www.fairchildsemi.com AN-6206 Primary-Side Synchronous Rectifier (SR) Trigger Solution for Dual-Forward Converter Introduction In any switching converter, rectifier diodes are used to obtain DC output voltage. The conduction loss of diode rectifier contributes significantly to the overall power losses in a power supply; especially in low output voltage applications, such as personal computer (PC) power supplies. The conduction loss of a rectifier is proportional to the product of its forward-voltage drop and the forward conduction current. Using synchronous rectification (SR) where the rectifier diode is replaced by MOSFET with proper on resistance (RdsON), the forward-voltage drop of a synchronous rectifier can be lower than that of a diode rectifier and, consequently, the rectifier conduction loss can be reduced. signals for the secondary-side SR driver FAN6206. FAN6210 also provides drive signal for the primary-side power switches by using an output signal from the PWM controller. FAN6210 can be combined with any PWM controller that can drive a dual-forward converter. To obtain optimal timing for the SR drive signals, transformer winding voltage is also monitored. To improve light-load efficiency, green-mode operation is employed, which disables the SR turn-on trigger signal, minimizing gate drive power consumption at light-load condition. This application note describes the design procedure of SR circuit using FAN6210 and FAN6206. The guidelines for printed circuit board (PCB) layout and a design example with experiment results are also presented. The highly integrated FAN6210 is a primary-side SR controller for dual-forward converter that provides control Vin Vac PFC stage Cbulk Lo Drv Vo n:1 R8 Q2 D1 FAN6210 PWM control signal (From PWM controller) R2 1 XP GND 8 2 XN SOUT 7 3 SIN VDD 6 4 RDLY DET 5 R1 D5 D3 R6 Drv D4 R7 FAN6206 C1 R3 D2 1 LPC1GATE1 8 From power supply of PWM controller 2 LPC2 GND 7 R5 D6 R9 Q1 R4 3 SN GATE2 6 4 SP VDD 5 C2 PT Figure 1. Typical Application © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 www.fairchildsemi.com AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE 1. FAN6210 External Component Setting Figure 4 and Figure 5 show the detailed timing diagrams of XP and XN for the rising edge and falling edge of the SIN signal. The delay from the rising edge of SOUT to XP signal rising edge (tDLY_XP) is programmable using R1, as shown in Figure 1. The linear relationship between R1 and tDLY_XP is shown in Figure 6. Figure 2 and Figure 3 show the simplified schematic of two switch forward converters and their waveforms. The rectifying SR (SR1) should be turned on right after the primary-side MOSFETs are turned on. Then, SR1 should be turned off right before the primary-side MOSFETs are turned off. The freewheeling SR (SR2) should be turned on right after the primary-side MOSFETs are turned off. Then, SR2 should be turned off right before the primary-side MOSFETs are turned on. The primary-side SR trigger controller FAN6210 generates XN and XP signals, where XN rising edge triggers the turn-off of SR and XP rising edge triggers the turn-on of SR. FAN6210 generates XP and XN signals two times for each in one switching cycle and FAN6206 in the secondary side determines which SR MOSFET should be controlled for each XP and XN signals within one switching cycle. The transformer winding voltage is much higher than the voltage rating of FAN6210 during PWM turn-on time. Therefore, R2 and D1 are used to block the high voltage, as shown in Figure 1. Since there is a 400ns DET falling-edge detection window after SOUT falls to prevent mistriggering of XP in DCM operation, too large value of R2 does not trigger XP properly due to too large RC time delay. It is typical to use 10kΩ~33kΩ for R2. The other requirement for triggering XP signal is that the HIGH level of the DET signal must be