APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 1. Introduction This application note compares the Macronix MX25L_06E and Atmel AT25DF_A families of serial flash devices. The document does not provide detailed information on the individual devices, but highlights the similarities and differences between them. The comparison covers general features, performance, packaging, and commands. The information in this document is based on datasheets listed in Section 8. Newer versions of the datasheets may override the contents of this document. 2. Feature Comparison Both flash device families have similar features and functions as shown in Table 2-1. Table 2-1: Features Feature Vcc Voltage Range I/O Mode*1*2 Sector Erase Size Program Buffer Size Security OTP Hold# Pin Block Protection Manufacturer ID Device ID 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb Macronix MX25L_06E 2.7V ~ 3.6V 1-1-1 1-1-2 4KB / 64KB 256 Byte 64 Byte*3 Yes BP bit Group Protection C2h 20h/13h 20h/14h 20h/16h 20h/17h Atmel AT25DF_A 2.7V ~ 3.6V 1-1-1 1-1-2 4KB / 32KB / 64KB 256 Byte 128 Byte*3 Yes Individual 64KB Sector 1Fh 44h/01h 45h/01h 47h/01h 48h/00h Note: 1. x-y-z in I/O mode indicates the number of active pins used for opcode(x), address(y) and data(z). 2. AT25DF041A doesn’t support multi I/O mode 3. MX25L4006E and AT25DF041A don’t support Security OTP P/N: AN0221 1 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 3. Performance Comparison Tables 3-1 and 3-2 compare the read and write performance of the MX25L_06E and AT25DF_A. Table 3-1: Read Performance Parameter Normal Read (max.) Fast Read 1-1-1 Mode (max.) Fast Read 1-1-2 Mode (max.) tCLQV / tV (max.) 15pF load 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb Macronix MX25L_06E 33MHz 33MHz 33MHz 33MHz 86MHz 86MHz 86MHz 86MHz 80MHz 80MHz 80MHz 80MHz 6ns 6ns 6ns 8ns Atmel AT25DF_A 33MHz 50MHz 50MHz 40MHz 70MHz 85MHz 85MHz 85MHz N/A 85MHz 85MHz 65MHz 6ns 5ns 5ns 5ns Table 3-2: Write Performance Parameter 4KB Erase (typ.) 32KB 64KB Chip Erase (typ.) Byte Program (typ.) Page Density Macronix MX25L_06E Atmel AT25DF_A 4Mb – 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb – 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb – 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb – 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb, 32Mb 64Mb 60ms 60ms 0.7s 0.7s 3.5s 7s 25s 50s 9us 9us 1.4ms 1.4ms 1.4ms 50ms 75ms 0.25s 0.3s 0.4s 0.6s 3s 16s 25s 70s 7us 30us 1.2ms 1ms 2.5ms 100,000 100,000 Write/Erase Cycles (Endurance) P/N: AN0221 2 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 4. DC Characteristics Comparison Tables 4-1 and 4-2 show that both flash families have similar DC characteristics. Table 4-1: Read / Write Current Parameter Read Current @ 1xI/O (max.) Standby Current (max.) Write Current Program/Erase (max.) Density 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb Macronix MX25L_06E 12mA @ 86MHz 12mA @ 86MHz 25mA @ 86MHz 25mA @ 86MHz 25uA 25uA 40uA 50uA 20mA/15mA 20mA/15mA 20mA/20mA 20mA/20mA Table 4-2: Input / Output Voltage Parameter Macronix MX25L_06E Input Low Voltage Input High Voltage Output Low Voltage Output High Voltage P/N: AN0221 0.3VCC (max.) 0.7VCC (min.) 0.4V (max.) VCC-0.2 (min.) 3 Atmel AT25DF_A 16mA @ 70MHz 19mA @ 85MHz 19mA @ 85MHz 38mA @ 85MHz 35uA 50uA 50uA 50uA 18mA/20mA 15mA/18mA 16mA/18mA 18mA/18mA Atmel AT25DF_A 0.3Vcc (max.) 0.7Vcc (min.) 0.4V (max.) Vcc-0.2 (min.) Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 5. Hardware Considerations Both devices are available in 8-SOP and 8-WSON packages with identical footprints. The figures below show the common packages and the pinout assignments for the Macronix and Atmel devices. Table 5-1: Packages Package 8-SOP (150 mil) 8-SOP (209 mil) 8-WSON (6mm x 5mm) Macronix MX25L_06E 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes - Atmel AT25DF_A 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Note: Not all Macronix package options shown. Refer to Macronix datasheet for additional package options. 