ETC AN-22

®
Designing Multiple Output Flyback
Power Supplies with TOPSwitch®
Application Note AN-22
Introduction
Many TOPSwitch flyback power supply applications require
two or more outputs to supply a variety of secondary circuits.
Typical consumer applications of these multiple output
converters include television and related products such as settop decoders and video cassette recorders (VCRs). Industrial
applications generally require a number of outputs to supply
analog and digital low voltage circuitry. Motor control
applications often require several separately isolated outputs
to supply half-bridge drivers and control circuitry.
When compared to single output flyback supplies, multiple
output applications demand further design considerations to
R6
10 Ω
30 V
C2
47 µF
50 V
D5
L3
3.3 µH
12 V
C3
470 µF
35 V
D4
C6
100 µF
35 V
L1
3.3 µH
5V
D2
C10
1000 µF
35 V
VR1
P6KE200
R2
100 Ω
1/2 W
C11
100 µF
35 V
RTN
C1
68 µF
400 V
L2
33 mH
D1
BYV26C
U2
NEC2501
BR1
400 V
D3
1N4148
C4
0.1 µF
R1
100 Ω
T1
U1
C8
0.1 µF
F1
1.0 A
L
N
J1
R4
10 kΩ
D TOP223
CONTROL
TOPSwitch-II
U3
TL431
C
R3
6.2 Ω
S
C5
47 µF
C7*
1.0 nF
Y1
C9
0.1 µF
R5
10 kΩ
* Two series connected, 2.2 nF, Y2-capacitors can replace C7.
PI-2123-120297
Figure 1. Schematic Diagram of 85-265 VAC, 25 W Power Supply Using TOP223.
March 1998
AN-22
The design begins with system specifications that define
regulation requirements, followed by selection of an appropriate
feedback scheme. It then moves to calculation of transformer
parameters and application of construction techniques specific
to multiple output supplies, aided by reference to Application
Notes AN-17 and AN-18 for detailed descriptions.
POWER SUPPLY SPECIFICATIONS
Input Voltage:
85-265 VAC
Voltage
5 VDC ± 5%
Current
0.40 A to 2.00 A
Voltage
12 VDC ± 10%
Current
0.12 A to 1.20 A
Voltage
30 VDC ± 10%
Current
0.01 A to 0.02 A
Appendix A provides some additional reminders for use of the
transformer design spreadsheet, while Appendix B contains
special techniques for use with output voltages of 3.3 V and
5 V. Appendix C gives complete construction details of the
transformer used in the hardware examples.
25 W
Design Procedure
Output 1
A discussion of output cross regulation includes measurements
and test results. Additional EMI considerations are presented
with reference to AN-15 and AN-16. There is also a listing of
general tips which may be appropriate to specific designs.
Output 2
Output 3
Total Output Power:
Table 1. Outline Power Supply Specification.
optimize the performance. The design of multiple output
power supplies always requires some breadboarding to verify
transformer designs, feedback techniques and system behavior.
This Application Note provides guidelines to streamline the
decision making process and to reduce development effort for
an optimized design. An example multiple output power
supply design illustrates the procedure. All essential aspects
are considered.
The design procedure for multiple output power supplies is a
simple extension of the single output case. The circuitry on the
primary side of the transformer is the same for either application.
Additional steps in the design for multiple outputs are needed
only to calculate turns ratios and wire sizes for the extra
windings. Transformer construction has more degrees of
freedom than in the single output case. The designer can apply
several circuit techniques to adjust output regulation
characteristics as needed.
POWER SUPPLY FEEDBACK TECHNIQUES
Output Regulation
Feedback Technique
Main Output
Other Outputs
Notes
Primary
(Basic or Enhanced)
±10%
Wider than ±10%
Any lightly loaded output may
be post-regulated to get ±5%
or better regulation
Opto/Zener
±5%
Wider than ±10%
With 2% Zener
Opto/TL431
±5%
Tighter than ±10%
Proportional feedback from two
or more outputs optional
Table 2. Choice of Feedback Technique Depends on Requirements for Output Regulation.
2
C
5/98
AN-22
Regulation Requirements
Specification of the regulation requirements on all outputs is
essential to successful design of the circuit configuration and
transformer. Requirements differ significantly depending on
the application.
One output usually requires tighter regulation than the others.
Usually the 5 V supply for logic circuitry requires regulation
of ±5% or less, while other outputs have a wider tolerance of
typically ±10%. Many applications now require both 3.3 V and
5 V outputs, with ±5% regulation specifications. There are
several techniques which can be used to achieve this
performance, and they are discussed in more detail in Appendix
B of this application note.
While a 5 V output may have the most stringent regulation
specification, a different winding often has a higher output
load specification. Consideration must therefore be given to
the required cross regulation between these outputs, because it
will influence the transformer winding technique for an optimum
design.
Table 1 gives an outline specification for a 25 W power supply
with three outputs. Note that the 5 V output has the highest
current and the tightest regulation, but the 12 V output delivers
the highest power. The techniques presented here can be
extended to any number of outputs. Some specific
considerations for more outputs are discussed later.
The next step of the design is to determine the most appropriate
feedback technique. As a quick reference for deciding the
optimum feedback technique, Table 2 provides broad design
rules which can be used, based on the required output tolerances
of a specific application. If no tighter than ±10% tolerance is
required on all outputs, a primary side feedback scheme may
be employed. This technique eliminates the need for an
optocoupler by using the primary bias winding of the
transformer to derive information about the regulated output
on the secondary. This type of feedback scheme is detailed in
AN-16. It is difficult, however, to achieve the output voltage
tolerance of ±5% with this scheme alone.
If outputs requiring ±5% are only lightly loaded, primary side
feedback may be used with a linear post regulator on these
outputs at the expense of some drop in efficiency. From the
specification in Table 1, however, the 2 A peak load on the 5
V output would lead to excessive dissipation in a linear
regulator; therefore, the remainder of this application note will
concentrate on feedback that uses an optocoupler.
There are two common techniques to generate a secondary
reference with optocoupler feedback. The first uses a simple
Zener diode as a secondary reference. This technique is
described in the supporting literature for Power Integrations’
RD5 reference design board. The output voltage is determined
by the Zener voltage, the forward voltage of the optocoupler’s
LED and the series resistor that sets the loop gain. A 2%
tolerance Zener diode allows ±5% tolerance on the regulated
output voltage. However, it is often necessary to improve cross
regulation by providing feedback from more than one output.
