z"
,<!+
$A(5
"F"
lÌÌ+N&¤«2«+NJ¥ƒ2ƒ=N}0/R¥Ì2Ìl9:L>Û28<³ÂP"
,>=6=K
2="(N+?@
B>"
E(*
F"
,>!(?@;*
B%}(#,:%}"
,>!#"
!2="
;:"
,77"
P8G[VB
!"<(*
="
A%&"
,
T0/5"
,Yv@o|_<?H}<"
,>"
"#J7+7"
Ä
$8
4.1 PowerPC Micro Benchmark: Performance
I2*+
H¬@
!"
}"
,!%'
5G%="
,G
;#,)
5
m=*(/Vt¨+"
2z«=8 ¥$81¨="
,MC#/\/$Y"E,0(6M
.,0C#/1/mN?H/+r/l"F!%'
w"
, ? ÿ -@'þ #,)
5
m`
8 _ rþ acbþ :>ý "Rÿ 6 d,9*): 0/+("
5"
,:D(?</+C?;S%"
,
$#mQ
D"
6M5"
:"
,T5CO+D* %'
(s$*Q%>¥ÌÌM9:LFÛ28R
"
,#,5C
ml?;,D#,-"
,Y
27"
EB"
,ÊG¤(#,
ç üGýýþÿÂ4
ÿ erþ ÿ þf\Rý ý H
þ rþ /f þ èN@?@RP"
,"5"
,
(?</(?;C6M
D!I?;"
,"
,H(?</(?;0/+("
(/E$"
,@$#m
%'
s=*zç _ rþ acbþ :>ý "ÿ 6 *,9*): è8[S,1"
,#,5C
mP)
.$N}"
,5C?</+(?;2D"
,0\?;,0""
,
$#mV%'
(s$*Q0/+D"
8V¦@,/*5"
1"
,5
/*"
Dz%
v@o|~7"#DF?AK"
5%4l?;,Qv@oG|µ<D(?H
</+D*(/:!+
6=2*K$8
v@o|®ç4[zC""
#è
ƒ=8 ‚=¤
ƒ=8 ‚ª
ƒ=8 ÌM‚
ƒ=8 Ì2ª
9:Øç4[zC""
#è
ƒ+8¤CÚ
ƒ+8¤CÚ
ƒ+8¤CÚ
ƒ+8¤CÚ
¦}"#Hç4[\""
#è
¥=8 ƒ2¥
¥=8¤ƒ
¥=8¤(Ú
¥=8 ¥$¤
ø –ùI”'Œg0qÐYŸ<‡ÒEŒ=ŠI‘–ÎŒR—4•S—4ñI”'ŒQˆQ‡qñ}ŒtòŸF‡+Ҍ=ŸE†.ö
+
(s$*
Ì2Ì59:L>Û
¤«2«59:LFÛ
¥ƒ2ƒ59:LFÛ
¥Ì2Ì59:LFÛ
v@o|®ç4[zC""
#è
ƒ=8 ڞ
¤8 ƒ2ª
¤8 «2Ì
¤8 ‚¬
9:Øç4[zC""
#è
ƒ+8¤CÚ
ƒ+8¤(¬
ƒ+8¤(¬
ƒ+8¤(¬
200
Eactive: CPU
Eactive: SDRAM
Eactive: others
Eidle: Extra energy required to be in idle mode
150
j
Joules
+
(s$*
Ì2Ì59:L>Û
¤«2«59:LFÛ
¥ƒ2ƒ59:LFÛ
¥Ì2Ì59:LFÛ
¦}"#Hç4[\""
#è
¥=8 ¥Ú
¥=8 Ì«
¥=8 ¬ª
«+8¤«
100
50
0
66/66
ø –ùI”'Œ.L}Ð\hT¡2‹(—OiŒQ‘‹–‹Œ1‰‡+Ҍ=5 {‡lŸ<‡ÒEŒ=ŸE† ‘J‘‹Œˆ
4.3 PowerPC Micro Benchmark: Energy
consumption
I*
ª=N@0/S¤(ƒR,(?;"
,l
t*
:%<"Â?HQ
#,5
m=8Aç4[VFK"H"
,<
*K"
@%I"
,A#,5
m=g/*
"
!0DK"#"
#è8g­F@?;K"
,:"
,>
*K"
A,C?;:DT"
,B!+
)
6=2*."
n*R"
,ToI$"
*.)30(/\7+7"
PN&"
,T
"
Q"
*0Kt!"
5"
,T#,5C
mV/"
/n5· ¸¹7º4»D¼½
0/uO="#zD/R"
DR1·<»DÈ¿K½8×*+"
,(N;-?HVC
V
"
-(*
l"
,l!(?H*
2P%B(,n!2="(N?H:!)
#C"
T· ¸¹Âº4»D¼½ $"
P62#g2!$"
8:v@oG|EN¨=¢BÜ>­>9QNJ0/
F"
,2!2$"
.%F"
,lM#/œç4?;,#,D*/5-ogvH³
+
D/2Y0/l"{?@
ml(C#/0è8
³{:q*;,5
m=g?H>#qN+2*A
*K"
A,(?@/T"
,0C"A$
(?@
D\"
,P%r
(s$*$NH"
,:"
"#>
n*/$t"
,P7+7)
"
ú*/"
,<O="#Yr/+F"
F
1皷 ¸¹7º4»D¼½ /5·F»È¿K½è
/+
(8TYO!2NZ?;,Q
*T"
, ý ý þ rþ #,5
mNC"
,H77"
_2*H¤ÌM¥$8 ƒ2<
Ú T22*DgC"H¥Ì2ÌB9:L>Û2N
?;,DK">"#m2¤(‚ƒ+8 ‚(
« T2*C"Ì2Ì29:L>Û28>L>2N1"
,>7+7)
"
PNZ=:C?H
T"
,%'
(s$*:"
:!2$">?;,
"
,E?H
m$)
22/Y(Q.2/s=*"
KR
62(/R?;K"
,2*"B
Ky0DPD"
$N
P>
(6M(/Z8;¦@,;
*K"F>2!!2K"
Y%'
2Ä"
,Y
*K"
<?H
"#D(/l%r
2w2*+<oI$"
D*.)30/T7+7"
P8
5. CHARACTERIZATION OF TWO SYSTEMS
¦@,
ED>."#2/²\E*7"F5mM?;,1$m+:C"B"
,
!%4
5P0/t!(?@(8u¨+,2*r/z"
,l!
$5
*t(?@
0/t
(/*1"
D6217"#"
1!(?@(N@*""#mM1V2T"
:"
266/66
Í;—'Î0Š}CŒHkZÐ\X<ÏR¡–0¡Ö}ŒtòCŒ=–0ñöCÐEŸ<‡ÒEŒ=ŸE†
Eactive: CPU
Eactive: SDRAM
Eactive: others
Eidle: Extra energy required to be in idle mode
140
120
100
j
Joules
4.2 PowerPC: Power Measurements
¦}l«P,(?;"
,577"
ï!(?H2*!"
2Q?;,T"
,
!#"
\7+7"
ǁD/+D:=/28t|FmM:$#m\"
,
""
D
1"
,EoI$"
*w7+7"
PN?HY"
,0C"F"
,
ED>/K²Z
ED
!(?H*
2E?;,Rr/+=/+C"Y/K²Z
="<%'
s=*D8B³Â
"
,.oI(?@#oHv!="#C"
2JN"
,E?@K"Ylç4[UHè<K"B
"5Dz"
,:!
$57"#C"
*.
D7"
"
Q!+
6M$""
,l!+
$7)
5%'
2p%'"
,\7"
*"
28œ­FK"
,*2,n"
,P!+
$:
"HO+*"
E7"
*"
2N$"
,;$#m.@7"
D2!#C"
DC"H"
,
!Ky0(/P%'
s=*$8>¦@,!(?H*!+"
2P%g"
,E!+
$7)
K"
K%>
(.D,$"
n"
,T%r
(s$*\
(NH*+"
K"5TQ5D<
P?;,x!0
/t"
-"
,:"
"#<77"
!(?H(8
¦};žB,C?;"
,@"
"#"
6MA7+7"
µ!(?@G*
2<C"H(,
%r
(s$*E?;,
*DF"
,AD!A#,5C
mZ8}­F&?;K"
,"
,
oI="
*.){(/17+7"
PNZ!(?@
(YB"
,E%r
(s$*1
#(/q8
133/66
200/66
CPU Frequency/ PLB (MHz)
80
60
40
20
0
66/66
133/66
200/66
CPU Frequency/ PLB (MHz)
266/66
Í;—'ΊJŒzÏlqÐ\hl¡2¡2Œ+‘(‘‹‡tˆQŒˆQ‡œòÂҍ—r‹ŒöCПF‡+Ҍ=ŸE†
!"
