# $
%&' %(()
!
"
1
*
+
$ ,
"
-
"
0
0
0
/
"
0
"
"
"
"
/
"
0
0
"
0
"
"
/
0
1
0
"
"
"
."
. "
/
0
"
0
"
"
"
"
/
2
"
"
2 ,3
0
4
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
5
/
0"
0
4
"
"
"
" ' /0/'
/
/
6
4"
0
3
*
789:'…'
8 "
<2 3 8
/
"
<2738
<2 38(
<2>3 8
"
-
;8
'
"
7
"
"
'
"
"
0
"
0
."
"
"
=
27'<3/
4
*
5
<2>3
–"
-
/
4
.
"
0
<2 3 ?<2 3
/
<2>3
.
<2 3@<2 3A<2
3/
.
0
."
0
"
0
"
/
5
*
5
,
–"
"
/
4
"
6826:'B'6 3
27'<3
0
6 !'
C 8:6 8<273'
C 6 ?<2 3
7/
0
"
"
"
"
.
/
6
–"
0
5
4 <2>3
<2
"
"
2
7
9D;3 . <2 3 A<2
<2>3 "
" "
/
"
" /
"
4
'
"
0
0
.
/
3
9D;3 . <2 3
27'<3
.
7
#
'
0
"
0
+
"
0
"
"
"
" "
'
" "
/
/
"
"
"
0 /
8
,
0
G6
G
5
0 ,
0 "
" 2F- 3
4
,
#
!
6
"
0H
$
I
2 ,3
"
"
/
0 , / 2F 3
"
"$
"
0
E
$
0
0
"
0 F- /
9
G"
"
F-
"
"
'
0
1
"
"
" ’
0
'
"
,
"
" "
/
"
1
"
"
,
"
/
"
"
.
,
/
0
"
"
/
10
,
,– "
"
,
/
"
""
G
0
/
0
0
,/
"
"
0.
"
0"
0
"
'
"
"
'
0
/
"
0
."
1
0
$/
11
,
"
!
* "
!
*
2:JJ:3
2:JJF3
5 2:JJK3' 5
2%(((3' 5 2%(((3
' "
$ 2%((%3
" '
'* " .
H
""
"
2%(()3
L
$
0 2#-3
2%(()3
,
L
02
2%((&3'
#-3
12
!
2 !-3
"
"
M '
0
#
0
/
$
6
$
/
.
/
"
6
6
"
0
/
13
!/
7
G"
7 89:'…' ;/
/
"
"
"$
.
5
""
0"
0 8
I(.
4
E
%
"
1
I
"
14
!-2"
'
'
7'
"
/3
"
I(@
0
GN
I
"$
/
!"
"
O+
/P
15
0
.
0
.
"
7
"
"
$
" ' 6"
.
03
"
/
!-
"
/
"
"
L 2L .
/
16
!
"
- "
– "$
"$
+
"
8:
.
9 4:
( 8
0( 8(
!-- 2734
. .
2- 3
'
6
2:JQR3
4
$
=
;8%
8%
23
2(3
S 8('B
8('B' 9I E @0 ;
8% 2 3 8('B'
2 3A 2(3
8:'B'
23
0 8('B'
17
!-- 273
I:E
0: I%E
0% B I E
0
T273
0
6
2I(@I:@B@I 3 E
20:@B@0 3
7/
9:'B' T273;
:
"
IE
0
"
18
-
- "
.
U
GN
0
0
4 I(@I:@B@I T273
0: @ 0%@B@0 T273/
V
""
' ""
4
"
0"
O 0P
GN
W T273
I
0/
. .
/
19
G6
!
(
:
%
F
&
R
4
I
0
IE
0
:((
:%
R%
&(
&(
:Q(
(
:/)R
R
:
(/&
(/J
..
K/QK82%/K%3%
:(/&82F/%%3%
&(82K/F%3%
:((8:(%
%((82:&/:&3%
I(@I:@///@I
0(@0:@///@0
..
K&
%&/F82&/JF3%
%K/F
20
G6
2"
/3 –
-
- "
9:'%;/
!
:
%
('&'Q…/
!
F
&
('Q':K'…/
!
R
(':K'F%…/
" "
G
:K
, "
4 I(
0
$
/
:K
:K
&
$ 2 :8 %8&3
Q
$ 2 F8 &8Q3
$ 2 R8:K3
$/
"
&
$ 2 (8&3/
21
-
-
0
0
2-
QR
"
KX
/
6
!
:JQR/3
"
"
0
"
"
"
/#
0
/
'
%X 2
U
/
!
.
QR/3
"
"
22
,
"
H
1
"
.
2%((&34
"
5
"
!!2%(()3
. "
""
0
–
' "
G N"
1
"
.
/
"
"
/
2#-3 "
0
/
23
"$
"
6
"
4
0
Y
!
:
%
F
&
R
G N %/K% F/%% K/F% :( :&/:&
:K
%
&
Q
Q
I(8(
- .
I(8:((
!
24
*
+
<2 38 !-- 2 3
#
'
!-- 2 34
5
S
9(;
8% 2 3
2 3A 2(3
23
0
'
7'
"
9I E @0 ;
9(;
9(;
9(;
<2 38(/
25
*
27'<3
2"
"
/3
0
/
<2>3
<2>3
0
.