The second technique uses a TL431 precision shunt regulator
to offer more flexibility in such cases.
The TL431 precision shunt regulator integrates an accurate
2.5 V bandgap reference with an amplifier and driver into a
single device. It is popular as a secondary referenced error
amplifier. The TL431 also introduces the possibility of
combining feedback from two or more outputs simultaneously
to its reference pin. This can be a useful technique when it is
required to employ one output as the primary source of
feedback but also introduce a proportion of the feedback
from another output. This advanced technique is described in
more detail later.
This application note, therefore, focuses on the use of the
TL431 shunt regulator. Figure 1 shows a schematic in a
typical application with an optocoupler to provide tight
regulation on the 5 V output of a multiple output power supply.
Transformer Design
The choice of TOPSwitch and calculation of the primary
transformer characteristics is independent of the number of
outputs. As such, the Power Integrations standard transformer
design spreadsheets (available from your local Power
Integrations representative or on the Power Integrations Web
site at www.powerint.com) can be used to define the basic
transformer specification in terms of the transformer core,
primary inductance, primary turns and the output volts per
turn. This basic design can then be extended to define the turns
and wire selection on other outputs.
Two spreadsheets are available: one for discontinuous
conduction mode (DCM) designs and one for continuous
conduction mode (CCM) designs. Refer to AN-16 and AN-17
in the Power Integrations 1996-97 Data Book and Design
Guide for further explanation of converter operation and use of
the spreadsheets.
Operation in DCM results in smaller transformer core sizes for
a given output power, but the smallest size is often not the most
desirable choice in multiple output power supplies. Transformer
hardware is usually selected to allow optimum circuit board
layout. This motivation drives the selection of a transformer
bobbin with the best arrangement of the number of pins and the
pin spacing.
Designing for CCM provides the optimum utilization of the
TOPSwitch silicon for a given output power. Therefore, this
C
5/98
3
AN-22
AN-22.XLS
A
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
B
C
D
Rev 2.1
INPUT
ENTER APPLICATION VARIABLES
VACMIN
85
VACMAX
265
fL
50
fS
100000
VO
5
PO
25
n
0.8
Z
0.5
VB
12
tC
3
CIN
68
E
OUTPUT
Volts
Volts
Hertz
Hertz
Volts
Watts
Volts
mSeconds
uFarads
ENTER TOPSWITCH VARIABLES
VOR
110
ILIMITMAX
1 . 6 5 TOP224
VDS
10
VD
0.7
VDB
0.7
KRP
0.45
Volts
Amps
Volts
Volts
Volts
F
CONTR2P1.XLS: TOPSwitch Continuous Flyback Transformer Design Spreadsheet
AN-22
Minimum AC Input Voltage
Maximum AC Input Voltage
AC Mains Frequency
TOPSwitch Switching Frequency
Output Voltage
Output Power
Efficiency Estimate
Loss Allocation Factor
Bias Voltage
Bridge Rectifier Conduction Time Estimate
Input Filter Capacitor
Reflected Output Voltage
From TOPSwitch Data Sheet
TOPSwitch on-state Drain to Source Voltage
Output Winding Diode Forward Voltage Drop
Bias Winding Diode Forward Voltage Drop
Ripple to Peak Current Ratio (0.4 < KRP < 1.0)
ENTER TRANSFORMER CORE/CONSTRUCTION VARIABLES
ETD29
0.76
cm^2
7.2
cm
2100
nH/T^2
19
mm
3
mm
2
4
Core Type
Core Effective Cross Sectional Area
Core Effective Path Length
Ungapped Core Effective Inductance
Bobbin Physical Winding Width
Safety Margin Width (Half the Primary to Secondary Creepage Distance)
Number of Primary Layers
Number of Secondary Turns
DC INPUT VOLTAGE PARAMETERS
VMIN
VMAX
Minimum DC Input Voltage
Maximum DC Input Voltage
AE
LE
AL
BW
M
L
NS
9 0 Volts
3 7 5 Volts
CURRENT WAVEFORM SHAPE PARAMETERS
DMAX
IAVG
IP
IR
IRMS
0.58
0.35
0.78
0.35
0.46
Amps
Amps
Amps
Amps
Duty Cycle at Minimum DC Input Voltage (VMIN)
Average Primary Current
Peak Primary Current
Primary Ripple Current
Primary RMS Current
TRANSFORMER PRIMARY DESIGN PARAMETERS
LP
1 3 3 9 uHenries
NP
77
NB
9
ALG
225
nH/T^2
BM
1 7 7 1 Gauss
BP
3 7 6 7 Gauss
BAC
399
Gauss
ur
1583
LG
0 . 3 8 mm
BWE
26
mm
OD
0 . 3 4 mm
INS
0.06
mm
DIA
0 . 2 8 mm
AWG
3 0 AWG
CM
102
Cmils
CMA
2 1 9 Cmils/Amp
Primary Inductance
Primary Winding Number of Turns
Bias Winding Number of Turns
Gapped Core Effective Inductance
Flux Density at PO, VMIN
Peak Flux Density (BP < 4200)
AC Flux Density for Core Loss Curves (0.5 X Peak to Peak)
Relative Permeability of Ungapped Core
Gap Length (Lg >> 0.051 mm)
Effective Bobbin Width
Maximum Primary Wire Diameter including insulation
Estimated Total Insulation Thickness (= 2 * film thickness)
Bare conductor diameter
Primary Wire Gauge (Rounded to next smaller standard AWG value)
Bare conductor effective area in circular mils
Primary Winding Current Capacity (200 < CMA < 500)
TRANSFORMER SECONDARY DESIGN PARAMETERS
ISP
14.98
ISRMS
7.62
IO
5.00
IRIPPLE
5.75
Peak Secondary Current
Secondary RMS Current
Power Supply Output Current
Output Capacitor RMS Ripple Current
CMS
AWGS
DIAS
ODS
INSS
VOLTAGE STRESS PARAMETERS
VDRAIN
PIVS
PIVB
ADDITIONAL OUTPUTS
VX
12
VDX
0.7
NX
PIVX
1667
1.05
Amps
Amps
Amps
Amps
Cmils
1 7 AWG
1 . 1 5 mm
3 . 2 5 mm
mm
6 2 6 Volts
2 4 Volts
5 5 Volts
Volts
Volts
8.91
5 5 Volts
Secondary Bare Conductor minimum circular mils
Secondary Wire Gauge (Rounded up to next larger standard AWG value)
Secondary Minimum Bare Conductor Diameter
Secondary Maximum Insulated Wire Outside Diameter
Maximum Secondary Insulation Wall Thickness
Maximum Drain Voltage Estimate (Includes Effect of Leakage Inductance)
Output Rectifier Maximum Peak Inverse Voltage
Bias Rectifier Maximum Peak Inverse Voltage
Auxiliary
Auxiliary
Auxiliary
Auxiliary
Output Voltage
Diode Forward Voltage Drop
Number of Turns
Rectifier Maximum Peak Inverse Voltage
Page 1
Figure 2. Spreadsheet to Design Transformers for Single Output and Multiple Output Flyback Converters.