higher than 3V. To shorten the falling time from HIGH level to LOW level, the breakdown voltage of Zener diode D2 is recommended as 5~6V. Figure 2. Simplified Circuit Diagram of Dual-Forward Converter Figure 4. Timing Diagram During PWM Rising Edge Figure 3. Key Waveforms of Dual-Forward Converter Figure 5. Timing Diagram During PWM Falling Edge © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 www.fairchildsemi.com 2 AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE To protect the XP and XN pins from transient voltage spikes; components R3, R4, D3, D4, D5, and D6 are necessary (shown in Figure 1). R3 and R4 are recommended as 10Ω. D3~D6 are chosen as Fairchild diode 1N4148. At the secondary side, R5 is connected between the SP and SN pins for reducing the overshoot caused by PT. The proper value of R5 is 1kΩ~10kΩ for most of applications. FAN6206 External Components Setting FAN6206 needs only four resistors to achieve winding detection and linear-predict control (LPC). Voltage divider with R6 and R7 detects the voltage across the drain-to-source terminal of Q1, while the other divider with R8 and R9 detects the voltage across the drain-to-source terminal of Q2. Figure 9 shows the typical waveform under CCM operation, which includes rectifying SR MOSFET drain voltage (Vds-R), freewheeling SR MOSFET drain voltage (Vds-F), inductor current (ILo), SR control signals (SP & SN), and SR gate signals. The detected signal on LPC1 and LPC2 pin determines the operation of synchronous rectification. Figure 6. Programmable Delay with Resistor R1 2. Pulse Transformer (PT) The differential SR control XP-XN is delivered from FAN6210 to FAN6206 through a pulse transformer (PT), as shown in Figure 7. For the proper signal transfer, the core should have high initial permeability (μi). To separate primary-side and secondary-side windings, isolation is also necessary. It is typical to have the same number of turns for the primary and secondary to maximize the coupling. As the inductance of the winding decreases, the magnetizing increases, causing the voltage drop in the primary winding, as shown in Figure 8. The HIGH level of XP or XN signal should be higher than 4V to ensure proper SR gate driving. Meanwhile, too many turns may increase the inter-winding capacitance and, therefore, the inductance value should be determined properly. Typically, the inductance value is recommended as 100μH~300μH. The voltage divider scale-down factors are defined as: RatioLPC1 = R7 R6 + R7 (1) RatioLPC2 = R9 R8 + R9 (2) 2.1 Rectifying SR Gate Drive Linear-predict control (LPC) is not essential for rectifying SR because rectifying SR is always turned off by the SN signal. Voltage divider with R6 and R7 is used to detect the HIGH/LOW status of Vds-R, as shown in Figure 9. The HIGH level threshold voltage for LPC1 is 2V, so the plateau voltage of LPC1 should be higher than 2V. To guarantee stable operation, the minimum plateau voltage of LPC1 is suggested to be 3V. However, LPC pin is a lowvoltage pin, so the proper operation range is from 3V to 5V. Therefore: Figure 7. Pulse Transformer Structure 3 < RatioLPC1 ⋅ Vin <5 n (3) where RatioLPC1 is specified in Equation 1, Vin is the input voltage for PWM stage, and n is the turn ratio between primary and secondary winding. Figure 8. Slope Difference Between Different Turn Number On XP Signal © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 www.fairchildsemi.com 3 AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE RatioLPC2 gets too much higher, freewheeling SR is still turned on after ILo decreases to zero. Therefore, negative ILo is generated. Abnormal voltage on VdsR is derived from negative ILo and exceeds the Vds rating of MOSFET in DCM operation. It’s important to determine RatioLPC2 properly. For normal LPC operation, the value of R7 and R9 are recommended as 4.7kΩ~15kΩ. R6 and R8 