5ÃÂ2V?;,D#,\V"
*+
Q
(/+*B"
,."
"
,.7+7"
A:D/>7"#C"
2N}h`H,2*r/"
,F!
$;
*5%c7"
F0/5C6M
$"
-"
,lD/l7"#"
:
T%r
(s$*$"
Kcm´W>*+.(C
D5*
)
$"
.,C?w"
,P,215*((8U³3"?A5
n.$"
"
*l"
,
B?@
m+22/1"F,2,F!%4
57"#C"
Y2
2*+;oI$"
*.)30(/7+7"
PN+/lC"<(?@A%r
(s$*525"
,
oI(?@#ogvg)30(/n7+7"
P8PL>
2N?HTD/+$"
%r\"
,Ts$*0"
%
"
,F7+7"
úB*7"g*0/+
7"#/5"
E5m2<"
,Dg"#2/²-/K)
2q8
¯@(/12R2*+>(*
="<,C?;1!+
6=2*K$N0?H*
"
,0C""
,.%'2C?;-#,0C#"
D7"
E,*D/V#Q,D/Q%4
7+7"
@?;K"
,:%'
s=*l!
$
™
û Io C?Hg*
;%qB7+7"
_,(?;G=/,0(6=D(8¦@,
77"
®?;DJK"
,<BzdM^bca'ájA7"#C"
EašëeDjH7"#C"
M„ ¥C˜š8
û oI%4
5H0/F%r
(s$*.çc!+
$}!%4
5g7"#C"
Cè
,0<;
D"
2,!J8
û ­F"
6MA7"#C"
<!(?HH
(H(C
?;K"
,.%'
(s$*%
"
,E!
$(8[\E/"
Y"
,"
D627"#"
!(?@B
%4*"
2P%I%'
s=*qo
™ nqpdr
½ s8
n »È¿K½ ?;D=H2D/+
(/E!!+
(O5C"
K
û ³7/g7"#"
H!(?Ho
27"#$";%4FDq%'
(s$*8
I>(?Nq"
$2m-"Elv@o|ú$"
6MY?@
m+22H
/ FØNq/Q7)
*B"
,C?H7"<%'
(s$*T"
,0C"F"
A"
,Y/2/
(s$*
)
$"
H%I?@
m=D22U
/ F tdu '» v 8G¦}m2!T2*</+*2A.)
!2N<?@Q*1"
,0"l"
,R*"
Û("
…%E"
,R77"
C"l%r
)
s$*
tdu O» v D¤N00
/ F "#mM
w px7yOz *K"
A%}"
DF"
.2.)
Frequency Scaling
7
P(freq): active state
Pidle: idle state
P(freq) with slope mcritical when idle = 0.5 Watt
P(freq) with slope mcritical when idle = 1.5 Watt
6
5
Watts
{
4
3
2
1
0
300
350
400
450
MHz
500
550
600
Í;—'Î0Š}CŒtÏÏ0ÐEÍ}CŒ?|JŠ}Œ+•I¡t‘(¡2–0”4—'•}Ît‘}‘‹Œˆ
!"
28T¦@,Y!B"
,77"
ÓEV"
6M7"#C"
Pçš/Q)
*E"
6M<7"#"
F!(?@S
nqp xoy'z è%'@"
,>/+*#C"
D5}% w~p xoy'z 8
+
2_"
,N$?@;m=(?n"
,0C"G"
,;
)
· p x7yOz */$"
,
7+7"
®?;,DY!+
$A
F ™
·)p xoy'z w~p x7yOz n€p x7y'z
­@"}@,2,}%r
(s$*
tJN?Hg$m"}A77"
U?;K"
,"
,
?H
m=Mg
/ F“D!(/:%4>"
,E
/+*#C"
D1%"
<
w pxoy'z 8
­@p x7"Ey'z %'
(s$*D
tJNg"
,5*"
DÛ"
2n%;"
,T7+7"
/
"
p çcD@%4Av@o|u$"
6Mg?@
m=M/NM?HAO+!"&"
,@!)
%'
5%H"
,7+7"
"
lD=6M
KR!
2!"
20&"
T"
,
x7y'z
%r
(s$*è8µ¦@,0C":"
,"T"
,R7+7"
ÑDl"
D62
p x7y'z *K"
>%G"
Y0/PD/\w pxoy'z ç7¤E) p x7yOz èA*K"
< %w~"
p 28
p
p
[VA("
,+*&2!*"
H"
,@
2*(/Y?;,A!
$D
F“";%r
(s$*(
tR™
· pA ç w pxoy'z p x7p yOz è n p 
É w px7yOz ç7ƒ
¤ ‚ p x7p yOz è n »È¿K½
5.1 Critical Power Slope
­<A?@
(DcNZ.
DY7+7"
®?H2*D/P,C?…!(?@F#,0#)
"
D7"
*,I"
,@2H,(?;DI2*
F¤2¤28&oIC?H
K?;K"
,"
,H%'
(s$*%"
,A!
$(N=0/27"#$"HC"
D/+D7"#C"
28T¯H"
,\2*+EoI$"
D*Ø/VoI(?@#oHv_7+7"
B,0C
"
,!
!"
8G[\/+"
B"
,B2!Y%&"
,BB
!+
$")
"
6M7"#C"
!(?@FPI2*+
.¤2¤E°8G¦@,qN
n€p  n€p x7y'z É®°çtA‚t u O» v è
³3%I?@*7"
K"
*"
n€pN0·)p
· p  ç w~p x7yOz p x7p y'z è„ nqp xoy'z É°Pçt~‚)t u »'v è{˜'Éçw~p x7yOz ‚
)
w~p x7yOz p x7p y'z è nI»DÈ¿K½
IF(?u?@F(5(D*D"
>"
,F
(s$*K
(/."
Y2!D"
%F
C"T62C
D*%'
s=*D8¯G2!0C
V"
,P
*(/nD
6
*Y%'
(s$*NI?H.?@*D/\m=(?µK%;"EE
V$"
"
5(?@>"
,Y%'
(s$*:"(8>¦@,qN?@E"
,"<"
,ED!
°×/+"
;"
,Y
*"
:/+2JNJ0/P"
,
Y,2*D/1
!<?;,
F
*
2F"H%r
(s$*HG(s$*0š8&[V@?;D
J"
,D;2!N&^`#a4bcaš^
d2ef+hi@j`k#ehfjA0/P/+"
„:
¹ r#»Dº4»¹Â¸(¿c8
¦J./
D62F"
,@!2N?H>y0/D!°…*#,T"
,";)
· pEA)
7"#$"@%4;0%'
s=*DA=26=Y%4°U?;,T%
· p x7y'z. )
· p8
¦@,:"
,B
K"
(J!C?H<2!Y™
¾ yOˆŠ‰Œ‹
„:
¹ r
»rº4»¹Â¸¿ †…‡ x7py'z xoy'z …

µ"
,H(s$*0C"
2JN2?@<<"
,"g"
,;
K"
(!(?@@2!<
/ "
(/R$1"
,."
6M.7"#C"
!C?Hn€p x7y'z 0/-D/.7"#"
!(?@)nI»È¿K½8G¦@,"{[email protected]""
*"
FC
Ž0*(/l$56
2*
!"
g*,.G2+y02*+#"
2%"
,A7+7"
P8I
2~>7+7"
!
!"
D622N"
,B!("
.
„:
¹ r#»Dº4»¹Â¸(¿J,0;<A%4D(?;™
û %"
*0D!n°X%"
,R,0#/=?AC
Q*(/u::"
,
"
,>
"
(J!(?H;2!
„l¹ r
»rº'»D¹{¸(¿N+K"AA
5.$"
"
:
*-"
,7+7"
X"E,D,Y%r
(s$*$8T¦@,0C"N&K"E
n$"."
QDDÛl"
,T"
:u"
6MP7"#"
0/T5O+ÛBD/B"
B%I77"
P8
„:¹ r
»Dº4»¹Â¸(¿šN
û %"
*0M2!;°z%="
,,#/+?@
G}
"
J"
,0%
"
,E77"
],2*D/1
*R"(?@B%'
(s$*:"
l
(6M
$8
û "
,G
G2!"