4
C
5/98
AN-22
example uses the spreadsheet for continuous conduction mode.
The techniques described in the following sections to extend
the standard single output transformer design to multiple
outputs are the same for either spreadsheet.
Spreadsheet Transformer Design
Figure 2 shows the spreadsheet for a transformer that meets the
output power and input voltage specification of Table 1. A full
explanation of the use of the spreadsheet is provided in AN-17,
but a brief overview will suffice for this explanation.
The first section of the spreadsheet is used to input the
application variables. Note that only the 5 V output is needed
to determine the number of turns of the primary, while the total
output power for all outputs is specified in this section to select
the transformer core, primary inductance and wire gauge.
Initial design requirements may not be firm enough to
determine which TOPSwitch will be used in the final product.
The designer usually has to choose between two likely
candidates (see AN-21). In all designs, whether single or
multiple output, the transformer design should accommodate
the largest TOPSwitch that might be used with it. A designer
may find it necessary to use the larger TOPSwitch (with a lower
on-resistance) to permit the use of a smaller heatsink, for
example.
Thus, although the circuit of Figure 1 specifies the TOP223Y,
the spreadsheet uses the upper current limit value for the
TOP224Y/TOP224P. The higher value is used here to ensure
flexibility to allow the use of the TOP224 should the application
require it. The change may be necessary if mechanical
restrictions in the available space of the power supply’s
enclosure force the use of a smaller heatsink.
The upper current limit is subsequently used in the spreadsheet
to determine the peak flux density BP, which should be limited
to prevent excessive core saturation under overload and start
up conditions.
are equally applicable. The bobbin style does not influence the
calculation of the primary inductance, but specific bobbin
width must be input to determine the physical space available
for the primary winding. Although triple insulated wire
techniques are not normally favored in applications requiring
a high number of secondary turns, transformer suppliers should
be consulted for advice on the optimum construction technique
in a particular application.
The spreadsheet defines two layers for the primary winding to
minimize construction costs. If other cores with reduced
bobbin widths are used, additional layers may be necessary to
satisfy recommendations for current capacity (CMA). It
should be noted that an even number of layers will ease
construction because the start and finish of the primary winding
will be at the same side of the bobbin.
The remaining sections of the spreadsheet provide the
transformer design that results from the input variables described
above. The key parameters that must be checked before a
design can be deemed acceptable are detailed in AN-17 and
summarized in Appendix A.
Since the spreadsheet is written for single output supplies, the
‘Transformer Secondary Design Parameters’ show values
assuming the total output power is provided by the 5 V output.
It is therefore necessary to extend these calculations to account
for the partitioning of output power defined in the power
supply specification of Table 1. The following section
provides the equations necessary to assign appropriate numbers
of turns and wire gauges to each output.
Calculation of Secondary Turns
From the spreadsheet, the 5 V output winding is defined as
having 4 turns. The voltage on the cathode of D2 in Figure 1
is 5 V. Therefore, 4 turns produce the output voltage plus the
forward drop of the output diode D2.
The volts per turn VPT is defined as:
The ferrite core used here is the industry standard ETD29. This
is used as an example only. Other standard cores such as the
EE or EER families can be substituted as desired.
The design is based on a margin wound construction, where
3 mm margins are provided at each side of the bobbin to give
a total of 6 mm primary to secondary creepage distance. This
is the standard creepage distance allowed for mains input
power supplies meeting IEC950 (or equivalent) isolation.
Local safety agency requirements for creepage and clearance
should be obtained before committing a design to manufacture.
Other transformer construction techniques, such as slotted
bobbin, concentric bobbin or the use of triple insulated wire,
VPT =
(VO + VD )
(1)
NS
where:
VPT = volts per turn
VO = output voltage (5 V)
VD = output diode forward voltage drop (typically 0.7 V
for ultra fast PN power diodes and 0.4 V for
Schottky diodes)
C
5/98
5
AN-22
30 V
22 T
0.5 mm (24 AWG)
77 T
0.3 mm
(29 AWG)
30 V
RTN
12 V
9T
0.5 mm (24 AWG)
2 in parallel
4T
0.5 mm (24 AWG)
3 in parallel
9T
0.3 mm
(29 AWG)
77 T
0.3 mm
(29 AWG)
13 T
0.5 mm (24 AWG)
12 V
5T
0.5 mm (24 AWG)
2 in parallel
5V
4T
0.5 mm (24 AWG)
4 in parallel
RTN
RTN
5V
RTN
9T
0.3 mm
(29 AWG)
(b) Stacked Winding
(a) Separate Winding
PI-2743-120297
Figure 3. Transformer Winding Diagrams Showing Two Techniques for the Secondary Winding.
NS = number of secondary turns (4 turns for the 5 V output)
A practical transformer requires integer numbers of turns;
therefore, the 12 V output uses 9 turns.
Substitution of these values into (1) gives:
For the 30 V output,
VPT = 1.43 V per turn
VO = 30 V
This value is used to calculate the turns required by the other
outputs.
Simple rearrangement of (1) gives:
NS =
(VO + VD )
VPT
For the 12 V output,
VD = 0.7 V
Substituting in (2):
6
C
5/98
Substituting in (2) gives:
(2)
NS30 =
(30 + 0.7)
= 21.5 turns
1.43
Select 22 turns for the 30 V winding.
VO = 12 V
NS12 =
VD = 0.7 V
(12 + 0.7)
= 8.9 turns
1.43
This last result highlights a frequently encountered problem in
multiple output transformers. An integer number of turns, such
as 21 or 22, will make the output voltage lower or higher
respectively than desired. Since this is a high voltage output
with a large number of turns, the difference between the
desired value and the integer value amounts to only about 2%.