8-SOP (150mil & 209mil): Macronix and Atmel devices CS# SO/SIO1 1 2 WP# 3 GND MX25L_06E 4 8 VCC 7 6 HOLD# 5 CS# SO/SOI 1 2 SCLK WP# 3 SI/SIO0 GND 4 AT25DF_A 8 VCC 7 6 HOLD# 5 SI/SIO SCK AT25DF041A doesn't support 1I/2O mode 8-WSON (6x5mm) Macronix and Atmel devices CS# 1 SO/SIO1 2 WP# 3 GND 4 MX25L_06E 8 VCC CS# 1 7 Hold# SO/SOI 2 6 SCLK WP# p 3 5 SI/SIO0 GND 4 AT25DF_A 8 VCC 7 HOLD# 6 SCK 5 SI/SIO AT25DF041A doesn't support 1I/2O mode P/N: AN0221 4 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 6. Software Considerations Basic command sets of both flash families are similar. Status Register and Security Register definitions may be slightly different, but the concepts are the same. Minor modifications to the algorithm may be necessary depending on application. See the Macronix datasheet for a complete list of commands, as additional features may be available but are not shown. Table 6-1: Command Comparison Instruction Instruction Type Read ID Read Write Register Other Command RDID READ FAST_READ DREAD WREN WRDI PP SE 4K BE 32K BE 64K CE RDSR RDSR-2 WRSR RDSCUR WRSCUR DP RES OTPP OTPR ENSO EXSO RST Description Read Identification Read Data Bytes Read Data Bytes at Higher Speed 1I/2O Read Write Enable Write Disable Page Program Sector Erase Block Erase 32KB Block Erase 64KB Chip Erase Read Status Register Read Status Register 2 Write Status Register Read Security Register Write Security Register Deep Power Down Release from Deep Power Down Program OTP Memory Read OTP Memory Enter Secure OTP Exit Secure OTP Reset Memory Macronix Atmel MX25L_06E AT25DF_A 9Fh 03h 0Bh 3Bh 9Fh 03h 0Bh 3Bh*2 06h 04h 02h 20h 06h 04h 02h 20h -52h 52h or D8h D8h 60h or C7h 60h or C7h 05h 01h 2Bh*1 2Fh*1 B9h ABh --B1h*1 C1h*1 -- 05h 31h*2 01h B9h ABh 9Bh*2 77h*2 --F0h*2 Note: 1. MX25L4006E doesn’t support command. 2. AT25DF041A doesn’t support command. P/N: AN0221 5 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 6-2. Status Register and Security Register Both devices use registers for providing status and setting device configuration, but there are some differences that designers need to be aware of as modifications to software may be needed. Register comparisons are shown in Table 6-2 and Table 6-3. If a detailed functional description of register bits is required, please refer to the datasheets listed in section 8. Table 6-2: Status Register Register Bit Macronix MX25L_06E Bit0 Bit1 Bit2 Bit3 Bit4 Bit5 Bit6 Bit7 Atmel AT25DF_A WIP, 1=write operation WEL, 1=write enable BP0, BP protection BP1, BP protection BP2, BP protection BP3, BP protection*1 Reserved SRWD, 1=SR write disable RDY/BSY, 1=write operation WEL, 1=write enable Software Protection Status Software Protection Status WPP, 0=WP# asserted EPE, 1=Erase or program error SPM, 0=Byte/Page Program mode*2 SPRL, 1=SR Protection Locked Note: 1. MX25L4006E/8006E Bit5 is Reserved for future use and = 0. 2. AT25DF081A/321A/641A Bit6 is Reserved for future use and = 0. Table 6-3: Macronix Security Register / Atmel Status Register Byte 2 Register Bit Macronix MX25L_06E Atmel AT25DF_A Bit0 Bit1 Bit2 Secured OTP; 1=Factory Lock LDSO; 1=OTP Lock Down Reserved Bit3 Reserved Bit4 Bit5 Bit6 Bit7 Reserved Reserved Reserved Reserved RDY/BSY, 1=Write operation ES, 1=Sector Erase suspended *1 PS, 1=Sector Program suspended*1 SLE, 1=Sector Lockdown & Lockdown State commands enabled RSTE, 1=Reset command enabled Reserved Reserved Reserved Note: 1. AT25DF081A bits 1 and 2 are Reserved for future use and = 0. P/N: AN0221 6 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 6-3. Manufacturer ID and Device ID Manufacturer IDs are different. This permits software to identify the device manufacturer. The