can be calculated according to proper RatioLPC1 and RatioLPC2. Vin n Vin n Vin n Figure 9. Typical Waveform in CCM Operation 2.2 Freewheeling SR Gate Drive Once the forward converter enters discontinuous conduction mode (DCM) at light-load condition, the current through the freewheeling SR decreases to zero before the turn-off command by XN signal is given. Thus, the current can flow in the reverse direction if the freewheeling SR is not turned off before the current changes direction. LPC function is necessary to turn off the free-wheeling SR before the output inductor current reaches zero in DCM operation. Figure 10. Typical Waveform in DCM Operation RatioLPC2 = is changed while Voltage divider with R8 and R9 determines the turn-off timing of freewheeling SR. For proper LPC operation, the LPC pin voltage should be normalized to the nominal output voltage. The scale-down factor of the voltage divider should be 1/VO. Gate drive of Freewheeling SR decreases SR is turned off later Figure 11. Typical Waveform of QR Operation (4) 2.3 VDD Section The power supply source of FAN6206 is provided from output voltage terminal (Vo). To keep FAN6206 away from output current interference, the VDD pin is suggested not to be connected to Vo directly. In PC power applications, the supervisor IC is applied to manage the protection of secondary side. Output terminal Vo is connected to the supervisor to achieve protection under abnormal conditions. Therefore, Vo detecting terminal of the supervisor IC can be used as the power source of the VDD pin. Adding a capacitor C2 between the VDD pin and the GND pin can keep the VDD pin away from noise. Adding a capacitor C1 is also recommended for the VDD pin of FAN6210. The recommended value for C1 and C2 is 100nF~1μF. Figure 10 shows the typical waveform in DCM operation. In proper designs, freewheeling SR is turned off before ILo decreases to zero. RatioLPC2 determines the internal charge current of LPC function. Figure 11 shows the relationship between RatioLPC2 and freewheeling SR gate drive signal. The voltage level detected by the LPC2 pin (Vo/n) determines the internal charge current ICHG. If RatioLPC2 becomes smaller, ICHG decreases. The voltage level of the VDD pin determines the internal discharge current IDISCHG. However, IDISCHG does not vary with RatioLPC2. Therefore, the discharging period is shortened. The turn-off instant of freewheeling SR gets earlier when RatioLPC2 gets lower. If © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 is fixed increases SR is turned off earlier For 12V output application, the proper value of RatioLPC2 is: 1 1 < RatioLPC2 < 11.5 12 R9 R8 + R9 www.fairchildsemi.com 4 AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE Printed Circuit Board Layout As indicated by 8, FAN6206 control circuits’ ground In Figure 12, the power traces are marked as bold lines. Good PCB layout improves power system efficiency, minimizes excessive EMI, and prevents the power supply from being disrupted during surge/ESD tests. Guidelines For PC power applications, the PFC/PWM combination controller is usually separated from main board and is applied at a daughter board. FAN6210 is also recommended to be placed on the same daughter board. As indicated by 1 and 2, FAN6210 control circuits’ ground should be connected together and to the GND pin of FAN6210 first, then the GND pin to ground of PFC/PWM combination controller. As indicated by 3 and 4, PFC/PWM combination controller’s ground and PWM MOSFETs’ ground are connected to the negative terminal of Cbulk. Keep trace 4 short, direct, and wide. A Y-cap between the primary and secondary is necessary for PC power applications. As indicated by 5 and 6, the Y-cap is suggested on the low-side, where it is between the negative terminal of Cbulk and case. Connecting trace 6 directly to case is helpful to surge immunity. According