The resulting change in output voltage is not significant, and
will be masked by other factors such as cross regulation and
diode characteristics. However, it is worth mentioning the
options available should this problem be encountered with
AN-22
lower voltage outputs where the requirement for integer
numbers of turns can introduce a significant deviation from the
desired value.
1. If the output in question requires a high degree of
accuracy, then a higher output voltage can be defined in
equation (2) and a linear post regulator employed to
achieve the output voltage.
2. If the tolerance is less critical, a series resistor and a
Zener diode of appropriate value can be used as a shunt
regulator for low power outputs.
final choice of turns on each output is therefore shown in
Figure 3(a), and summarized as follows:
5 V — 4 turns
12 V — 9 turns
30 V — 22 turns
Figure 3 illustrates two winding diagrams: one with separate
windings for each output and one with stacked output windings.
These two configurations are discussed in detail later in the
section on transformer construction.
Choice of Output Wire Gauge
3. The fundamental transformer design could be modified
such that the main 5 V output uses a number of turns
which yields an integer number of turns on the other
windings when calculated using equations (1) and (2).
4. The choice of rectifier on the main regulated output can
be used to influence the volts per turn. If a Schottky
diode with a forward voltage of typically 0.4 V were
employed on the 5 V output, the VPT from (1) would be
1.35. A standard PN diode on the 30 V output would
from equation (2) yield 22.7 turns, which is closer to the
integer number 23.
Use of the Schottky diode with 4 turns on the 5 V output,
however, would decrease the accuracy of the 12 V output. The
required number of turns would move farther away from an
integer value, from 8.9 to 9.4 turns.
The designer can investigate alternative integer turns ratios
with both Schottky and PN diodes by repeating the spreadsheet
design for other values of secondary turns. If a need for higher
efficiency calls for a Schottky diode on the 5 V output, then 3
turns on the 5 V output with 7 and 17 turns for the 12 V and
30 V outputs respectively may give acceptable results.
Designers often use the "golden ratios" of 3:7:9 with a
Schottky diode for the 5 V output and a PN diode for the 12 V
output, or 4:9:11 with all PN diodes to achieve outputs of 5, 12
and 15 V. Another useful ratio is 2:3 for outputs of 3.3 and
5 V with Schottky diodes on each. The turns could be in the
ratio of 3:4 if the 3.3 V output uses a PN diode and the 5 V uses
a Schottky diode. All designs need to be tested thoroughly to
verify acceptability.
In practice, if tight tolerance is required on windings other
than the main feedback output, some form of post regulation
or combined feedback circuitry is often necessary. These
issues of cross regulation are discussed later in the section on
circuit performance.
In this case, as mentioned above, the choice of 22 turns for the
30 V output will not introduce a significant inaccuracy. The
Appropriate wire gauge for the outputs is determined on the
basis of the maximum continuous RMS current rating for each
winding. The analysis of the distribution of current in the
various outputs can be very complex, but a few reasonable
assumptions make the task easy.
The waveshapes of the currents in the individual output
windings are determined by the impedances in each circuit.
Leakage inductance, rectifier characteristics and capacitor
values are some of the parameters that affect the magnitude and
duration of the currents. The average currents are always equal
to the DC load current, while the RMS values are functions of
peak magnitudes and conduction times. The RMS values
determine the power dissipation in the windings. For ordinary
multiple output designs it is valid to make the reasonable
simplifying assumption that all output currents have the same
shape as for the single output case. This is the case of greatest
dissipation.
Ultimately the final design of the transformer has to be decided
on the basis of tests and consultation with transformer suppliers.
However, the first order analysis that assumes the same
waveshape for all output currents provides a start point for the
choice of wire gauge.
The single output design of the spreadsheet calculates the RMS
current in the secondary as if the 5 V winding supplied all the
power. However, from the specification of Table 1, the 5 V
output supplies a maximum of 10 W. The actual currents in the
multiple output application are computed from quantities on
the single output spreadsheet.
Since we assume the currents in the output windings have the
same shape, each will have the same ratio of RMS to average
as the single output case. If KRA is the ratio of RMS to average
current, then
K RA =
ISRMS 7.62 A
=
= 1.524
IO
5A
(3)
C
5/98
7
AN-22
where ISRMS and IO are from the spreadsheet.
To find the RMS current in a winding, we simply multiply its
average current by KRA.
I RMSX = I X × K RA
(4)
Hence, the RMS current in the 5 V winding is
493 and 197 CMA respectively) allows acceptable power
dissipation in the majority of applications, depending on the
conditions of maximum ambient temperature and efficiency
requirements. In the United States, it is common to use the
reciprocal of current density expressed as circular mils per
ampere (CMA). One mil is 0.001 inch, and the area in circular
mils is the square of the wire diameter in mils. One circular mil
is 7.854 × 10-7 in2 or 5.067 × 10-4 mm2.
Based on 9 A/mm2 (219 CMA), using the RMS current
calculated above, the minimum bare copper diameter for each
output is:
I RMS5 = 2.0 A × 1.524 = 3.05 A
and the RMS current on the 12 V winding is
5 V output
I RMS12 = 1.2 A × 1.524 = 1.83 A
12 V output — 0.51 mm (24 AWG)
Similar calculations for the 30 V output yield
30 V output — 0.07 mm (41 AWG)
I RMS30 = 30.5 mA
The wire diameter can be chosen on the basis of the total
dissipation in the output winding. One can find the resistance
of the winding from the resistance per unit length of a particular
wire gauge and the length of the wire associated with each
output winding. However, a calculation based on the current
density can be used to make a first estimate of the required wire
gauge on each output.
A current density between 4 and 10 A/mm2 (corresponding to
WINDING TECHNIQUE
— 0.66 mm (22 AWG)
The above calculations define the minimum wire diameter
specifications. However, practical considerations of
transformer manufacture determine the actual wire gauges
used. For example, two or three parallel windings on the higher
current outputs can reduce the required wire diameter while
optimizing coverage of the bobbin. These issues are discussed
in detail next.
Transformer Construction
Primary winding techniques are well documented in AN-18
ADVANTAGES
Separate Output Windings 1. Flexibility in winding
placement; Output with
highest current can be
positioned closest to primary
to minimize energy lost from
leakage inductance.
