TISP® Terms and Letter Symbols Introduction Thyristor-based overvoltage protectors for telecom systems were first introduced in the late 1970s. The characteristics of thyristor SPDs (Surge Protective Devices) are very different than the normal SCR (Silicon Controlled Rectifier) and TRIAC (Triode for AC Control) type thyristors. In many cases the standard thyristor terms, definitions and test circuits were inadequate for thyristor SPDs. This situation led to many manufacturers and users “inventing” terms or using terms from other device types for the description of the thyristor SPD parameters. Manufacturers of avalanche or zener breakdown diodes used for TVS (Transient Voltage Suppression) applications adopted TVS terms. Manufacturers of SIDAC® (Silicon Diode for AC, in Japan a registered trademark of Shindengen) type thyristor devices which are typically used for discharge lamp ignition, often used SIDAC® terms. Manufacturing testing was another problem area; standard thyristor testers could not cope with thyristor SPD measurement and manufacturers had to either commission special test equipment or build it themselves. The lack of a common nomenclature and test conditions caused frustration for designers and users who wanted to compare and evaluate products. The first comprehensive standard on thyristor SPD terms, letter symbols, definitions and test circuits was the result of the IEEE Surge Protective Devices Committee (SPDC) authorizing the development of C62.37 - 1996 (IEEE Standard Test Specification for Thyristor Diode Surge Protective Devices), which was published in August 1997. To further the understanding of how thyristor SPD parameters are used in the design of protection systems, the IEEE SDPC has now released a companion publication called C62.37.1 (IEEE Guide for the Application of Thyristor Surge Protective Devices). The purpose of this review is to provide a cross-reference between some of the common non-standard parameter sets and the C62.37 parameters. This review is not intended to replace or summarize the IEEE C62.37 publications, and interested parties are encouraged to study these comprehensive standards. Letter Symbols The letter symbol, read right to left, usually gives the parameter term. The first part of the symbol is the prime quantity. Some examples are: V = voltage I = current P = power C = capacitance The first subscripted letter indicates the operating condition of the thyristor. Some examples are: D = off state (BR) = breakdown T = on state R = reverse Note that the breakdown condition has parenthesis around the two letters, BR. This is to ensure that the two letters are read together rather than separately. In addition, the first subscripted letter can also indicate a specific point. Some examples are: (BO) = breakover S = switching H = holding For ratings, the second subscript letter indicates the type of rating. These letters are: R = repetitive S = non-repetitive (surge) The final subscript letter(s) may indicate a limit value, e.g. M = peak (maximum). In addition, there are some alternative subscript letters and some subscript letters which have been established through historical use. Examples are: o = off state as an alternative to “D” in capacitance symbols PP = Peak (im) Pulse current The above list is not comprehensive and readers are referred to C62.37. Only fixed voltage thyristor SPDs are covered here. Gated thyristor SPDs are also available and the additional parameters needed for this type of protector are covered by C62.37. OCTOBER 2000 Specifications are subject to change without notice. TISP® Terms and Letter Symbols Letter Symbols (continued) To deduce a letter symbol term, the convention is to read the symbol from right to left as in the following examples: VD = Off-state, D, voltage, V ID = Off-state, D , current, I VDRM = Peak, M, repetitive, R, off-state, D, voltage, V V(BO) = Breakover, (BO) , voltage, V IPPS = Non-repetitive, S, peak pulse, PP, current, I ITSM = Peak, M, non-repetitive, S, on-state, T , current, I IT = On-state, T, current, I Electrical Characteristic Curves Thyristor SPD current parameters cover a range from a few nanoamps to hundreds of amps. To represent this on a linear scale is impossible, so the current scale used for the characteristic voltage-current curves is non-linear. The distorted scale is chosen to illustrate specific regions: very low current parameters in the nanoamp to milliamp area for the off-state condition, hundreds of milliamps for breakover, switching and holding points, amps