Û(/>"
,gD/+Dg7"#"
gDN"
,G
%c(6M#D
"<A"
*:"F,D,A%r
(s$*$8
"
,.7+7"
X/+!"
(/RzI2*+
P¤2¤2NJ"
,.
"
(H!(?@
2!?;,l"
,D/+D7"#C"
!(?@<¤B[zC"";D™
‘ ¸(º4º ’#¾ ‘ ¸(º4“º ’
”••Š–@—,˜ ¾ R Ù ••Š–2—,˜ š™ ƒ=¤(«
³{"H"
*
H2*"A"
,"@"
,B"
6MB7"#"
>!C?H;B(s$*@"
,F
K")
(}!C?HFD!28<¦@,<(A"
,0"<%4v@o|_$"
6M?@
m$)
M/NG2T,2*r/\0/\*!Q?;"
,\"
,5
5
V
M#/+
%;"
,.%'
(s$*$8:³{%A"
,5D/57"#"
T
Q5D
"
,0¤[\""(NI
"
(H!(?@2!.?;@2.,D,Y"
,
"
,T"
6M5!C?HDl,C?;z\"
,5ID*
R¤2¤?;,D#,\%cC)
6M
G
*>"
,A?@
m=D22/5"HB,,G%'
(s$*$8Hç3¨+<D/+D
7"#"
R!(?@lT,(!qN;7+7"
p,*D/u2\$"
zD/17"#"
-
2@!2Cè8gW>"
,F"
,H,0/qNM?;,5D/F7"#C"
>!(?@
,,"
,¤[zC""(N}
K"
(H!(?@E2!2
5;"
,0l"
,Y"
6M!(?@F8
³{%F?@1$2m"5"
,P
K"
(F!C?HT2!1%4l*ToI$"
*.)
0(/:7+7"
PN+K"<D™
Ù ›‘ œ›Š¸(–@º4º —,’¾ ˜Ù{í ‘ ¸(Ÿ º4º ’ š™ ƒM¥¬
Ù{>í ž
¨+"
,"
*0G!.%@T!"
*DCY77"
´(QE(*+)
D"
(/l=$N
¾
„  … ‡p2 ¾ …p xo‡ x7y'z y'z
"
,B"
*}!.°ß%4<"
,oI$"
*.)30(/l7+7"
ú2
•Š‘ ¸(º4“º ’¾ ‘ ¸(º'º ’
›œ›Š–@R —,˜ ¾¢¡ ›œ›Š–2Ù —,˜ Ù{>í ž Ÿ€£ M™ ƒ2¥ƒ
?;,#,QB5DB"
,0R"
,
"
(g!(?H2!28YLF2NZK"
$"G"
>
*5C"G"
,;,2,7"H!%4
5;7"#C"
28
2*+FoIC?H#ogvg){(/P7+7"
PN="
,B
K"
(J!C?H<2!Y™
>í ž í ¤ ‘ ¸(”º4º”Š’#–@¾ —,>í ž •˜ í ‘ ¸(º'º ’ š™ ƒ2ƒ«2¬
?;,
YA"
,Y"
*0J2!Y™
¤ ‘ —¥¸(˜ º'º ’ š™ ƒ2ƒžM«
R ž Ù R ”‘ ”Š–2¸(º4—,º ’#˜ ¾ ¾ >í ”ž ”Ší –@
í
vg
K"
(;!(?@2!:.5D"
,\"
,l"
*A2!l2
"
,YoI(?H#oHvF80¦@,;
*K"
(/:1E"#2/²R?;,
K"<F
D=";"
/*>%'
(s$*5?;,D#,PA"
,!!2K"
B%r
2Ä"
,
oI$"
*ï(8tWF%<2*+
2NG"
,l2*$"%F
(/+*"
zDz%r
)
s$*\*=Ã7""
-"
,27"#$"
.*#,n"
,T/K
(/
!%'
52NË>M¨62cN=@
(K)3"
;
(s$*K
$"
8I­F"
,
2
6"
2T?@(:5m2F%'
®"
,A@"
,0C"(NK%I?H
Y>"
2!+"
DÛ<"
,<D/+D<7"#"
F!(?@H2*!"
%J2*HoI(?@#ogvg)
0(/17+7"
"
5(?ú¤8 Ú2Ú5[\""
Eç4%4O!DN2Dl$"
/!@!+
$A!T=/N$@,=*""
Y/(?;5!0"
g%q"
,
Voltage Scaling
7
active state
idle state
6
5
{
Watts
7+7"
ÄmMB"
,B"{?@
mZN<$N$?;,#,:5m2@"
,
K"
K)
I2!E5èN"
,:
*D5"<"
,,D,7"<%'
s=*:
T$";"
,0l
*.";"
,BC?H7"<%'
(s$*$8
­<F?H.(RNJ
"
(g!(?H2!(!+"
*
>"
,E
*$"
D
"#/²
DC"
D,D!U"{?@U"
,-"
6MR7"#"
-
u0/
D/+Dl7"#"
:0/t(nl2D/
(/n1"
T?;,,n0/(C"
"
,T%D/7"#C"
B
D"
6MB"
"
6M7"#"
8
4
3
6.
CRITICAL POWER SLOPE IN
SYSTEMS WITH VOLTAGE SCALING
PROCESSORS
³{"
,;!+
6=D*"
JN$?@<*(/"
,"G"
,;"
6M;!C?H
?@;(C<?;K"
,T%'
(s$*$8Gvg
K"
(}!(?@;!(lB*(/
"
*0/+
7"#/l"
,B
*="
B!%4
5B"#/²V%7+7"
?;,
"
,DY*!+"
DV/+$",D/q8Þg"#2.P!+
)
,(?F2D(G"
6M@!(?@,0(6=DG&*7"#"
/
tI2*+
P¤C¥ œ 8l|>Dm277"
B?;"
,\%r
(s$*-(R!+
)
N;"
,120"
x%B6M2K"#R(t0/%r
(s$*
5D/+B(CB
(6=D2F%g!C?H.çš/+*"
5§
o ¦ßì í
rC"
2,!è8A¦@,F(A"
,0C";"
,2!Y%&"
,Y"
6M7"#C"
!(?H5"27"#$"(NA0/tK"5/
(5!%4
5:
(?@
(/q8
³{."
,;(F?;,
<?H>*(/"
,"H"
,<"
6M<!(?@HD!
?@(C(NH?H:2Kz/(/\"
-D$mn".T
%4
P!)
C"
z!2$"l(
" tdu O» v "
z5mM:"
,:"#2/+²…/+2J8_¨+
"
6M.!(?@YD?;K"
,Q%r
(s$*$N"
,E
D"
6M
DC"
D)
,!"Â?H"
6M;!C?HgD!<0/E"
,A
K"
(!C?HgD!
ç4?;,"
,l1TrC
2T"
,0"
,1"
,è"
,1
R"l
!#"
!2$"
8
<6M2K"#2Y(7+7"
N=?H(/T"
.$2ml"<6MT!)
#"
!D$";B"
,2!<C
"<7"#="(8g¦@,";N%'
6M!#"
E!2$";C"@%'
(s$*A
t¨+N+?H>$2m5C"H"
,B"
D62
!(?H<
n ¨ N/P/
D62Y"
,
K"
(&!(?@>2!Y%4>%r
(s$*
td¨™
„ ¹pr
© »rº4»¹Â¸¿  … ‡ © ¾ p© … y“ˆŠ‰Œ‹
¦ ,JN?@Y2!
YK"BMD7"B"
,E"
*0}!(?@>2!„ p ©
@
C"Y2!#C"
:!=">?;"
,R%'
s=*=t¨8
]"
,DNZ?H.m=(?
"
,"<)
· p © ?;,#,lA
T*/TC"A%'
(s$*
t ¨ ,@"
,
%'2(?;Dl!+
2!"{5"
*l2B?H
m=M2
/ FX™
p©Bª „ ¹pr
© »Dº4»¹Â¸(¿ N"
,P)
· p ©d«¬)­ )
· p© ­ )
· p ©®¬
û K7% „
p© ­ „ ¹pr
© »Dº4»¹Â¸(¿ N"
,P)
· p ©d«¬ ª )
· p© ª )
· p ©®¬
û K7% „
?;,
g
¯TTV5DF=*(8S³{%B?H1$2muC"l\77"
?;"
,
622K"#.(:!