DISADVANTAGES
1. Poor regulation of lightly loaded
outputs due to peak charging.
2. Generally higher manufacturing
costs.
3. More pins on bobbin.
Stacked Output Windings
1. Improved cross regulation.
2. Generally lowest cost
manufacturing technique.
1. Winding with lowest or highest
voltage output must be placed
closest to the primary winding
– no flexibility to reduce leakage
inductance of outputs with higher
currents.
Table 3. Comparison of Secondary Winding Techniques in Margin Wound Transformers.
8
C
5/98
AN-22
30 V
C6
100 µF
50V
C12
100 µF
50 V
D5
UF4004
L3
3.3 µH
12 V
C11
100 µF
35 V
C10
390 µF
35 V
D4
MUR420
L1
3.3 µH
D8
MBR745
VR1
P6KE200
5V
C2
1000 µF
35 V
C3
120 µF
25 V
RTN
C1
68 µF
400 V
L2
33 mH
D1
BYV26C
U2
CNY 17-2
BR1
400 V
D3
1N4148
R2
100 Ω
1/2 W
C4
0.1 µF
R1
75 Ω
T1
F1
1.0 A
C9
0.1 µF
U1
C8
0.1 µF
D TOP223
CONTROL
TOPSwitch-II
L
N
J1
R4
10 kΩ
C
R3
5.2 Ω
S
C5
47 µF
U3
TL431
C7*
1000 pF
250VAC
Y1
R5
10 kΩ
* Two series connected, 2.2 nF, Y2-capacitors can replace C7.
PI-2125-121197
Figure 4. Schematic of Multiple Output 25 W Power Supply with Stacked Secondary Windings.
and are not influenced by the number of output windings.
There are, however, two secondary winding techniques
commonly used in margin wound transformers. These are
described below and summarized in Table 3. Other transformer
constructions such as slotted bobbin and concentric bobbin
designs may demand other considerations. The designer should
consult with the specific transformer supplier to insure the
optimum technique in each case.
The leakage inductance of a transformer is the inductance
associated with flux which does not link all windings. As such,
this flux does not contribute to the transfer of energy. In single
output transformer structures, all the leakage is usually measured
on the primary by shorting the output winding and measuring
the resulting inductance of the primary. This provides a good
estimate of the energy which the primary clamp circuitry will
dissipate. In Figure 1, components D1 and VR1 are specified
for clamping the leakage energy.
Separate Output Windings
The winding diagram of Figure 3(a) shows each output wound
as a separate coil. In this way each winding conducts only
current associated with the specific load on that output. Since
each output is wound as a separate operation, this construction
technique provides flexibility in the placement of output
windings relative to the primary winding. This freedom can be
an important consideration in multiple output transformers to
minimize the leakage inductance.
However, in a multiple output design, there are leakage
inductances associated with each output winding according to
its coupling to the primary and to other secondary windings.
Placement of the output windings should be made to minimize
the leakage inductance associated with outputs that provide the
most current. For example, in the circuit design of this
application note, the 5 V and 12 V outputs handle most of the
power with 2 A and 1.2 A respectively, while the 30 V output
has a load of only 20 mA. The windings therefore should be
C
5/98
9
AN-22
The stacked configuration improves cross regulation while
reducing construction costs. Consider this example where the
5 V output is fully loaded but the 12 V and 30 V outputs have
minimum load applied. With separate output windings, the
capacitors on the 12 V and 30 V outputs would tend to peak
charge under the influence of leakage inductance. However,
with a stacked winding, the fact that the 5 V output forms part
of the 12 V and 30 V windings reduces the impedance of these
windings and reduces the effect of peak charging.
FINISH
START
}
}
}
}
}
Turn
1
Turn
5
Turn
2
Turn
4
Turn
3
PI-2128-120297
Figure 5. Cross Section of Bobbin Showing Five Interleaved Turns
of Four Parallel Conductors on a Single Layer.
arranged such that the 5 V and 12 V outputs have the best
coupling to the primary winding.
An arrangement that has the 30 V winding closest to the
primary may show the same primary leakage inductance as the
preferred structure when measured with the standard technique
of shorting all outputs together. In the application, however,
efficiency will be reduced since the leakage inductance
associated with the 5 V and 12 V outputs will be higher.
The use of separate output windings provides complete
flexibility in the winding arrangement. In this case the optimum
configuration for separate layers might be to wind the 5 V
output first followed by the 12 V winding and finally the 30 V
output. That is, the winding with the greatest output current
would go next to the primary. An even better arrangement
would have the two highest current windings share a single
layer using the nesting technique illustrated in Appendix C.
Separate windings, however, tend to increase the cost of the
transformer since every output winding is a separate operation.
The alternative stacking technique described below improves
the regulation, particularly on lightly loaded outputs.
Stacked Output Windings
Figure 3(b) shows a stacked output winding configuration,
which is generally favored by transformer manufacturers. The
windings of the 5 V output provide the return and part of the
windings for the 12 V output. Similarly, the 30 V output uses
the turns of the 5 and 12 V outputs and additional turns to make
up the full winding. The wire for each output must be sized to
accommodate its output current plus the sum of the currents for
the other outputs stacked on top of it.
10
C
5/98
The only disadvantage of this winding technique is that there
is little flexibility in the placement of the windings relative to
the primary. Either the 30 V or 5 V winding must form the start
of the output windings closest to the primary. In this case, since
the 5 V has the highest loading, it is defined as the start of the
secondary winding.
Since the stacking technique generally offers the best cross
regulation, the winding construction of Figure 3(b) was chosen
for the example circuit in this application note, as illustrated in
Figure 4. The only difference between T1 in Figures 1 and 4
is the use of the stacked winding technique on the transformer
in Figure 4.
Construction to Improve Cross Regulation
The cross regulation is a measure of how well the output
voltages regulate under the influence of varying load conditions
on other outputs. The quality of cross regulation depends on
the coupling between the various output windings. The better
coupled these windings are, the better the cross regulation.
As such, it is recommended that each individual winding is
wound to cover the complete bobbin width. Therefore, the
easiest way to wind the transformer is to use several parallel
wires of the same gauge to insure the bobbin is well covered.
In this case, the total copper area used by the 5 V winding must
handle the total RMS current of all outputs.
The total output RMS current is:
I RMSTOT = I RMS 5 + I RMS12 + I RMS 30 = 5.03 A
This summation is possible only when the currents have the
same shape, which is a valid simplifying assumption for the
design.