to the safety requirements, the creepage between the two pointed ends should be at least 5mm. The Y-cap should be far away from PT. should be connected together, then to the GND pin of FAN6206. As indicated by 9, the GND pin of FAN6206 should be connected to the source of Q1 and Q2 separately. Keeping trace 9 short and direct can maintain the ground level between MOSFET and GND pin closed. Thus, the SR control signal can be kept away from error triggering. As indicated by 10, the source terminals of Q1 and Q2 are connected to the negative terminal of Co. Keep trace 10 short, direct, and wide. As indicated by 11, Vo is connected to the supervisor IC. As indicated by 12, the power supply source of FAN6206’s VDD pin is connected to the detection terminal of supervisor IC. Trace 11 should be long and far away from Vo terminal. It’s helpful to prevent LPC mechanism from output current interference. As indicated by 7, the negative terminal of Co is connected to case directly. Figure 12. Layout Considerations © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 www.fairchildsemi.com 5 AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE Design Example The following example is a 12V/300W PC power supply, in which the dual-forward topology is used. As Figure 13 shows, the FAN4801 integrated CCM PFC/PWM combination controller is used as the controller for both PFC stage and PWM stage. Table 1. System Specification Input Input Voltage Range Line Frequency Range Output Voltage of PFC Stage (Vbulk) The basic system parameters are listed in Table 1.The twolevel Vbulk is derived from FAN4801. The typical voltage level for Vbulk is 380V; but under low-line and light-load condition, Vbulk is 310V for decreasing power loss at the PFC stage. The typical switching frequency (fs) is 65kHz for both PFC and PWM stage. Output Output Voltage (Vo) Output Power (Po) Typical Switching Frequency (fs) 12V 300W 65kHz In addition to low-line and light-load condition, Vbulk is boosted to 380V. The turn ratio n for of TX1 is 11, hence the Vds voltage during PWM turn-on period is 380/11=34.55V. According to Equation 4, RatioLPC2 = 1/11.5. The divided voltage on LPC2 is 3.00V. According to Equation 3, the plateau divided voltage on LPC1 during PWM turn-off period should be between 3V~5V. Select RatioLPC2 = 1/7.8, then the divided voltage is 4.43V. Select R9 = 10kΩ and R8 = 105kΩ, then R7 = 10kΩ and R6 = 68kΩ. Under low-line and light-load condition, Vbulk is decreased to 310V. The divided voltage on LPC2 is 2.45V, while the divided voltage on LPC1 is 3.61V. In a typical PC power application, multi-output is necessary. If the 12V output terminal is used to generate other output terminals, SG6520 can be the proper supervisor IC. The power supply of the supervisor is from 5V standby output terminal. Flyback topology is the general structure for standby power. The following measurements include standby loading. FAN6751 is chosen to be the PWM controller of standby stage. From the specification, all critical components are treated and final measurement results are given. Base on the design guideline, the critical parameters are calculated and summarized in Table 2. PFC stage (controlled by FAN4801) 90~264VAC 47~63Hz 310V / 380V + - =12V IPWM (To FAN4801) 1 LPC1GATE1 8 2 LPC2 GND 7 OPWM (From FAN4801) 1 XP GND 8 2 XN SOUT 7 3 SIN VDD 6 3 SN GATE2 6 4 SP VDD 5 Supervisor 4 RDLY DET 5 From VDD of FAN4801 Power supply is from 5V standby output Figure 13. Complete Circuit Diagram © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 www.fairchildsemi.com 6 AN-6206 Table 2. Part APPLICATION NOTE Bill of Materials Value Note Part Resistor Value Inductor R1 8.2kΩ 1/8W L1 73µH R2 10kΩ 1/4W L2 1.8µH R3 10Ω 1/8W R4 10Ω 1/8W D1 FR107 R5 2kΩ 1/8W D2 Zenor Diode/5.6V R6 68kΩ 1/8W D3 1N4148 R7 10kΩ 1/8W D4 1N4148 R8 105kΩ 1/8W D5 1N4148 R9 10kΩ 1/8W D6 1N4148 