AN5177 Application Note AN5177 Improved Gate Drive For GTO Series Connections Application Note Replaces September 2000 version, AN5177-3.0 AN5177-3.1 July 2002 Using an improved gate drive to ease GTO series connection problems. INTRODUCTION There are problems encountered with dynamic voltage sharing of series connected GTOs both at turn-on and turn-off. This application note will deal with the problems associated with turnoff and a further note will address turn-on problems. Switching high voltages using rectifier diodes or thyristors is routinely done using devices connected in series. With resistor and capacitor networks connected, 100 devices or more can be wired in series. The basic problem of series connection is to ensure good voltage sharing between devices under both static and dynamic conditions. By using devices selected within defined limits of leakage current and reverse recovery charge, together with correctly sized resistors and capacitors reliable operation is assured. Unfortunately, series connection of GTOs involves more restraints. For traditional applications such as rail traction where high turn-off currents are important series connection of GTOs has not usually been cost effective. A higher voltage GTO has been the preferred solution. However, this application note shows that even standard design GTOs when used with improved performance gate drive units can be successfully connected in series for certain applications. Fig. 1 GTOs in series with snubber networks In this note, a specific type of application is considered where reverse blocking GTOs are used in series in a current source inverter. In this application, the GTOs are not usually required to turn-off near to their ITCM limits. voltage source inverters turn-off by anode current reversal is not usually relevant. THE SERIES CONNECTION PROBLEM TURN-ON Three modes of operation need to be considered: Figure 1 shows two GTOs in series with snubber networks fitted. For simplicity, static sharing parallel resistors are not shown. There will always be a time difference, ∆T, between the GTOs turning on. This time difference is the combination of differences in td and tr of the GTOs, together with the gate drive units propagation time variations. 1. At GTO turn-on. 2. At GTO turn-off by gate commutation. This is the conventional mode for most GTO applications. 3. At GTO turn-off by anode current reversal i.e. natural commutation. This is similar to diode reverse recovery. Figure 2 shows the waveforms at turn-on. All these operating modes apply to current source inverters. For 1/5 www.dynexsemi.com AN5177 Application Note ∆tgs This is the difference in storage time between the GTOs in series. Traditionally, GTOs are turned off slowly, typically with dIg/dt = -40A/µs. With this condition, ∆tgs values are fairly large. The gate drive unit described achieves turn off current rates of 250A/µs so that tgs and ∆tgs are much smaller. Cs Snubber capacitor values need to be high to reduce the effect of high ∆tgs. It follows that if ∆tgs can be reduced so can Cs. TURN-OFF BY CURRENT REVERSAL This is the reverse recovery mode, as with a diode and conventional thyristors and is only applicable to reverse blocking GTOs. In this recovery mode the gate drive unit has no effect. Fig. 2 Turn-on waveforms TURN-OFF BY GATE COMMUTATION At turn-off, the voltage mis-sharing, ∆V, is very dependent on Itm, Cs, and ∆tgs. Sharing considerations are as for fast recovery diodes. Thus, to minimise the value of the snubber capacitor the difference between the reverse recovery charge values of the GTOs, (∆Qs) must be kept to a minimum. ∆V = Itm . ∆tgs/Cs SELECTING THE VALUE OF Cs ITM Cs must be sized for (a) minimising delay time variations at turnon, (b) conventional GTO gate commutated turn-off and (c) GTO reverse recovery, if appropriate. The requirement for turn-off usually dominates. Clearly, the aim must be to reduce the value of Cs to as low a value as permitted by the application and the GTO specification. Using a gate drive which delivers a higher turn-off gate current rate can help to reduce the required value of Cs. This is the current being turned-off. This current is relatively low in a current source inverter. By contrast, currents can be very high in a voltage source inverter and this leads to high values of ∆V. Consequently, Cs values must be high to compensate. Fig. 3 Simplified version of gdu turn-off section - in reality 10x 470µF capacitors used 2/5 www.dynexsemi.com AN5177 Application Note Fig. 4 Loop inductance and dynamic resistance IMPROVED GATE DRIVE UNIT TURN-OFF PERFORMANCE A new gate drive unit(GDU) has been