Based on a current density of 9 A/mm2 (219 CMA), the copper
diameter of a single wire would need to be 1.03 mm (20 AWG).
However, if the wire is split into several parallel sections, each
carrying an equal share of the current, we may use a smaller
diameter wire which is much easier to handle during
manufacture.
AN-22
The 12 V winding must handle a total of 1.86 A RMS (IRMS12
+ IRMS30). To maintain a maximum current density below
9 A/mm2 (219 CMA) we can use the same 0.4 mm (27 AWG)
wire with the number of parallel strands reduced to 2. Again
this should be wound evenly across the bobbin with turns
distributed to provide the optimum coupling with the 5 V and
primary winding. Appendix C shows how to put both windings
on the same layer for best coupling.
Finally, the 30 V winding is added across the entire bobbin
width. This winding carries the current for only the 30 V load;
therefore, we can use a single strand of the 0.4 mm diameter
(27 AWG) wire. If desired, a thinner wire gauge may be
specified to reduce the volume occupied by the winding. The
same wire may be used in all windings to reduce cost. Appendix
C illustrates these methods with complete construction details
of the transformer used in this Application Note.
The techniques detailed above should be used in the transformer
construction to optimize cross regulation. However, additional
external circuit techniques to further enhance cross regulation
are discussed in the section on circuit performance.
PI-2142-121997
Output Voltage (% of Nominal)
105
5V
12 V
30 V
100
95
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
(a) 5 V Load (A)
Figure 6 (a). Cross Regulation with Feedback from 5 V Only.
Response to a 5 V Load.
As in single output converters, the proper choice of output
rectifiers in multiple output converters is essential to achieve
desired performance and reliability. It is important to use only
Schottky and ultra fast PN junction rectifiers. The effects of the
reverse recovery characteristics on the primary circuit are
amplified in multiple output applications because the output
rectifiers are effectively in parallel. Refer to AN-19 for a
discussion of how the selection of output rectifiers influences
efficiency.
The specification on each output rectifier diode is determined
on the basis of the required voltage and current rating. The
peak inverse voltage (PIV) on each diode is given by:

N 
PIVX = VX +  VMAX × X 
NP 

(5)
where VX is the voltage of the particular output, NX is the
number of output turns on the particular output and NP is the
transformer primary turns. VMAX is the maximum primary DC
rail voltage, which for 230 VAC input applications is typically
375 VDC (peak value of 265 VAC).
For the transformer in this example,
N P = 77 turns
VMAX = 375 V
Hence, for the 5 V output,
105
PI-2144-121997
In this example we chose to split the 5 V winding into six
conductors to fit the pin arrangement of the bobbin. One pin
can accommodate three wires. Since each wire carries one
sixth the current, or 0.84 A RMS, we may use a wire diameter
of 0.4 mm (27 AWG), which is much easier to handle during
manufacture.
Output Rectifier Specification
Output Voltage (% of Nominal)
Also, the multiple parallel strands of thinner wire can be placed
flat for good coverage of the bobbin as shown in Figure 5. This
will insure that the winding is well coupled to the primary and
to the other secondaries that are wound afterwards.
100
5V
12 V
30 V
95
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
(b) 5 V Load (A)
Figure 6 (b). Cross Regulation with Feedback from 5 V and 12 V.
Response to a 5 V Load.
C
5/98
11
AN-22
C6
100 µF
50V
C12
100 µF
50 V
D5
UF4004
30 V
L3
3.3 µH
12 V
C10
390 µF
35 V
D4
MUR420
L1
3.3 µH
D8
MBR745
VR1
P6KE200
C11
100 µF
35 V
R6
75 kΩ
5V
C2
1000 µF
35 V
C3
120 µF
25 V
RTN
C1
68 µF
400 V
L2
33 mH
D1
BYV26C
U2
CNY 17-2
BR1
400 V
D3
1N4148
R2
100 Ω
1/2 W
C4
0.1 µF
F1
1.0 A
C9
0.1 µF
U1
C6
0.1 µF
D TOP223
CONTROL
TOPSwitch-II
C
R3
5.2 Ω
S
L
C5
47 µF
N
J1
R4
21 kΩ
R1
75 Ω
T1
U3
TL431
C7*
1000 pF
250VAC
Y1
R5
10 kΩ
* Two series connected, 2.2 nF, Y2-capacitors can replace C7.
PI-2131-121197
Figure 7. Modified Schematic with Feedback from Both 5 V & 12 V Outputs.
4
PIV5 = 5 +  375 ×
= 25 V

77 
For the 12 V output,
9
PIV12 = 12 +  375 ×  = 56 V

77 
For the 30 V output,
22
PIV30 = 30 +  375 ×  = 137 V

77 
The diodes chosen for each output should have a reverse
voltage rating 1.25 × PIVX. This insures that the peak reverse
12
C
5/98
voltage never exceeds 80% of the rating of a particular diode.
Hence, in this case, the diode on the 5 V output should be rated
for more than 30 V, the 12 V output more than 70 V, and the
30 V output more than 171 V. Peak reverse voltages should be
measured on all diodes under maximum load and startup
conditions to ensure that ratings are not exceeded.
The rule of thumb for the diode current rating is to choose a
device with a DC current rating at least three times the average
DC output current of the particular output. From the current
specifications of Table 1 and the voltage requirements above,
the following minimum ratings should be defined in this case:
5 V output diode
—
6.0 A, 30 V
12 V output diode —
3.6 A, 70 V
30 V output diode —
60 mA, 171 V
AN-22
100
95
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
1.20
(a) 12 V Load (A)
PI-2148-121997
5V
12 V
30 V
105
Output Voltage (% of Nominal)
PI-2146-121997
Output Voltage (% of Nominal)
105
100
5V
12 V
30 V
95
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
1.20
(b) 12 V Load (A)
Figure 8(a). Cross Regulation with Feedback from 5 V Only.
Response to Variation of 12 V Load
Figure 8(b). Cross Regulation with Feedback from 5 V and 12 V.