R10 10kΩ 1/8W D7 1N4148 R11 10kΩ 1/8W D8 1N4148 R12 4.7Ω 1/8W D9 UF1007 R13 4.7Ω 1/8W D10 UF1007 R14 10kΩ 1/8W MOSFET R15 10kΩ 1/8W Q1 FDP5800 R16 0.15Ω 2W Q2 FDP5800 R17 3kΩ 1/8W Q3 FCP20N60 R18 38.3kΩ 1/8W Q4 FCP20N60 R19 10kΩ 1/8W R20 1kΩ 1/8W Diode Transformer Capacitor TX1 66:6 Primary 20mH TX2 1:1 Primary 160μH TX3 1:1.2 Primary 300μH C1 100nF 50V C2 100nF 50V C3 470pF 25V U1 FAN6210 C4 100nF 50V U2 FAN6206 C5 270μF 450V U3 PC817 C6 1μF 50V U4 TL431 C7 3300μF 16V C8 3300μF 16V C9 4.7nF/250V Y-Capacitor © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 Note IC www.fairchildsemi.com 7 AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE Figure 14 and Figure 16 show the example design waveform. Figure 14 shows the typical SR driving signals and SR control signal SP-SN under CCM operation. Figure 16 shows that the freewheeling SR is turned off by the LPC mechanism under DCM operation. Figure 16. Freewheeling SR is Turned Off by LPC Mechanism Under DCM Operation Figure 14. SR Gate is Driven by Primary-Side Control Signal Under CCM Operation Figure 17. SIN Signal (Falling Edge) and SR Control Signal Table 4. Efficiency Measurements at VAC=115V on 300W PC Power with SRs (FDP5800) Figure 15. SIN Signal (Rising Edge) and SR Control Signal Table 3. Efficiency Measurements at VAC=115V on 300W PC Power with Schottky Diodes (FYP2006DN) Load Input Watts(W) Output Watts(W) Efficiency 100% 50% 20% 357.98 174.21 70.84 305.42 152.56 70.84 85.31% 87.57% 85.95% Load Input Watts (W) Output Watts (W) Efficiency Vs. Schottky Diode 100% 50% 20% 347.02 169.75 69.24 305.43 152.69 61.04 88.01% 89.94% 88.15% +2.70% +2.40% +2.20% Figure 15 and Figure 17 shows the SIN signal of FAN6210 and SR control signals of FAN6206 together. The efficiency test results are shown in Table 3 and Table 4. The significant difference between the SR MOSFET and the Schottky diode is shown in Table 4. © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 www.fairchildsemi.com 8 AN-6206 APPLICATION NOTE Related Resources FAN6210 — Primary-Side Synchronous Rectifier (SR) Trigger Controller for Dual Forward Converter FAN6206 — Highly Integrated Dual-Channel Synchronous Rectification Controller for Dual-Forward Converter FAN4801 — PFC/PWM Controller Combination FAN6751MR — Highly Integrated Green-Mode PWM Controller SG6520 — PC Power Supply Supervisors FDP5800 — N-Channel Logic Level PowerTrench® MOSFET 60V,80A, 6mΩ FCP20N60 / FCPF20N60 — 600V N-Channel MOSFET 1N/FDLL 914/A/B / 916/A/B / 4148 / 4448 — Small Signal Diode DISCLAIMER FAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTOR RESERVES THE RIGHT TO MAKE CHANGES WITHOUT FURTHER NOTICE TO ANY PRODUCTS HEREIN TO IMPROVE RELIABILITY, FUNCTION, OR DESIGN. FAIRCHILD DOES NOT ASSUME ANY LIABILITY ARISING OUT OF THE APPLICATION OR USE OF ANY PRODUCT OR CIRCUIT DESCRIBED HEREIN; NEITHER DOES IT CONVEY ANY LICENSE UNDER ITS PATENT RIGHTS, NOR THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS. LIFE SUPPORT POLICY FAIRCHILD’S PRODUCTS ARE NOT AUTHORIZED FOR USE AS CRITICAL COMPONENTS IN LIFE SUPPORT DEVICES OR SYSTEMS WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN APPROVAL OF THE PRESIDENT OF FAIRCHILD SEMICONDUCTOR CORPORATION. As used herein: 1. Life support devices or systems are devices or systems which, (a) are intended for surgical implant into the body, or (b) support or sustain life, or (c) whose failure to perform when properly used in accordance with instructions for use provided in the labeling, can be reasonably expected to result in significant injury to the user. © 2010 Fairchild Semiconductor Corporation Rev. 1.0.0 • 4/27/10 2. A critical component is any component of a life support device or system whose failure to perform can be reasonably expected to cause the failure of the life support device or system, or to affect its safety or effectiveness. www.fairchildsemi.com 9