designed which gives the GTO improved turn-off performance. Figure 3 shows a simplified circuit of the turn-off section of the GDU. The turn-off current pulse is achieved by charging a parallel bank of low inductance capacitors to 20 volts and discharging into the GTO gate using MOSFET switches. To achieve a high current and high dIg/dt a low loop inductance is required. LOOP INDUCTANCE AND DYNAMIC RESISTANCE The relevant parts of the loop inductance and dynamic resistance are shown in figure 4. Unfortunately, the physical design of the GTO itself, with its centre gate and gate termination layout, limits the minimum loop inductance which can be achieved. However, careful design of the gate drive PCB and of the interconnecting lead to the GTO housing has resulted in a great reduction in the overall loop inductance. For the GTO type DGT409 a loop inductance of less than 65nH has been achieved. This compares with 500nH for the conventional GDU and lead switching at 40A/µs and around 15nH for the IGCT. Conventionally, coaxial type cable is used as the gate lead to GTOs but the inductance of a normal cable and its terminations is too high for our application. To minimise the mutual inductance of a connecting lead pair it is necessary to keep the spacing between the forward and return lead as small as possible. A coaxial cable is better than a twisted pair but the strip line is probably the best. Here the conductors are usually thin copper sheets separated by a very thin insulating sheet. The effective inductance of a conductor is, in part, determined by the operating frequency. The dynamic resistance of a lead is increased at high operating frequencies by the ‘skin’ effect i.e. the tendency of high frequency currents to flow near the outer surface of a conductor. For this reason, strip line with its high surface area to cross sectional area ratio is an ideal choice for high current pulses with fast rising and falling edges. PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENTS IN THE GTO AT GATE TURN-OFF The performance improvements reported below are for a standard DGT409 which is a reverse blocking GTO type. In measuring the effects on GTO performance of high dig/dt gate turn off, three areas are of key importance. 1. The effect on turn-off switching loss. 2. The effect on turn-off current rating, Itcm. 3. The effect on storage time. 1. Figure 5 shows the increase in turn-off switching loss with dIgt/dt However, at high dIgt/dt values, above about 50A/µS, the rate of increase is low so the loss penalty for using high dIgt/dt values is small. 2. The effect on Itcm is beneficial. The high dIgt/dt and peak turnoff current ensure that the elements most remote from the gate connection on the edge of the silicon slice receive more gate current than normal. This means that the storage time variations between the elements is much less and sharing of turned off current between elements is much better. Figure 6 shows the variation of ITCM with Cs for normal and high dIGT/dt. 3. The reduction in storage time, tgs, is very marked between dIgt/dt = -40A/µs and –250A/µs, typically a factor of 6. It follows that as ∆tgs also reduces by a factor of 6 then Cs can be reduced by the same factor for the same change in ∆V. Figure 7. However, by the law of diminishing returns further 3/5 www.dynexsemi.com AN5177 Application Note 4500 2.0 4000 1.8 Max. permissible turn-off current, ITCM - (kA) VD = 4500V Conditions: VDM = 4300V, Tj = 100˚C 1.6 Turn-off energy loss, EOFF - (mJ) 3500 VD = 3000V 3000 1.4 – dIGQ/dt = 220A/µs 1.2 2500 – dIGQ/dt = 20A/µs 1.0 2000 VD = 1500V 1500 0.6 1000 0.4 Conditions: Tj = 115˚C, RS = 10Ω, IT = 800A, CS = 2µF 500 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Rate of rise of reverse gate current, dIGQ/dt - (A/µs) 0.2 0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 Snubber capacitance, Cs - (µF) 2.0 Fig. 6 Max. permissible turn-off current vs snubber capacitance Fig. 5 Turn-off energy vs rate of rise of reverse gate current 18 Conditions: Tj = 100˚C for Cs = 0.1 to 2µF 16 14 Gate storage time, tgs - (µs) 0.8 – dIGQ/dt = 20A/µs increases in dIGT/dt will have much less effect in further reducing storage time. 4. The reduction in gate turn-off charge Qgq is less marked, typically 40% for a change of dIgt/dt from 40 to 250A/µs. The consequence of this is that the power output requirement of the gate drive unit is reduced by 40%. Again for further increases in dIGT/dt the law of diminishing returns applies. 