for on-state voltage measurements, tens of amps for a.c. ratings and hundreds of amps for impulse ratings. A similar situation exists for thyristor SPD voltages. This is a simpler situation with volts to tens of volts for the on-state region, a specific region for any d.c. off-state current test and a specific voltage band for the breakdown region. Figure 1 shows the result for one voltagecurrent quadrant. There are four regions to the switching characteristic; off-state, breakdown, switching (from breakdown region, from on-state region) and on-state. The breakdown region is often re-entrant (reduces in voltage with increasing current, then increases in voltage) as it is the breakdown of an internal open-base transistor structure. Higher voltage Thyristor SPDs, e.g., 300 V breakdown, can show re-entrant levels of 20 V. The high current end of the breakdown region terminates at the switching point. The peak voltage point in the breakdown region will always be higher in voltage than the switching point. +i Quadrant I Impulse Rating Switching Characteristic On-state Region AC Rating Switching Point On-state Voltage Measurement Switching Region Holding Measurement Breakover Point Breakdown Region Off-state Current Measurement +v -i Off-state Region Figure 1. Thyristor SPD Switching Quadrant Regions Several manufacturers approximate the characteristic curve by three straight lines, Figure 2. In working with this reduced form, there are several points to be remembered. First, the variation of off-state current is not resistive as shown, but tends to be independent of off-state voltage until the breakdown region is approached. Second, with a straight line for the breakdown region, the re-entrant voltage reduction is not obvious. Third, at the high current termination of the breakdown region, there isn’t any differentiation between the breakover and switching points. Fourth, the increase of on-state voltage as the holding point is approached is not shown. OCTOBER 2000 Specifications are subject to change without notice. TISP® Terms and Letter Symbols Electrical Characteristic Curves (continued) +i Quadrant I Impulse Rating Switching Characteristic On-state Region AC Rating Breakover Point On-state Voltage Measurement Switching Region Holding Measurement Breakdown Region Off-state Current Measurement +v Off-state Region -i Figure 2. Straight Line Approximation of Thyristor SPD Switching Quadrant Regions Figure 3 shows the essential ratings and characteristic values for the voltage current characteristic from C62.37. One C62.37 rating, the peak repetitive on-state current, ITRM, is not shown in Figure 3 as this would be normally covered by the long term, 1000 s, I TSM value. Most data sheets will give two breakover voltage values (V(BO)); one for a.c. conditions and the other for impulse conditions. The impulse V(BO) test conditions may be a specific waveshape of given peak current, IPP, or an equivalent di/dt ramp (See M. J. Maytum, K. Rutgers & D. Unterweger “Lightning surge voltage limiting and survival properties of telecommunication thyristor-based protectors”, IEEE/ESD Association, 1994 Electrical Overstress/Electrostatic Discharge Symposium Proceedings., ISBN 1-878303-51-1, EOS-16, pp 4.6.1-4.6.11, Las Vegas, Nevada). +i Quadrant I IPPS Switching Characteristic ITSM V(BO) , I(BO) IT VT IH IDRM ID +v VD VDRM -i Figure 3. Thyristor SPD Switching Quadrant Regions with Letter Symbols Comparison of TISP® and C62.37 Parameters Bourns TISP® (Totally Integrated Surge Protector) thyristor SPDs are designed and manufactured at its Power Innovations facility. Production of these devices started in 1982 and today, both fixed voltage and gated products are produced. The standard TISP® parameters align with C62.37 apart from the impulse current rating parameter. The characteristic curves are shown in Figure 4 and the table below lists the single parameter difference. OCTOBER 2000 Specifications are subject to change without notice. TISP® Terms and Letter Symbols Comparison of TISP® and C62.37 Parameters (continued) +i +i Quadrant I ITSM Quadrant I IPPS TISP® C62.37 Switching Characteristic Switching Characteristic ITSM ITSM V(BO) , I(BO) IT VT IH V(BO) , I (BO) IT VT IH IDRM IDRM ID +v VD ID +v VDRM VD -i VDRM -i Figure 4. Comparison of TISP® and C62.37 Switching Quadrant Parameters Differences between TISP® and C62.37 Terms and Letter Symbols TISP® C62.37 TERM SYMBOL Non-repetitive peak on-state pulse current ITSP TERM SYMBOL Non-repetitive peak pulse current IPPS Comparison of Manufacturer