Response to Variation of 12 V Load
For reverse voltage ratings less than 100 V, Schottky diodes
can be used to minimize power losses. As discussed earlier,
Schottkys can also be used to improve the relative accuracy of
output voltages when calculating the number of turns. Schottky
diodes are more expensive than PN junction diodes. The
circuit of Figure 1 uses ultra fast recovery PN diodes for the
lowest cost, while the circuit in Figure 4 uses a Schottky diode
on the 5 V output with the same transformer design. Circuit
performance may be improved with a transformer designed
specifically for a Schottky diode on the 5 V output.
changes with load current and temperature. As the outputs
have varying loads, the output diodes will exhibit different
forward voltages depending on the load conditions on the
particular output. Changing load conditions on the 5 V output,
for example, will inherently influence the voltages on the other
outputs.
In this example many possible diodes are available to achieve
the required characteristics. The devices in the example of
Figure 4 are:
5 V output:
MBR745
7.8 A, 45 V
Motorola
12 V output:
MUR420
4.0 A, 200 V
Motorola
30 V output:
UF4004
1.0 A, 400 V
General Semiconductor
Other suitable diodes are available from different
manufacturers. Tests with a number of diodes are
recommended to verify the optimum devices in each
application.
Circuit Performance
The volts per turn defined in Equation (1) is an approximation
based on the forward voltage of the output diode. This value
In addition, secondary effects such as voltage spikes from
leakage inductance and quality of coupling between output
windings, lead to reduced voltage accuracy on outputs which
do not provide feedback through the optocoupler.
The basic circuit of Figure 4 derives feedback only from the
5 V output. As a consequence, the other output voltages vary
as the 5 V output current changes. The influence on the 12 V
output is shown in Figure 6(a). Use of a Schottky diode in a
circuit designed for a PN diode emphasizes the effect of a
change in voltage drop, as illustrated in this example.
The 5 V output voltage is well controlled since it exclusively
provides the feedback signal. The 12 V output, however, is
seen to vary by ± 2% as the 5 V load is varied between 25% and
100% (0.5 amps to 2.0 amps). For this test the 12 V output load
was held constant at 0.6 amps. The 12 V and 30 V outputs are
also below their nominal values because of the lower drop of
the Schottky diode.
Transformer construction techniques to optimize output cross
regulation were discussed earlier. However, it is often necessary
to further enhance cross regulation using external circuit
techniques. For example, if improved regulation is required
on the 12 V output, a simple technique is to derive the feedback
from both 5 V and 12 V outputs. In this example, as in most
applications, higher accuracy is required on one of the outputs.
Here it is assumed that the main output is still the 5 V, but some
feedback may be drawn from the 12 V output to improve its
C
5/98
13
AN-22
C12
100 µF
50 V
C2
100 µF
50 V
D5
UF4004
L3
3.3 µH
C3
390 µF
35 V
D4
MUR420
30 V
Isolated
RTN
12 V
C6
100 µF
35 V
L1
3.3 µH
5V
D2
MBR745
VR1
P6KE200
C13
1 nF
500 V
R2
100 Ω
1/2 W
C10
1000 µF
35 V
C11
120 µF
25 V
RTN
C1
68 µF
400 V
L2
33 mH
D1
BYV26C
U2
CNY 17-2
BR1
400 V
D3
1N4148
C4
0.1 µF
R4
10 kΩ
R1
75 Ω
T1
U1
C8
0.1 µF
F1
1.0 A
D TOP223
CONTROL
TOPSwitch-II
C
R3
6.2 Ω
S
L
C5
47 µF
N
J1
U3
TL431
C9
0.1 µF
R5
10 kΩ
C7*
1.0 nF
Y1
* Two series connected, 2.2 nF, Y2-capacitors can replace C7.
PI-2129-121197
Figure 9. Modified Schematic of Figure 4 with Isolated 30 V Output and C13 for Common Mode Current Return.
load regulation. The schematic of Figure 7 illustrates a simple
modification to the original circuit of Figure 4, where resistor
R6 is introduced from the 12 V output to the reference pin of
the TL431 shunt regulator.
A good rule of thumb as a start point for tests is to choose R6
such that it yields about 10% of the current in R4 (with the
TL431 reference pin at 2.5 V).
In this example the current in R4 before modification is:
Figure 6(b) illustrates the improvement obtained by
employing this new feedback scheme where the load
regulation on the 12 V output is improved to ± 1.5%. The
effect would be more dramatic if the transformer had greater
leakage inductance on the output windings.
The value of R6 is generally determined through iteration and
depends on the degree of feedback desired from the second
output. Introducing feedback from a second winding has a
detrimental effect on the regulation of the main output. In this
example the change in the 5 V output increases from effectively
0% in Figure 6(a) to ± 0.75% in Fig 6(b).
I R4 =
(5 − 2.5) V
= 250 µA
10 kΩ
To emphasize the effect, we let the 12 V output provide 50%
of this amount through R6. Assuming that the TL431 reference
pin is still at 2.5 V
R6 =
(12 − 2.5) V
125 µA
= 76 kΩ
A standard resistor value of 75.0 kohm was chosen for R6 in
Figure 7.
14
C
5/98
AN-22
Note that since the sum of the currents through R4 and R6 is a
constant equal to 2.5V divided by R5, the additional feedback
that R6 introduces from the 12 V output will tend to reduce the
regulated value of the 5 V output. This requires that R4 is in
turn adjusted to retain the 5 V output at the desired level. To
retain the voltage at the reference pin of the TL431 at 2.5 V, the
value of R4 must therefore be increased to reduce its current by
50%.
R4 =
100%. In Figure 8(a), the 5 V output is very stable since this
is exclusively providing output feedback, while the 12 V
output drops by 4% over the load range. In Figure 8(b), the
introduction of R6 maintains tighter regulation on the 12 V
output (± 1.5% variation with load), whereas this additional
feedback introduces a ± 0.75% variation in the 5 V output
voltage over the same load range.
The degree of feedback required from each output can thus be
determined depending on the application requirements for
output voltage tolerance. Breadboard evaluation is necessary
to adjust component values for the desired performance.
(5 − 2.5) V
= 20 kΩ
(250 − 125) µA
A slightly larger precision 21.0 kohm resistor was specified in
the circuit of Figure 7 to compensate for the small penalty in
regulation on the 5 V output.