12 CONCLUSIONS 10 8 – dIGQ/dt = 220A/µs 6 4 Using gate drive circuits with faster rates of rise of gate turn-off current results in higher turn-off current rating, Itcm. Another benefit is the reduction in storage time resulting in smaller sharing capacitors for series connected GTOs. The turn-off power requirements of the gate drive are less for a GTO operating with high rates of rise of turn-off current. The performance improvements described have been achieved using a relatively low cost gate drive and offer a very cost effective alternative to the IGCT in many applications. 2 0 0 500 1000 1500 On-state current, IT - (A) 2000 Fig. 7 Gate storgae time vs on-state current 4/5 www.dynexsemi.com POWER ASSEMBLY CAPABILITY The Power Assembly group was set up to provide a support service for those customers requiring more than the basic semiconductor, and has developed a flexible range of heatsink and clamping systems in line with advances in device voltages and current capability of our semiconductors. We offer an extensive range of air and liquid cooled assemblies covering the full range of circuit designs in general use today. The Assembly group offers high quality engineering support dedicated to designing new units to satisfy the growing needs of our customers. Using the latest CAD methods our team of design and applications engineers aim to provide the Power Assembly Complete Solution (PACs). HEATSINKS The Power Assembly group has its own proprietary range of extruded aluminium heatsinks which have been designed to optimise the performance of Dynex semiconductors. Data with respect to air natural, forced air and liquid cooling (with flow rates) is available on request. For further information on device clamps, heatsinks and assemblies, please contact your nearest sales representative or Customer Services. http://www.dynexsemi.com e-mail: [email protected] HEADQUARTERS OPERATIONS DYNEX SEMICONDUCTOR LTD Doddington Road, Lincoln. Lincolnshire. LN6 3LF. United Kingdom. Tel: +44-(0)1522-500500 Fax: +44-(0)1522-500550 CUSTOMER SERVICE Tel: +44 (0)1522 502753 / 502901. Fax: +44 (0)1522 500020 SALES OFFICES Benelux, Italy & Switzerland: Tel: +33 (0)1 64 66 42 17. Fax: +33 (0)1 64 66 42 19. France: Tel: +33 (0)2 47 55 75 52. Fax: +33 (0)2 47 55 75 59. Germany, Northern Europe, Spain & Rest Of World: Tel: +44 (0)1522 502753 / 502901. Fax: +44 (0)1522 500020 North America: Tel: (613) 723-7035. Fax: (613) 723-1518. Toll Free: 1.888.33.DYNEX (39639) / Tel: (949) 733-3005. Fax: (949) 733-2986. These offices are supported by Representatives and Distributors in many countries world-wide. © Dynex Semiconductor 2002 TECHNICAL DOCUMENTATION – NOT FOR RESALE. PRODUCED IN UNITED KINGDOM Datasheet Annotations: Dynex Semiconductor annotate datasheets in the top right hard corner of the front page, to indicate product status. The annotations are as follows:Target Information: This is the most tentative form of information and represents a very preliminary specification. No actual design work on the product has been started. Preliminary Information: The product is in design and development. The datasheet represents the product as it is understood but details may change. Advance Information: The product design is complete and final characterisation for volume production is well in hand. No Annotation: The product parameters are fixed and the product is available to datasheet specification. This publication is issued to provide information only which (unless agreed by the Company in writing) may not be used, applied or reproduced for any purpose nor form part of any order or contract nor to be regarded as a representation relating to the products or services concerned. No warranty or guarantee express or implied is made regarding the capability, performance or suitability of any product or service. The Company reserves the right to alter without prior notice the specification, design or price of any product or service. Information concerning possible methods of use is provided as a guide only and does not constitute any guarantee that such methods of use will be satisfactory in a specific piece of equipment. It is the user's responsibility to fully determine the performance and suitability of any equipment using such information and to ensure that any publication or data used is up to date and has not been superseded. These products are not suitable for use in any medical products whose failure to perform may result in significant injury or death to the user. All products and materials are sold and services provided subject to the Company's conditions of sale, which are available on request. All brand names and product names used in this publication are trademarks, registered trademarks or trade names of their respective owners. www.dynexsemi.com