On determining a viable path to resilience at exascale,

$
$
!
"
!
"#$%
&'()
*+
$#&)))
),'-
'.
$#%%
/
0+
1))#)))
&'&
" #
$%
#
&
"
'(
#$
"
")*
&
+,
,,-.,-" /0,120.3
4
,
',5
67(
8
4
$$9
!
"!
#
$ &'
( '
%
)*+
./#0
1
) 232
2
./+'
1+4
)2+4
)-2+4
./
2
./7 +'
) 1+4
85/6
227
+
('
56
1+4
*,&-+
56
1+4
"93
94
5964
/
5/
6
5/
6
:4;
$$
#
"$'
(
$
"$'
(
1
:/;
56
7#
1+
1
<
= #
1+
1+
<
$:'>>?>(
$$2:=7
+:= 2@@
+
"#
1
1+
A
>:'>?>('8$
+8$(
B "#
17
1+
A1
#
7
177
C
77+
"#
17
1+
<
$+
"#
1
1+
A
"
77
(
4< +$=,#
77
'!>=+>:(
=
2
#
# '
(
!
3-
2
,
)
$
)
$
1
--
4
--
4
2
,
)
&
77
#
&
)
,
$
+
&
56>7
&?7 3@
6
:
27
! >=+>:
2<5
6
:
4A
$%#
%#"#
DEAD-#
!"#
5
:/;
56
!
7"
"#
17
1
</A7A1
>:$
3
"
B@1BF%
/
;<$;
! 7
'
G7H (
>#7
!$ !$(
!$#A
#=
#A
#
7"7
$
$
&#
&# I
!"#
"
J1
"
#
!'
" #()'
A @
5A !! >=+>:+>$
K >:$
K J'7L(
K =0 "
2/<
;
,2
:
#7B'
(
"!+#
"!+#
! #""
#""
7
$ #
7
7
7
787 "
## *
*
#(
#( #"
#"
("(
("(
"(,
"(,
!
! % $"+
#-
#()#+
%
;)
>7
#
3? "@
@ #<
5ADDA,#7
M5M#7
AE
<7
NM
<7
$ !$7
$ B7
DA, "7
N5M
"7
7.8
798
7.8
798
$0.43/8
*
6
.
$)
;2#
;2
#"
#
'
8>C$
M.D
5N
(
1A5, ! !
- #
M,, .N
$$
7
#>$
#97: @
2
>:
:L'"
(
1A
#7/?
A3
: !
""
1
EA
$
+
>=@
?
7
?
#97
F*
7
7
'
(
+ !"# L$
"
C)A
>
" : !"
F"9-"
$1
56
:#
$#
&
)71 ?
#1
#"
#7
#I
>
##
=
#
#
"
)
!$#
" -
#
A
#I !1 7
7
1
$(
:/;
5*6
!!
L5$N$
'5$N$;7(/
"
3
!5$N$
"/$?>3
F*'O(/A$03
"
ED-
-
N-
-
1
E5-
-
-
-
1
,-
,-
D-
M-
1
N,-
5-
-
N,-
:
9,-
:
'
:
<
(
$&
0//
</7>
: 1
: /L7I
2?03
/A$03
F
7
@
!
!
8
7
7' !(
!
/L72053
L
#7
L7# A
'$2(
F*12:=5-
2 /$
03
$5
/7A >
@
<
7
$ 7+ 7 '+(
# 7
$2I
$!
$/
/7 ;
/B+0
!#-
!
%!
?8
D-
-
?>C
.-
-
-
-
$FLLN2
5@;
MA,@&
#
$$
L$
71
7
$"
7C< 526
&,7
A J
771
7 E-
1
5A 9
7
I&
NA 1
7
$%
/
>7
@
=
'
(
"$
6 "'(
=
#
$
" 27
:
, #
"7
!
!
!
)
/
L
:
L$
=
$
J $
2
K 1
17
1#1A
$
#
$
/
##
#
"
7
7
!
&&#
#
"
#
:
$
N&#
/
=7L$
1
$
1
000//
>7
@
, !
"!!
!
!
:"
#
:
"
, %
(
:
C71
#
2'25N(
"
#
7$
"
7
"
7
"
A
+POP
#+"
1
K "
7
K 7
/ " &
/;
%'
'
%
%
1#
7
N$
A
5
#//
?4
!2
>
" N$
7 5$
/
A /;)#
L$7"
'+#
(
!
#!
"
A #
/=
67
4,'
.1D..
(
J
5AN@
')#AMM1DM(
L$ 4
67 ?
!
(!&
J
2#
L$5-71
'$2
(
%
A #
/=
67
4,'
.1D..
(
J
5AN@
')#AMM1DM(
L$ 4
.+#/
0")#1
(# 23
4
# +
67?
!
(!&
J
2#
L$5-71
'$2
(
1)
$7+ A0 >)@
7#
#
$
7
>
"
A $22
##
5A $2
L 7
$2
7
!
###
5NM,D
! 7K > $2#
$
&&! K :#K "
1$
#
8K =$?A>
&77
#
#
$
MED,5
"
7<
!#71
,-
#
77
1
"
07#
0 #>)@
#A$
#
'2(
Q#
Q
L$#
/$3
##
7/$$3
'2K 2(2
"
$
$
5N#A5M
1"#A%
$
11
"
07#
0 #56
7
#
;7A
L$;
'L
9M(/$3
$
$7
'
(
$
"
$
;
$
"
1(
"
07#
0 #5*6
!
#
="
#7
"
*
6
?
6
$A
E.
@
#75+ '5$(
"
#717
=
R
#7
D,
'$AD$(
#
1&
!
#
17
# !!
! &
- #
A EA:
1 !
!
! #
#A S # !$1
#7
S ;
7
"9-"
!) # #
5$;
5$;&
A
$2$2
'71:=1 !(
"
*
#17A
#1
7
7
$2
7
>:1#
! 1:
15
:%/
$A2!L?$71 "
2!L2L85,L:5,DDM12L85.L:5,.N 12L=,!:55 5,1?$5N , 1M5N1M5ED,N1,.
E1E,.N1EN E.
2!L2L=MEM=>.,'$?>(12!L2L=,!:55 5,'!:?>(1>>D. .ME'>>(
?$C6AB1
=A?7&1
F7'!:?>(1
AB#1
JAJ1
2A16AL
!:?>
L71
$>A$
>> 7
#
$?>J1:
7"
:
:
1/
5-6:;
<
2
0D E
>:
" 7
#1L:
% '>>(
>:'
(
6
:
7
BA.A1$>:
7
K 2#A"
K 7
"'
(1
1
K =
#
#
2
$
:7
'( $A
! 1B= 51 1$>C:
1>$7
=2+
! '
(
6
11
1#7
1"
?$
"
7
>
6
$
7
$ !)
?
=
#
K 7
1%
5)6
"
7
PTC L$LP$=:L?2'
1
( AT
K>
"#
1 7
K#A
A
7
""T
P J'
( 77
K 7#
KC1
A 7
# .
5)5(. #4
# P?L@P J'(
P JP:LT'(
()