$
*#,V>"
,2,(?;-VI2*+
¤(¥<0/!0
"
,
K"
(+!(?HI2!H/"
,H"
*0$2!2N
?H2+"#:"
,B%'2(?;D
*K"
™
š™ ƒƒ2¬« ªª „ ”••Š–2—,˜ š™ ƒM¥CžMƒ
š™ ƒƒ2Ì=¤ ª „  í –2—,˜ š™ ƒ+¤¬MÚ
š™ ƒƒž2ƒ ª „ œŠ•Š–2—,˜ š™ ƒ+¤ƒMÚ
š™ ƒƒM¥Ú ª „.R ¤ –2—,˜ š™ ƒ2ƒžMƒ
š™ ƒƒM¥«
„ R ••Š–2—,˜ š™ ƒ2ƒ2¥2Ú
š™ ƒƒM¥¥ ­ „ íí –2—,˜ š™ ƒ2ƒƒMÚ
š™ ƒƒ2«ƒ ­ „QÙ •Š–2—,˜ š™ ƒ2ƒƒž
š™ ƒƒM‚Ì ­ „&¤ –2—,˜ M™ ƒ2ƒƒ2«
[Vll"
,0Cª "C",2ª ,%r
(s$*N¥„ p © ­ „ ¹pr
© »rº'»D¹{¸(¿ 0/
,5· p ©*«¬
· p©
· p ©®c¬ 8P¦@,"(K"Y
\%')
„ ¹”r
•»D•Šº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„ ¹ rí »Dº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„ ¹œŠr
»D•Šº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„(¹R r¤ »Dº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„ ¹R r•»D•Šº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„ ¹í
rí »Dº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„-¹Ù r»D•Šº4–@»D¹{—,¸(¿ ˜
„.¹¤ r»D–@º4»D—,¹{¸(˜ ¿
y$""
1(?@"
,%r
(s$*$81­<E?HT(?@"
,%r
(s$*$N
œ ­F"
6MB7"#C"
!(?@<0(/:1¦J#"#/+$*="C„ Ú(˜
2
1
0
0
100
200
300
MHz
400
500
600
Í;—'Î0Š}CŒtÏ=ÔqÐ\°‡”'‹–Î0ŒR‘(¡2–”4—4•}Ît‘J‘‹Œˆ
"
,
l?;F1-!2$".?;,
.„ ¹
p r#© »Dº4»¹Â¸(¿ Ped`c§$j`"
,
„ p © 8I¦@,}$*
}?;,
g"{?@¥¥2‚9:L>Û@0/«ƒ2ƒM9:LFÛ28
I"
,g!*
!g%0*/+D*2qN2"
*"
,0"I!2$"I?A
¥ªƒM9:LFÛ28¦@,IZ"
,0C"}K"}DJ;22&yD2"
A%4*+"
,
(/+*Y6M"#2C?ß!2$""<
?;,#,R">>(!0%g,+)
/l¥ª2ƒM9:LFÛ2NJD· í ± •Š–2—,˜ ª · íí –@—¥˜ 8›>2T$"
TD/+D
7"#"
2;#,(!;"
,0l
*2>";(?@F!%4)
5;(?œ¥ªƒM9:L>Û8H¦@,"HDN$"
,F7+7"
µ?@*D/F
D="}"
F
*EC"g¥ª2ƒ29:L>ÛA0/Y2FD$"
Fr/+H7"#"
N2#"
,I"
,
(/+*>6M2K"#;/
*>"g¥2¥‚29:LFÛF0/2>D$"
BD/+D
7"#"
;%'
s=*$"
K$8
*+"
,l
u
(/+*"
…C%'"
:6M2K"#2Vx2
²Z"
6M.5-#,6M/Q$-!%4
D:$#m-"
,+
""
çš/5$"#A"
,g6MK"#2@èq(?n¥ª2ƒM9:LFÛ@O— NR"
,g2!g%
"
D62F7"#C"
>!(?@@DF*DY$m."
,+
""
Y@
(C"
@"
,
"
,E
K"
(&!(?HB2!8B³{%"
,E!%4Y"
D627"#C"
!(?@
*<D$#mF"
,+
""
;J5D}"
,0B"
,&
K"
($!C?HI!2N
"
,
GJ;$"
6M&"
A
(/*&%'
(s$*F(?@I"
,E¥ª2ƒM9:LFÛ28
¦}#,Ds=*H*,T@$m."
,+
""
E(5"
,
"
(DK5
(/+*
"
D62E7"#C"
!(?HB/+(?;P"
5.D6M}DE"
D/+DE7"#"
Y!(?@
6M.%r"
gD!;%q"
D62A7"#"
;!(?@7
ŽC""
*"%4H6MK"#2
(D8E¦@,B<"
,0C">"
,E2!%'D$#mP"
,
""
D5(
!"
="
DDK:7"
!<"
,0:"
,2!%'"
6M7"#"
Y!(?@
;*622K"#F(D8g¦@,Gg0/+(/"
,A(<D*7"#"
(/
\„ ÚC˜š8
oI2*$?H„¤ª˜,(?;!C?HG(*+
$"&/"#>62YDDC
"
.I*
¤(¥E%4<7+7"
®(/T2P¨="
M­<ÜB9 !
$
ç3¨­;)
¤2¤(ƒƒMè
8 T2*7"mM5I2*+
1¤C¥=N}"
,5"
D62!C?HE2!%4
"
,I77"
!
ŽC""
J2*+"I622K"#A/%r
(s$*I(?@
/q8
³7/+H7"#"
g!(?@&?;,D#,ED&"&7"
"
KY7"#="(N,(?;;D,$"
l"
,.%'
(s$*VE#D/q8Q¦@,KO+!
5?;K"
,
6M"#2@>,(?;}"
,0C"I"
,H¨­;)#¤¤(ƒƒ<!+
$?@&g"
2!#"
%'
ӂªM9:L>ÛEC"Bƒ=8 ÚªÞ_*!:"
T¥2‚$¤C9:L>ÛEC"¤8 Ì2‚ÞE80[\
7"
5"
%r
2X"
,K/"#=N&"
,0C"E"
,5
K"
D@!([email protected]!5%4
"
,<7+7"
Ä2;D
F"
,T"
,Y"
*0q!(?@F2!YC"
*/QÚCž$9:LFÛ28
"
,Ey2*+
!+
6=D//qN0?H!!
(O+5"
"
,>
K"
DI!(?@F!Y">ڞM9:L>ÛE™
„ ¹¤ r
œŠ»D–@º4»—¥¹Â¸(˜ ¿  Ù{íÙ u ‘œŠ–@¾ —,œ” ˜ u ‘  ƒ+8 ƒ2ƒ=¤
¤
/T"
,Y"
*q!C?H<2!E™
„&¤ œŠ—,˜  Ù{휊ٖ2u —,‘ ˜ ¾¾ Ù •”–@u —,‘ ˜  ƒ=8 ƒ2ƒ+¤
¤
±
¦@,@G"
,0C"(N+K"
,*2,"
,KA7+7"
×T*!!"@6MK")
:(D-%r
2 ¥2‚=¤(9:L>Û:"
Q‚ªM9:L>ÛNH6MK"#2l(-27"
Repeated Request to Apache Top Page
1800
1700
100%
62%
1600
Energy (Joules)
1500
1400
1300
1200
1100
1000
900
800
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500
Requests/sec
Í;—'ΊJŒzÏ?0ZЍ²5Œ=‰Œ=–‹Œ+ñnŒ?|qŠ}Œ+‘‹‹‡D0c³.´]‰}–Î0Œ
mMKt2.$"7"#C"
DVC"TڞM9:L>Û28¦@,=*NG"
,
;D$"
6MF"
2!#C"
Y";"
,>#"Â?H1ÚCž$9:LFÛY0/
‚ªM9:LFÛE*.6MK"#28
*"
,(N$"
,
FD;Y#,0F"
,"@%r
(s$*(D.(l!+
)
6=D/-
-
x
C6=P(?ïڞM9:L>ÛQ2S"
,V¨­;)#¤¤(ƒƒ)
(/t7+7"
P8t¦@,P"
D62:!([email protected]!:%4.%'
s=*z(K)
.?;,P"
,6M2K"#YDFmM!+";27"#$"BC"¤8 ‚Þß?A>!!+
CO+K)
5C"
K5ƒ+8 ƒƒM¥ªE?;,,T@
"
@"
,"
,F
K"
(Z!(?@@D!