.
'
0
"
0
"
<273
"
0/
0
"
/
0
Y
26
!
4
"
"
"
0
27'<3
/
"
.
0
/
27
,
"
4
6
"
"
"
"
0"
"
7
I 8I
"
8
'
0
0
':
"
T273/
'
I(/
I(
.
I(/
28
G6
!
I
0
( :(( (
: :% :/)R
% R%
R
F &(
:
& &( (/&
R :Q( (/J
4
Z
2Z I(@I 3E @0
I(8(
&
&
(/F(R%
(/KJ&Q
:)/:F 2)/)R3
R(/F)2FF3
Q
Q
:F 2:F3
Q/% 2Q/%3
:K
%R/KR 2%R/KR3
29
"
"
Y
4
"
,
#
"
4
0
"
'
"
"
0
I(/
30
7
L 0 2%(()3 2#-3 – "
0
.
"
/
0
"
.
" /
0
" "
" U /
!"
"
00
'
"
’
0
31
,
"
!
M/M ' /
2#-3 – "
1
"
'
M/ * "
0
"
$2%((K3
0/
32
,
"
-
0
" ,
'
"
"
"
/
G"
"
2
"
3/
"
"
#
"
0
"
“ 0”
'
"
6
.
"
"
/
$
0
Y
33
5 "
789:'…' ;
7
"
"
0
-
G"
6
"
"
=
/
8 E [:/
:8 (W
:
%
…
6
"
W
@:8(
34
,
“ 0”
2 38
'
"
"
2 38
/
2 38 2 3E 2 3/
"
"
'
"
0
"
0-
"
<2 38 2 3E
2:. 2 338 2 3E
2 2 3. 2 33/
<2 38(/
27'<3
"
0
/
35
"
+
<2 3 <2 3
<2 3[<2 3
<2 3
'
<2 3 <2
<2 3[ <2
7 "
3 <2 3/
3[<2 3/
<2 3
' / /'
' .
<2 38<2 3' <2 3[<2 3
8
"
<2 3W<2 3/
36
"
<2 3
.
<2 3
' / /'
<2
0
"
3 <2 3@<2 3'
"
"
0
.
0
/
37
Is the cost function <2•3 concave ?
"$ 2
!-3
"
<2 38 2 3E
2 2 3. 2 33
" "
0
" '
0'
"
'
.
/
"$ 0 Y 7 \
2
6
3
"
"
38
How do we prove that (N,V) is balanced?
, "
#
" "
"
'
0
27'<3
0 4
#
"
2:3 #2738<273
2%3 #2 3 <2 3
7
2F3 #2•3 " "
2
.
'
0
27'#3
"
"
27'#3
"
"
"
/
/
<2•3
#2•3
04
3
" /
"
27'<3/
39
The game (N,W)
#2 38
#2 3
"
9<2 3 4
7;
"
#2 3 8 (' #273 8 <273'
#2 3 <2 3
7/
' #2•3
#2 9 ;3 #2 3 2
' < 2 •3
3/
"
.
"
1 /
0' / /'
40
Is W(•) concave?
! " '
#2 38
#2•3
.
#2•3 " "
, "
9<2 3 4
Y
Y
7;
.
/
41
The Good News
4
27'#3
27'<3
0
0
"
"
0
#2•3
%
=
"
"
.
"
0
/
"
4
"
0
"
27'#3/
!"#
"
"
!$#
&
42
How to find an allocation in the
core?
7 6
"
82
:'
%'…'
5
0
' ( " ) *!
!'
"
2
"
3
"
+!…!
'
27'#3
"
27'#3 4
/
"
2:
3
,#
% " ) *! +!…!
#
!
% *,
!"#
!
!$#
&
"
6
2:J):3
\
/
"
0
"
2:JQ:33
43
,
"
+
:'
:
0
"
7'
0
%
%'
T
9<2 3 4
<2 : %38<2 :3/
0
7;
"
' T
/
/
44
,
"
0
T
4 '
7/
4 #2 3
T/
(4
T8 = ’87] /
" 8 6 ’=
:4 #
<2 T3 <29" ;3
T T 9" ;' ’
’ ] 9" ;/
’
" 8 6 ’/
' " 8(
0
%/ G
/
%4 #2 38<2 T3/ !
#2 3
T/
45
G6
<
9:;
9%;
9F;
9:'%;
9:'F;
9%'F;
9:'%'F;
J
R
:
:&
:(
K
:R
:(
:(
:(
%(
%(
%(
F(
(/J
(/R
(/:
(/)
(/R
(/F
(/R
T
J 9:'%'F;
: 9%'F;
:E
J
9F;
)E
F 9:'%'F;
: 9:'%'F;
FE
) 9%'F;
: 9:'%'F;
#
:
FE
)
:E
J
:
:
FE
)
:
46
G6
-
– 6
"
"
6:
6%
6F
:'%'F
:
(
(
:'F'%
:
(
(
%':'F
&E
)
FE
)
(
%'F':
&E
)
FE
)
(
F':'%
QE
J
(
:E
J
F'%':
&E
)
%(E
KF
:E
J
47
+
"
"
# $
"
U
/
48