A and C62.37 Parameters The fixed voltage products from this manufacturer originally were negative breakdown slope devices, but now the majority are positive breakdown slope devices like the Bourns TISP®. A straight line characteristic approximation is used and there are several term and symbol differences from the C62.37 standard. The characteristic curves are shown in Figure 5 and the table below lists the parameter differences. +i +i Quadrant I IPP Quadrant I IPPS Manufacturer A Switching Characteristic ITSM C62.37 Switching Characteristic ITSM VS , IS IT VT IH V(BO) , I (BO) IT VT IH IDRM IDRM +v +v -i VDRM VDRM -i Figure 5. Comparison of Manufacturer A and C62.37 Switching Quadrant Parameters . OCTOBER 2000 Specifications are subject to change without notice. TISP® Terms and Letter Symbols Differences between Manufacturer A and C62.37 Terms and Letter Symbols Manufacturer A TERM TISP® C62.37 SYMBOL Peak pulse current IPP TERM SYMBOL SYMBOL Non-repetitive peak pulse current IPPS ITSP Peak one cycle surge current ITSM Non-repetitive peak on-state current ITSM ITSM Peak off-state voltage VDRM Repetitive peak off-state voltage VDRM VDRM Leakage current IDRM Repetitive peak off-state current IDRM IDRM Switching voltage VS Breakover voltage V(BO) V(BO) Switching current IS Breakover current I(BO) I(BO) Users are advised to carefully check parameter test conditions and measurement technique to confirm the equivalence of the above. Comparison of Manufacturer B and C62.37 Parameters The use of VR type letter symbols and terms like stand-off are a heritage from TVS diodes. Where a VBR value is quoted, in most cases the TISP® V DRM value is equivalent. A combination of two straight lines and a curved line are used for the characteristic curve. There are several term and symbol differences from the C62.37 standard. The characteristic curves are shown in Figure 6 and the table below lists the parameter differences. +i +i Quadrant I IPP Quadrant I IPPS Manufacturer B Switching Characteristic ITSM C62.37 Switching Characteristic ITSM VBO , IBO IT VT IH V(BO) , I (BO) IT VT IH IRM IR IBR +v VRM -i VR V(BR) , I (BR) IDRM VBR ID +v VDRM VD -i Figure 6. Comparison of Manufacturer B and C62.37 Switching Quadrant Parameters Differences between Manufacturer B and C62.37 Terms and Letter Symbols Manufacturer B TERM TISP® C62.37 SYMBOL TERM SYMBOL SYMBOL Non-repetitive peak pulse current IPPS ITSP ITSM Non-repetitive peak on-state current ITSM ITSM Leakage current at stand-off voltage IRM Off-state current ID ID Stand-off voltage VRM Off-state voltage VD VD Peak pulse current Non repetitive surge peak on-state current IPP Continuous reverse current IR Repetitive peak off-state current IDRM IDRM Continuous reverse voltage VR Repetitive peak off-state voltage VDRM VDRM Breakdown current IBR Breakdown current I(BR) I(BR) Breakdown voltage VBR Breakdown voltage V(BR) V(BR) Breakover current IBO Breakover current I(BO) I(BO) Breakover voltage VBO Breakover voltage V(BO) V(BO) Users are advised to carefully check parameter test conditions and measurement technique to confirm the equivalence of the above . OCTOBER 2000 Specifications are subject to change without notice. TISP® Terms and Letter Symbols Comparison of Manufacturer C and C62.37 Parameters A combination of a straight line and a curved line are used for the characteristic curve. There are several term and symbol differences from the C62.37 standard. The characteristic curves are shown in Figure 7 and the table below lists the parameter differences. +i +i Quadrant I IPP Quadrant I IPPS Manufacturer C Switching Characteristic ITSM C62.37 Switching Characteristic ITSM VBO, I BO IT VT IH V(BO) , I (BO) IT VT IH IDM IDRM +v +v VDRM VDM -i -i Figure 7. Comparison of Manufacturer C and C62.37 Switching Quadrant Parameters Comparison of Manufacturer C and C62.37 Parameters Manufacturer C TERM TISP® C62.37 SYMBOL TERM SYMBOL SYMBOL Non-repetitive peak pulse current IPPS ITSP ITSM Non-repetitive peak on-state current ITSM ITSM Off-state current IDM Repetitive peak off-state current IDRM IDRM Maximum off-state voltage VDM Repetitive peak off-state voltage VDRM Breakover current IBO Breakover current VDRM I(BO) Breakover voltage VBO Breakover voltage V(BO) V(BO) IH IH Peak pulse current Peak on-state surge current Hold current Ipp IH Holding current I(BO) Users are advised to carefully check parameter test conditions and measurement technique to confirm the equivalence of the above. OCTOBER 2000 Specifications are subject to change without notice.