C"TڞM9:L>Û28t[VP
l*"#".?;,"622K"#:"
,l77"
?@D"
P,00/5ÚCž$9:LFÛ28T¯H*"YK%@"
,.2!.%'Y"
,0C"Y6M2K")
2YF
("
F"
,l"
,
K"
(J!C?H<2!E">ڞM9:L>Û2N"
,
"
,.27"B
R$"Y!D-Q"
,.¨­;)#¤¤(ƒƒ)30(/Q7+7)
"
ß?@2*D/H"
B!CE6MK"#2A*$"
2*0/ڞ$9:LFÛ
0/:7?;K"
#,:"
.!*
>%r
(s$*T(5/+C?;l"
‚ª29:L>Û28
vg
K"
(E!(?H12!Q(œQ*(/u"
x/+"
-
!"
5q%'
(s$*5%'>1(//+(/l/+6=B?;K"
,RyO+(/l%r
)
s$*n
!
$5?;,,xD5"lDP"
V(P"
,P%r
)
s$*ÝC6M2K"#>/=+0($8}¢B2
@(5(*+
;"
,>)
"
6M>!C?H;2!2ND/B7"#C"
!C?H(N/l(D*D"
B"
,>
K"
(
!(?H>!28g[u"
,l"
,;D+%4
5"
2qN02(P/D/+B"
,B!)
"
5J!#"
!2$"<%'<"
,0C";!0"
*DF/6=28
7.
CRITICAL POWER SLOPE IN A
REALISTIC WORKLOAD
¦JT2y
w2*Fy0/FQ
Y
7"
DE?@
m+22/qN?H
*
E7"#"
E!02Y
(s$*7"<2-?HR
6M(8F¨$"#"
Y!0
s=*7"
;27"
K"
*"
EPKy0($"F!"
21%&
J?HP
62
?H
m=M/8[V1*(/x­F!0,)
¤28 «+8¤(¥C)Â¥2‚z5*5?@x
6M(8
¦@,HoI="
*.){(/<D!"
!?AJ2"
(//K
"
KF"
;@7?;"
#,
6=D.³7¯@9ï&"
,µ T"B«2¥"F(C#/*¤(ƒ2ƒ29:R"{?@
mT(C#/q8;¦@,
D$"EY1/+
"
KQ2"
(/R"
l"
,.7?;K"
,-?;"
,VQ¤5›>
2"
2q8F¦}2#"
Y
(s$*7"
N0?@E*(/:5!*DKPC6K)
B?@:
(s$*7"<#C"
<(D(/ *¶·2þ #¸ „K¤ž˜š8
¯Gly
7"F
6=."
,B
!2;%'
2w*F
6M(N+?@Y)
D*/(/z"
,0C".*
625":¤(ƒ2ƒV÷ï!%'
5T?A.:"
,/*!:"
1¤C‚ƒ2ƒ
(s$*7"
#ÝC"
.
(s$*7"
F"
"
,"
!1!0
%J"
,F
6M(8G¦@,;"
2!5!2F%q"
,;
6M@?AA!!
(O+D5C"
K
«©Y¯\Û2NM0/E.2*O!
D="
NC"
,@!02@?A(#,(/
P$8
I*
u¤(«n,(?X
*K"
1%
U(*
$"
P%"
,
6M
C""Â?HQ!+
$5!%4
5l7"#C"
N@C"P¤(ƒƒM÷ï0/
Ì2¥=8 ‚2÷Ç,/-LB¦A¦Ao_
(s$*7"
%'T̃Q0/+8n[V:(C)
*+
(/x"
,R
x*(/u$n"
,R
6MPC"P/+²Z
$"l
(s$*7"
#C"
8g­@"¤(ƒ2ƒ2÷ú!%4
57"#"
2N+"
,>
6M<,00/+DA*!l"
¤C‚ƒ2ƒ
(s$*7"
#ÝC0/q8<­@">ÌM¥÷TN0"
,Y
62>>"
5,00/
A"
,5ڃ2ƒB
(s$*7"
#ÝC28[\A,(6M;2+y
(/"
,G%4"H=
$2m=C";"
,B=*@%I
(s$*7"
A,0/(/TDT"
,̃0/
!
=/q8B¯H"
,R"
,ÌM¥÷ 0/\¤(ƒƒM÷w!%4
57"#"
E
6M
,00/+D/T"
,
=*@%&
s=*7"
;:"
,0C"<Ì2ƒ.0/:!)
=/qNg(R"
,0""
,
5?A"RDKy0$"
P
!D"
$8
[\."
,0C""
,.
Q*/Q$1"
,.
6M
Y
(5D+)
(C
I"
,H
(s$*7"&#"
@
((/q8&­FNM"
,g
*K"gD
K
0/+D"
E"
,0"E\"
,!"
*rCoI$"
*.)3(/V7+7"
PN}K"
j€Zj`š§à…j ¹^a3j€b"

*ßC"-x,,R!%'
5z7"#C"
2N
#"
,."
,t"
Q
*z"
, C"T-(?@T!/n62n"
,2*2,tK"
5\!+
6=D/5(s$*@*.!
6M(/z!%4
528-[SK"
,u¤(ƒ2ƒ
(s$*7"
#Ý5
(s$*7"Y#C"
2N&"
,
62.C"l¤ƒ2ƒ2÷Ø!%4
5
*/œ¬ƒMÚ$8 e
Ì T22*D8Ó¦@,V
6MR"-Ì2¥2÷Õ!%4
5
7"#"
1*(/u¬«M¥=8 D
Ì T2*8­Ó¥H
‚ T22*Q/+K²Z
1DxÌ2ƒV)
2/8Y­@"BڃƒT
(s$*7"
#Ý2N¤ƒ2ƒM÷w
6MB*(/\¤2¤ª2ƒ=8 (
ž T22*
/\"
,TÌM¥÷ï
6M*(/u¤C¥ž2«+8 H
ª T2*8\­ ‚«+8 ‚ T22*P/K%r)
%4
z̃:0/+8T¦@,
"
0/-,D/-"
*%4"
,
O+!
$"
@?;K"
,:L>¦A¦Ao
(s$*7"
@"
!0<%/+²Z
$";DÛ
çc+8n¤©´0/x¤ƒ©Eè0/z/+²Z
$"!%'
557"#"
Pçc2.)
!0C
"
,®2K:K%I"
,T(P,/>"
,
>?@
m=D22/è8
­F5,C?;xDS¨+"
U‚=8¤2N<
K"
(B!(?@T2!R0/+D"
(/
"
,0C"2-2*+YoI$"
* 0(/-7+7"
PNZK"
P$"B"
*P";"
,,D,7"<!%'
5Y7"#"
8@¦@,Y
*K"
;0/P2
(D7"
Y?@
m+22/PD2y
Ä2*+Ay00/+28
8. RELATED WORK
9P$…?HQ!
$
V,C62\"
,z(!0DK"{"
S!
C6=D/
2-!(?@:52$"T%'("
*+
PD*/n¨$"
2­<ÜB9
¨­;)
¤2¤(ƒƒ„K¤(ªC˜šN00/5¦J#"#+î ;vg
*$M„ ÚC˜q?;,#,T!+
C6+D/+g%r
)
s$*F(F/B6M2K"#g8³{$"
$¨=!(/0¨$"
!}„K¤ƒ˜2"
,+)
2²Z
"Â?HB2!#"
!D$"
G(#,C"H/+K²Z
$"G6M2K"#8
gO!2N+¤C›>LFÛ;";¤28 ڃÞu?;,#,.2*F5O+*…%
«ž+8 ƒ[z""
N/1ڃƒM9:LFÛC"Y¤28 «M‚CÞß?;,,l2*<5CO+)
*%I¤(Ì=8D¤A[\""
8}³{%?H@?@
@"
F$2mE2K""
,@!
$(N
"
,;"
6M;!(?@g2!;"
,0""
,;"{?@!#"
!="
g/+#?
*,,2,@"
,0T"
,F
K"
(J!(?@A2!>%'A"
,F!
$(8
L>2N"
,G
*$"
g"#/²Z&"Â?H"
6M@7"#C"
A!(?@G0/
D/>7"#C"
>!(?@A7"
22K%c(6M
@2D$"
E"
,F(?@A2!#C")
T!2$"*P¨=!(/0¨$"
!P?;,6MB!2D8³3"BB*(C
"H"
,@!2$"@,(?U*#,.K"#"
2lD5
5
(6=H"
,
F
$T,0(6=DKl"{?@.!#"
.!2$"
8
¦@,
>,0Hl62#0
!"