Device IDs are different between both families. The same command is used to read the different IDs. Table 6-4: Manufacturer and Device ID Command Type 4Mb 8Mb RDID 9Fh 32Mb 64Mb Macronix MX25L_35E C2h/20h/13h C2h/20h/14h C2h/20h/16h C2h/20h/17h Atmel AT25DF_A 1Fh/44h/01h 1Fh/45h/01h 1Fh/47h/01h 1Fh/48h/00h 7. Summary The Macronix MX25L_06E and Atmel AT25DF_A have similar commands, functions, and features. Additionally, the supported package types have identical footprints and nearly identical pinout definitions. A more detailed analysis should be done if any of the “special” functions not supported by the Macronix flash are used, such as the Atmel 32KB erase size, or the Individual Block Protection. Commands to access and program the OTP area are different as well. If common features are used in standard traditional modes, the comparing may need only minimal software modification. 8. References Table 8-1 shows the datasheet versions used for comparison in this application note. For the most current, detailed specification, please refer to the Macronix Website at http://www.macronix.com Table 8-1: Datasheet Version Datasheet MX25L4006E MX25L8006E MX25L3206E MX25L6406E AT25DF041A AT25DF081A AT25DF321A AT25DF641A P/N: AN0221 Location Website Website Website Website Website Website Website Website 7 Data Issued FEB. 10, 2012 FEB. 10, 2012 FEB. 23, 2012 JUN. 13, 2012 09/2008 08/2010 12/2009 05/2012 Version Rev. 1.3 Rev. 1.2 Rev. 1.4 Rev. 1.5 Rev. 3668D Rev. 8715B Rev. 3686D Rev. 8693B Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E 9. Appendix Table 9-1 shows the basic part number and package information cross reference between Macronix MX25L_06E and Atmel AT25DF_A parts. Table 9-1: Part Number Cross Reference Density 4Mb 8Mb 32Mb 64Mb Macronix Part No. Atmel Part No. Package Dimension MX25L4006EM1I-12G AT25DF041A-SSH-B/T 8-SOP 150 mil MX25L4006EM2I-12G AT25DF041A-SH-B/T 8-SOP 209 mil MX25L4006EZNI-12G AT25DF041A-MH-Y/T 8-WSON 6x5mm MX25L8006EM1I-12G AT25DF081A-SSH-B/T 8-SOP 150 mil MX25L8006EM2I-12G AT25DF081A-SH-B/T 8-SOP 209 mil MX25L8006EZNI-12G AT25DF081A-MH-Y/T 8-WSON 6x5mm MX25L3206EM2I-12G AT25DF321A-SH-B/T 8-SOP 209 mil MX25L3206EZNI-12G AT25DF321A-MH-Y/T 8-WSON 6x5mm MX25L6406EM2I-12G AT25DF641A-SH-B/T 8-SOP 209 mil 10. Revision History Revision Description Date 1.0 Initial Release MAR. 19, 2013 P/N: AN0221 8 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013 APPLICATION NOTE Comparing Atmel AT25DF_A with Macronix MX25L_06E Except for customized products which have been expressly identified in the applicable agreement, Macronix's products are designed, developed, and/or manufactured for ordinary business, industrial, personal, and/or household applications only, and not for use in any applications which may, directly or indirectly, cause death, personal injury, or severe property damages. In the event Macronix products are used in contradicted to their target usage above, the buyer shall take any and all actions to ensure said Macronix's product qualified for its actual use in accordance with the applicable laws and regulations; and Macronix as well as it’s suppliers and/or distributors shall be released from any and all liability arisen therefrom. Copyright© Macronix International Co., Ltd. 2013. All rights reserved, including the trademarks and tradename thereof, such as Macronix, MXIC, MXIC Logo, MX Logo, Integrated Solutions Provider, NBit, Nbit, NBiit, Macronix NBit, eLiteFlash, HybridNVM, HybridFlash, XtraROM, Phines, KH Logo, BE-SONOS, KSMC, Kingtech, MXSMIO, Macronix vEE, Macronix MAP, Rich Au-dio, Rich Book, Rich TV, and FitCAM. The names and brands of third party referred thereto (if any) are for identification purposes only For the contact and order information, please visit Macronix’s Web site at: http://www.macronix.com P/N: AN0221 9 Ver. 1 Mar 19, 2013