@2"
,F²Z"
@%q%'
s=*
(D8l0
m„ ‚(˜As$*0="
Ky(/R"
,.
-*!+"
2-%;
!$#mM"Y!*"
*.
T2C6P!!(C"
D8loI2*$?H-„K¤ª˜
!
C6=D/H/"#D/l0K+@2"
,F!0"g%}/++0D;6MK"#2
(DD$m=D5">v@o|_/l5!C?H<2*!+"
D8
¦@,
.
62C
D*>?H
m=2R
(/+*T7+7"
´
R2+)
*!+"
2J8ßoI(?@P(?@
-n7+7"
5,0(6M1S!
)
!2/nœ„¤¤˜š8n¢>+0DT6M"#2l(uçc¢<Þ¨èE2
K"
,
2//+
g"
,>*>$.
(/+*Y"
,<6M"#20/."
,;%'
s=*
%&"
,Ev@oG|ú„ ¥ƒ˜3„ ª˜3„K¤C‚(˜38<¦@,0DE!!
2#,P<"
(/*B"
,
!%'
55%;"
,5!+
$
=Q=/K%rP"
,.%'
s=*
/6MK"#2@?;,DA7"
!+
C6+D/+DB/(s$*0C"
@!%'
528&¢F+)
0E622K"#(DP
K"
,>/D/+,C?*,:"
5(
"
,G%'
(s$*ÝC6M2K"#A/Y?;,J8&WF%'"
K"&!
(/+"
I%4*+"
*
g
)
s$*K
$"
A0/l/D/+A"
,B(D%c"
F$52
6=D.!
)
6=2*A
*
Y*
2>*+"
DÛ(C"
2J8HoZ­<v@<„K¤(«C˜I!+
6=D/<!)
%4
5ls=*62D="2!+"
DÛ"
2z"
R¢FÞB¨V
K"
,8-[\
6M."
,"Y2*+Y?@
m-Y2!D$"#RE(\.*(/-"
O="
/"
,@?H
m=8GHO!2N2?H;(!+"
*
@"
,A27"@%"
,
7+7"
wD/?;,#,1F%'"
12"
/q8@[V,0(6M,(?;
"
,+
2*2,."
*0*
$"&/C"#+N"
,0C"r/+@27"G(@62
O!6M2N00/P,2N"
,0E!
%g¢<Þ¨T2
K"
,
"
,"E(?@6M2K"#CÝC%r
(s$*\*Y
$N}5Q"K)
?@>Y"
*28>¦@,
2*2,1"
,E*E%g
K"
(&!(?HB2!Nq?H
C
EB"
.+%4
Ä"
,¢FÞB¨T2
K"
,<"
,>#2%²Z)
"
6MY0/TD²Z"
6M!#"
.!2$"
8
vH!YD7"#:„¤(‚C˜G(Q/!CM(/1DRD"
2
?;K"
,\¢<Þ¨:"
P!+
C6+D/+7+7"
´?;K"
,\*%4*G,="
B"
l5mM)
%'
(/1/+2q8AÜFK){¦@DY¢<Þ¨RçcÜg¦H)3¢<Þ¨è@2
"
,(„K¤(¬˜
!#"
E
(K)š"
,(/*D12
K"
,Y?;"
,z¢<Þ¨-K)
K"
,8G¦@,<
C"
7y0A
()š"
B*0#$"
;A?H}AD(?A)
DP"
,.
V*
28:­<"
,E!!
2#,\E"
:2/!"Y"
,
!!D(C"
2\„ ¬˜q"
"
,>=6=K
2$"(8­F!!("
2l(l>!+
)
#(/-t:?Axçc$-#,02P"
,5$"
EEy/+"{è
"
2
6M
T?;,T
(s$*K
(/Z8
¯g*#/J„ «C˜!+
2!2gFDDG=/+$%'
2ß"
,@!2$"%JvA91W¨
!
$/+2B"
,K}62#M!(?@I0K+I"
,=/+)
2$8Hvg
K"
(J!(?@;2!Y
<?;K"
,l"
,K;=/cN/5?H
*7"#C"
"
,B*DT"
*(*+
$"F/C"#+8E*+"
,(N0?H
*(/l*;=/+0"
./+y0>
=)3D=";!#"
.!2$"
?;,,PPB*(/:$"
,!#"
.7+7"
P8
9. CONCLUSION
+
(s$*E(E/.6M2K"#2;(Y,C62A.!+
2!2/
Y!
25"
#,rs$*>"
l
/*"
,
R*
2$RO=)
!2K"
1"
,.%4""
,0"E7+7"
E/1"/Q"
P
*zC"!m
!%4
5:A"
,5"
28\³{t"
,.!0!(N?@P0+Û/t"
,
*$"
DF²Z"
A%I%'
s=*l.:!%'
52N!(?@(N
0/:
$8
[V;*(/."Â?HY6M/+K²Z
$"H!D"%4
g
*YÊJ=*OZ8W>
,D,Q!%4
5ogv…0(/12-5oI$"
D*]³³³<¬2‚ƒM9:LFÛ
!+
$(8¦@,"
,Y!D"%'
ÓB"#C
2"
(/QV(//+(/
/+6=T?;K"
,toI(?@#oHvúž2ƒM‚2›Bo_!+
$(8\W>*E
*"
,(?
"
,"V*YoI$"
*.)3(/P7+7"
PNqK"
RD=""
*:C"@"
,F,2,7"A!%'
5F7"#"
2N/TT"
,BoI(?@#oHvg)
(/S7+7"
PNF":zC?H:%r
(s$*x?;,S6M"#2QDlmM!+"
27"#$"(8
[V>O+!rl"
,<
(l%'A"
,>2? Ž0"
E
*K"
A$$"
)
/+*!"G?@<(^`#a4bcaš^
d2eMf+hiHj`>k#ehfj8gvg
K"
(!C?H
!
!
$"
>"
,Y
*$"
"#2/²ZB"{?@Q"
6M7"#C"
!(?HT/nD/P7"#C"
:!(?@(8x³3"."
*?;,"
,.5"K"
<
l$"<"
*1C"B,2,>!%4
57"#C"
E0/
2!"
T"
,T?@
mn0/t2V$"
-r/+P7"#"
28L>2Ng
K"
(
!(?HA2!B5>*(/5AY"
<"
E*/
7"#0/.,C?u.)
D="A"
,B7+7"
®;l
2#/A"
r/+B7"#"
B
DC"
D62>"
"
D62
7"#C"
28
*"
,(NA?@RO="
0/2*:K+l"
z6M"#2-(t7+7)
"
8>¯GP$2m=T"F"
,Y
K"
(&!(?HB2!%G6M#I7+7)
"
NJ?H52//=
B"
,DK"#"
V%@6M2K"#(P"EC?H
!%4
57"#C"
N&0/1"
,.!
DE"
,0C"YD(?HE6M2K")
2CÝ(%'
(s$*l*AD<
55(5"<?@;<"
*28&[V
C
2*B%4<"
,>!2K"ÂT"
,0"<20C"
D:%6M2K"#(K)
\/t%r
(s$*t(Duç4?;,PmM!R"
,l6M2K"#P)
7"#$"èg
F
5$"@"
,T!*+
F6MK"#2>(.(/
!!+
M#,8
10. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
¦@,E?H
mQ?@E*!!"
(/V$Q¢>­<Ü>oZ­µ2$"#"
&««2Ì=¤C‚C)
ƒƒ)Âvg)
¤CÚ«2Ì-0/V&«2«2Ì=¤C‚()ƒ2¥C)
¤)3ž2ƒ2ƒž+8Q[V.?@*D/VmM"
P"
,0m
"
,
%;­<*7"
\Ü<(
#,zÊJzC"³Â¯A9 NIÜ<(K){¦@
9:*K"
D/D1Ê}t"5vA9:|EN&0/V"
,T2$+2*
%4
%'
"
,K;%4(/+0m8
11.
º »¼½¥¾*REFERENCES
¿À*ÁÂþUÄ~Å*Á>Æ Ç*ÈÊÉÀ*Ë̓Å*ÁÀ*Á¾<ÍoÅ*Î~Ã>É,ÏÁËÃ>ÉOÐÀdÂÃÑÒÃÂ>Ì Æ¢ÂÀ*ËÌOÅdÁÓ
Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö×ØضÙcÚ Û*Û>Ü7ÜoÜSÖ Ø¶ÝŠÞŒÝµÙß*àØ>Ö áŠß*âÛãáŠÙ9ä'Ûå
Ù݊á*Ö ×ضâBÖ
º Ô ¼)æ}Ö9çqß*×9à
݊à>ÓÊè¥ÖÊè¢ÞŒé9ß*êµã×dëÓìƒÖ9íݵތތ݊àµÓ9î(Ö9íäŒå¶Ø¶ÞŒÝµàµÓï,ÖÊð/Ýñ“ò9à¶óëdÓ
ïÖ9îBáµô,ß>܀݊ތÞÓ9ãé9õBöƒÖöoã÷¶ãâ<ß*éëdÖ9ì7×9݃áµãå¶Ýñ“ß*à7Ùß>܀݊à
â\ãéãó*݊â<ݵédØoäŒéÜqݵø2å
݊à¶ùd݊à¶å>ÖÍ7Å*΢õɽ,Î~À*ɶÃBÄ}Å*ú,ÒÈËÌOÁÇ*Ó
Ô*Õ*Õ*Ô ÖíތÝ܀݊àoû¥áµãõ9݊â<äŒáƒæ¢ò9ø9ތäŒå¶×9݊à
åµÖ
º ü¼)ìSÖ9ô)ÖçqòÊà
õ2ãé9õAöƒÖÊýCÖçqà
ßõ9݊à
å¶ÝŠécÖè¢éÊݵà¶óëÝŠþáµäŒÝŠédØ,ï7î4ÿ
â<äŒáµà¶ß*Ù9à
ßáŠÝŠå
å
ß*à€õÊݵå¶äŒó*écÖéBÍ7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶЃËÊÃ
*˃À*΢À*Ì'Ì
ÏÁËõÉÁÀ*Ë̓Å*ÁÀ€Ä}Å*Á>ЊõɶõÁÂÃÅ*ÁBÑËõú яÂ>ÌOÃ>ÁÂ
ÃÓãéÖc»ÊÖ
º ¼Öïq×ãå
Ý*Óô)ÖÊû,é9õÊݵà¶å
ß*écÓ9æ}ÖÊìo×9ããà>Ó9û)Ö¢ã×9õãصÓãé9õ
öSÖ9ô,ß>ëތÝ*ÖîAãéãó*äŒé9ó<݊é9݊à¶óë@ãéÊõ@å
݊àùdݵàoà
݊å¶ß*ò9à
áŠÝŠå¥äŒé×9ß*åØ
äŒé9ó
áµÝŠédØ
݊à¶å>ÖéBÍ7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶЃËÊÃ
*Ë@Ñ*ú¥ÒÊÅÌ'ÈÊú`Å*Á
ÒÊõɶÀ*ËÌ'ÁÇ<ÑËÃ>ú7Í7ÉÌ'ÁÂ>Ì Ò ÃÑ Ñ9Í"!Ó?ÿ,áØµÖ Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö
º ¼%í%Ö#ãà$ãå>ÓÖ#}ތäŒéÊécÓ&%)Ö9ç€ãá'?Óô)Ö&%,à¶ò9é܀ãތõcÓãé9õ(Ö )û)Ö
û,é9õ9݊à¶å
ß*écÖ*,ò9ãéضä ñOëäŒé9ó%ض×9݃݊é9݊à
óë2áŠß*é9å
òÊâ<ÙÊØ
äŒß*é2ßñ}ã%Ùßá$*݊Ø
áµß*â<ÙÊòÊØ
݊à¥ãé9õBã¥÷
ãŠù*ã)ùäŒà¶Ø¶òãÞcâ\ãá
×9äŒé9Ý*ÖéBÍ7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶЃËÊÃ
ÏÁËõÉÁÀ*Ë̓Å*ÁÀqÄ}Å*Á>ЊõÉÃ>ÁÂÃ)ÅdÁ(+4ÃÀÈÊÉÃ>ú%Ã>ÁˀÀ*Á¾,+Uŵ¾Ã Ì'ÁǍŶÐ
Ä~Å*ú¥Ò?ÈËÃ>ÉÑËÃ>úO½Ä-+ Ñ9Ï./+(021-37ÏÄ Ñ!ÓdòÊé9Ý Ô*Õ*Õ*Õ Ö
º 4¼%í%Ö# Þ#ãòÊضé9݊à>Ó?Ö9öo݊äŒé9×9ãà
õÊصÓãé9õ2ìSÖ9îBò9õ9ó*Ý*Öû¥òÊØ
ß*â\ãضäŒá
Ù?݊àñ“ß*à¶â\ãé9áŠÝ5)å
ÝضضäŒé9ó%ñOß*à€õÊëéãâ<äŒáùdß*Þ Ø
ãó*Ýå¶áµãތäŒé9ó9Öé
Í7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶЃËÊÃÏÁËÃ>ÉÁÀ*ËÌOÅ*ÁÀ€Ä}Å*Á>ÐÃ>ÉÃ>ÁÂÃ%ÅdÁ6+UÅ7ŠÌ Ã
Ä~Å*ú¥Ò?ÈËÌ'ÁÇ2À*Á¾98SõËÎ~ÅdÉ$:ÌOÁÇ(;+ /< ÏÄ +9!Ó Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö
º =>¼%î(Ö# ތ݊äŒå
á×9â\ãéÊécÖ9ôoëÊéãâ<äŒá,æ}ߵ܀݊à,îAãé9ãó*ݵâ<݊édØ7ñ“ß*à¥ïqà
ò9å¶ßÝ
æ¢à
ßáŠÝŠå
å
ß*à¶å>ÓãéÖ Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö×dضضÙcÚ Û*Û>Ü7Ü7ÜÖ Ø¶àãéÊå
â<ÝØãÊÖ áŠß*âÛÖ
º >¼Ö# ތäŒé9é@ãéÊõAî(ÖãØëãéãàãŠëãéãéc֏è¢é9݊à
óë) ãŠÜ7ãà
ÝSãõãÙØãضäŒß*é
ñ“ß*à7â<ß*ø9äŒÞŒÝ,ãÙ9Ù9ތäŒáµãØ
äŒß*éÊå>ÖéBÍ7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶЃËÊý%Ä-+
Ñ*ú,ÒÅ
ÌOÈú`ÅdÁ ÒÃ>ÉÀ*ËÌ'ÁÇ<ÑËõú¥Í7ÉÌ'ÁÂ>Ì Ò& ÃÑ Ñ9Í?!Ó9ô,݊á*Ö
»ÊÖ
º ¼%ô)Ö&%,à¶ò9é܀ãތõcÓ9æ Öð/ÝùäŒå>Óí%Ö#ãà$ãå>Óï,Ö9îBß*à
à
ÝëdÓãéÊõ
î(Ö@¥ÝŠòÊñO݊ތõcÖ9æ ß*ތäŒáŠäŒÝŠå€ñ“ß*à7õÊëéãâ<äŒááŠÞŒßá'2å¶á×9݊õ9ò9ތäŒéÊó9Öé
Í7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶЃËÊÃA/Å*ÈÊÉˍÑ*ú,ÒÅÌOÈú ÅdÁ ÒÃ>ÉÀ*ËÌ'ÁÇ
ÑËÃ>úCBÃ̌Ç*Á4À*Á¾<Ïú,Ò& õúÃ>ÁËÀd˓̓Å*ÁÓ?ÿ,áØµÖ Ô*Õ*Õ*Õ Ö
º » Õ ¼éض݊ÞÖîBß*ø9äŒÞŒÝDédØ
ÝŠÞ æ ݊éضäŒò9âEFG€æ¢à¶ßáŠÝŠå
å¶ß*àoäŒé@çH%,û Ô ãéÊõ
îBäŒáµà¶ß*æI%,û Ô æ}ãá'ãó*݊åµÓ Ô*Õ*Õ »*֏ÿ,à
õ9݊àH@¥òÊâ%ø݊à Ô >*ü4*üJ) Õ*Õ*Ô Ö
º »*»¼)û)ÖöƒÖ9ðcݵø݊á'Ó&K)Ö#ãécÓLSÖ&M?݊é9ó9Ó?ãéÊõAï,Ö&?ÖÊè¢ÞŒÞŒäŒåµÖÊæ ß>Üqݵà
ãµÜ7ãà¶ÝƒÙãó*ÝãތތßáµãضäŒß*écÖéÀÉÅ>ÂÃ
þ*ÌOÁÇ%ŶÐC8ƒÌ'ÁË
ÏÁËõÉÁÀ*Ë̓Å*ÁÀ€Ä}Å*Á>ЊõɶõÁÂÃÅ*Á@½,ɶÂNÌOËÃ
Â>ËÈɶÀÑ?È>ÒdÒÊÅ*ÉË/ЊÅ*É
Í7ÉÅÇ*ÉÀdú)ú%Ì'ÁÇPO/À*ÁÇ*È9À>ÇÃSÀdÁ¾ ÒÊõÉÀd˓ÌOÁÇ<Ñ
ËÃ>ú“½Ñ9Í/O Ñ
ÏFQI!Ó@oß>ù?Ö Ô*Õ*Õ*Õ Ö
º » Ô ¼ÖÊð/ß*à
á
×Bãé9õ2û)Ö&â<ä Ø
×cÖÊè¢é9݊à¶óë2áŠß*é9å¶ò9â<ÙÊضäŒß*é@ßñ û¥Ù9Ù9ތÝ
îAãáµäŒédضß*å
×@áŠß*â<Ù9òØ
݊à
åµÖÏG0/0R0S+4̓µÉÅdÓc»>T;4UÓ@¥ßµùÖ»>ÊÖ
º »µü¼ÖÊð/ß*à
á
×Bãé9õ2û)Ö&â<ä Ø
×cÖâ<Ù9à
ßµùÊäŒéÊó%õÊëéãâ<äŒá,ùdß*Þ Ø
ãó*ÝSå
áµãތäŒé9ó
ãތó*ß*à
ä ض×9â<åqÜoä Ø
×2æû¥ïqè¥ÖéAÍ7ÉŵÂÃþ*Ì'ÁÇ)ŶÐSËÊÃÏÁËõÉÁÀd˓̓Å*ÁÀ
Ä~Å*Á>ÐÃ>ÉÃ>ÁÂ
ÃÅ*ÁV+4ÃÀÈÊÉÃ>ú%Ã>ÁË7À*Á¾9+4Å>¾dà ÌOÁǍÅ
Ð<Ä}Ådú¥ÒÈÊËõÉ
ÑËÃ>ú“½%Ä-+ Ñ9Ï./+0W1X3oÏÄ/Ñ!Ó&*ò9é9Ý Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö
º »5¼%ô)ÖîBß*å¶ø?݊à¶ó*ݵàoãé9õ@ìSÖ*äŒécÖ9×dضضÙ݊à¶ñÚ¢ûDضßß*ÞcñOß*à7â<ݵãå
ò9à¶äŒé9ó
܀݊ø@å
݊àùdݵà7Ù݊à¶ñOß*à
â\ãé9áŠÝ*ÖéBÍ7ÉŵÂÃþ*Ì'ÁÇ)Å
ЃËÊÃA¢Ì'ÉNË
Y Å*É$:FÊŊÒ(Å*ÁBÏÁËõÉÁÃ>Ë~яõɿÃ>É,Í7Ã>ÉOÐÅdÉú%À*ÁÂÃ>Ó&*ò9éÊÝ»>ÊÖ
º »¼%ô)ÖîBß*å¶å
Ý*ÓLSÖ9û¥ëõ9äŒécÓ9ç,Öïq×9äŒÞŒõ9݊à¶å>ÓãéÊõBöƒÖîB݊ތ×9݊âBÖ
ï€ß*â<ÙÊäŒÞŒÝµàG) ãå
å¶äŒå¶Ø¶ÝŠõõëÊéãâ<äŒá,Ù?ߵ܀݊àF) ãŠÜ7ãà
݃å¶á×9݊õ9ò9ތäŒéÊó%ñ“ß*à
à
ݵãÞ )ضäŒâ<ÝãÙ9Ù9ތäŒáµãضäŒß*é9å>ÖéAÍ7ÉŵÂÃþ*Ì'ÁÇ)ŶРY Å*É$:FÊÅÒ.Å*Á
Ä~Å*ú¥Ò?ÌZ õÉ%À*Á¾ ÑЊÅ*ÉDOcÅ*ÎÍoÅ*Î~Ã>É[ŠÄ O/Í?!Óÿ,áØ>Ö Ô*Õ*Õ*Õ Ö
º »4¼)ìSÖ9îBò9õ9ó*Ý*Öæ ß>ÜqݵàµÚ~ã\à
åØ7áŠÞ#ãå
åoõ9݊å
äŒó*é@áŠß*é9åØ
à
ãäŒéصÖ
Ä~Å*ú¥Ò?ÈËÃ>ÉÓüT]UÚ Ô^ =Ó?û,Ù9àµÖ Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö
º »=>¼)ìSÖÊæ ݵà¶äŒé9ó9Ó9ìƒÖ9çqò9à
õcÓ9ãé9õBöƒÖçqà¶ßõÊݵà¶å
݊écÖôoëÊéãâ<äŒá¥ùdß*Þ Øãó*Ý
å
áµãތäŒé9ó<ãé9õØ
×Ê݃õ9݊å
äŒó*é@ßñ~ã%ތߵÜH)Ùß>܀݊à7â<äŒáŠà
ß*Ù9à¶ßáŠÝŠå
å¶ß*à
å¶ëå¶Ø¶ÝµâBÖéAÍ7ÅdÎ~Ã>ÉDBSÉÌ'¿ÃµÁ(+4ÌOÂ>ÉÅ>À*ÉÂ5Ì'ËõËÈÊÉà Y Å*É$:FÊÅÒÓ
dòÊé9Ý»>ÊÖ
º »>¼)æ}Öæ¢äŒÞŒÞ#ãäãé9õ2í%Ö&%)Ö×9äŒécÖ9öoݵãÞ )ضäŒâ<Ý,õÊëéãâ<äŒáoùdß*Þ Øãó*݃å¶á>ãތäŒéÊó
ñ“ß*à7ތß>ÜH)Ùߵ܀݊ào݊â)ø?݊õ9õÊݵõ2ß*Ùݵà
ãØ
äŒéÊó<å¶ëå¶Ø¶Ýµâ<åµÖéAÍ7ÉÅ>Â
Ãþ*ÌOÁÇ
Å
ЃËÊý%Ä-+ Ñ*ú,ÒÅÌOÈú`Å*Á ÒÃ>ÉÀ*ËÌ'ÁÇ<ÑËõúòÉÌOÁÂµÌ Ò& Ã
Ñ Ñ9Í?!Ó Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö
º »¼ÖÊæ ß*ò܀݊ތå¶ÝdÓí%Ö9ð ãé9ó*݊é9õÊß݊écӏãé9õ(LÖ&äŒÙ9å>Ö9ô¥ëÊé9ãâ<äŒá,ùdß*Þ Øãó*Ý
å
áµãތäŒé9óß*é@ã)ތß>ÜH)Ùߵ܀݊à¥â<äŒáŠà
ß*ÙÊà
ßáµÝŠå¶å
ß*àÖéBÍ7ÉŵÂÃþ*Ì'ÁÇ)Å
Ð
_ ËZÏÁËÃ>ÉÁÀ*ËÌOÅ*ÁÀ€Ä~Å*Á>ÐÃ>ÉÃ>ÁÂ
ÃÅ*ÁV+4Å`7ŠÌ Ã2Ä}Å*ú,ÒÈÊ˓ÌOÁÇ@À*Á¾
8SÃ>˓΢Å*É$:*Ì'ÁÇ6]+UÅ7µÌOÂÅ*úa!Ó&*ò9Þ ë Ô*Õ*Õ »*Ö
º Ô*Õ ¼%î(ÖÊýU݊äŒå
݊à>Ó9ç,ÖÊýU݊ތá×cÓûÖô,݊â<݊à
åµÓ9ãé9õ6?Ö×Êݵé*ݵàµÖ
á×9݊õ9ò9ތäŒéÊóñ“ß*à7à
݊õ9òÊáµÝŠõBï€æ/bC݊é9݊à¶óëÖéBÍ7ÉŵÂÃþ*Ì'ÁÇ)Å
ЃËÊÃ
Ñ*ú,ÒÅ
ÌOÈú`ÅdÁ ÒÃ>ÉÀ*ËÌ'ÁÇ<ÑËõúaBÃ̌Ç*Á4À*Á¾
Ïú¥Ò Ã>ú%Ã>ÁËÀ*ËÌOÅ*ÁÓ@¥ß>ù?Öc»9Ö