Figure 8 shows load regulation measurements before and after
these circuit modifications with the 5 V output load held
constant at 1 A and the 12 V output load varied from 10% to
EMI Considerations
In general, the EMI considerations in a multiple output
TOPSwitch power supply do not differ from those of a single
output supply, and are covered in detail in AN-15. There are,
however, specific multiple output power supplies where
C12
47 µF
50 V
D5
UF4004
30 V
C6
100 µF
50V
L3
3.3 µH
12 V
C11
120 µF
35 V
C10
470 µF
35 V
D4
MUR420
L1
3.3 µH
D8
MBR745
VR1
P6KE200
5V
C2
1000 µF
35 V
C3
120 µF
35 V
RTN
C1
68 µF
400 V
L2
33 mH
D1
BYV26C
U2
CNY 17-2
BR1
400 V
D3
1N4148
R2
100 Ω
1/2 W
C4
0.1 µF
R1
75 Ω
T1
F1
1.0 A
L
N
J1
C9
0.1 µF
U1
C8
0.1 µF
D TOP223
CONTROL
TOPSwitch-II
R4
10 kΩ
C
R3
5.2 Ω
S
C5
47 µF
C15
22 µF
25 V
U3
TL431
C7*
1000 pF
250VAC
Y1
* Two series connected, 2.2 nF, Y2-capacitors can replace C7.
R5
10 kΩ
PI-2132-121897
Figure 10. Modified Schematic of Figure 4 with Soft-Start Capacitor C15 Added.
C
5/98
15
AN-22
DC Rail
DC Rail
+V Output
+V Output
DRAIN
Bias
Output
RTN
–V Output
Primary
RTN
(a)
DRAIN
Bias
Output
RTN
–V Output
Primary
RTN
(b)
PI-2130-120297
Figure 11 (a), (b). Two Configurations to Get Negative Outputs.
additional measures are necessary to optimize the EMI
performance. This is particularly true when the outputs are
galvanically isolated from each other. In motor control circuits,
for example, several isolated outputs may be required to
supply high side drivers in an inverter output stage.
In these cases it is important that displacement currents driven
by the TOPSwitch DRAIN node through the transformer’s
interwinding capacitance have a low impedance return path
from a specific output to the primary side of the power supply.
This consideration demands that each isolated output provide
a low impedance path for common mode displacement
currents to return from its own return to the primary return
(TOPSwitch SOURCE potential). This low impedance path
can usually be provided from the output’s return through a
capacitor (suitably rated for the isolation voltage required on
a particular output) to the main secondary return, from where
a safety Y capacitor is connected to the primary return rail.
This configuration is shown in Figure 9, where the isolated
30 V output has a 500 V capacitor, C13, connected between
its return rail and that of the main power supply output.
If these low impedance capacitive paths are not provided on
each isolated output, then the common mode displacement
currents transferred through the transformer interwinding
capacitance will return to their source on the primary of the
transformer through any alternative route that is available.
The common mode currents may split many times on their
route to the DRAIN node. If a capacitive return path is not
present, there is the risk that enough of the displacement
current will flow through the AC input conductors to fail
regulatory emission specifications.
16
C
5/98
The need for additional capacitors in this type of circuit
depends on the transformer’s interwinding capacitance.
Additional capacitors from an isolated output may not be
necessary if its capacitance to the primary is low enough.
However, tests are essential to verify the necessity of additional
components.
One other EMI consideration related to output diode snubbers
is worthy of note. Output diodes are always a source of
additional noise that depends on their forward and reverse
recovery characteristics, particularly the di/dt and dv/dt during
recovery. Many diodes are now available with so called ‘soft
recovery’ characteristics which are designed to limit switching
noise. It is often desirable, however, to further snub the diode
characteristics with external components.
These external snubbers are usually a single capacitor, or series
resistor and capacitor in parallel with the output diodes.
In many cases the snubbing circuitry can be limited to a single
output diode to achieve the desired reduction in switching
noise. In such cases, the highest voltage winding with
significant loading should be chosen for the snubber circuitry.
In this example, the 12 V output diode would be chosen since
the capacitors on that output have lower ESR than the
capacitors on the 30 V output. It also has the best overall
coupling with the primary winding because it is physically
closest. During the primary switching events, these snubber
components are an AC current path in series with the output
electrolytic capacitors. They therefore provide a low
impedance AC path across the transformer output winding and
the output diode to confine the noise currents created by
primary switching events.
AN-22
Additional Tips
Following are some tips which can be considered and tested
where necessary to improve circuit performance.
Optocoupler Connection
In multiple output power supplies, the current for the
optocoupler LED is often supplied via the loop gain setting
resistor from an output other than the main feedback voltage.
In Figure 4, this connection of R1 is made to the 5 V winding.
This technique introduces some AC feedback from the 5 V
winding, which helps reduce variation on that output during
transient load conditions.
R1 and R2 may be connected to the 12 V output instead of the
5 V output (with their values changed appropriately). Ripple
current from this output has a path to the TL431 reference pin
via R1 and C9. This type of connection, however, will often
introduce loop instability with very light loads on the 12 V
output. The reason is that the 12 V output is subject to peak
charging from energy in leakage inductance as its load
approaches zero. Peak charging effectively uncouples the
output so that it is no longer related to the 5 V output by the
turns ratio. If instability is observed during light or no load
conditions on the 12 V output, two options are available:
1. The optocoupler LED should be supplied from the 5 V
winding (with the value of R1 selected to maintain
acceptable AC gain) or
2. A dummy or minimum load resistor can be added to the
12 V output to eliminate the effects of peak charging.
Dummy loads are usually added to improve regulation at
light loads. R2 is used for this purpose on the 5 V output
in Figure 4. R2 might be moved to the 12 V output if one
dummy load is sufficient to meet specifications. The
value of this resistor should be adjusted as necessary to
allow for the load range of a particular application.
Soft Start Circuitry
Soft start circuitry is often useful to avoid output voltage
overshoot during power supply turn on. This is achieved
simply by introducing a capacitor from the TL431 cathode to
anode as shown by C15 in Figure 10.
Note a discharge path is required for this capacitor to insure
the soft start function is reset when the output voltages decay
at turn off. This function is provided in Figure 10 by the
minimum load resistor R2.
When introducing soft start, it is useful to supply the
optocoupler LED from a higher voltage output, such as the
12 V rail in this case, since this will insure that C15 begins to
charge and provide the soft start function as soon as possible
after the power supply starts to operate. The issues of
minimum load on the higher voltage output, discussed above,
must be considered when doing this to insure loop stability
under all conditions.
Improving Regulation in Lightly Loaded Outputs
Some outputs, such as the 30 V output in this example, can
have very light loads even under maximum load conditions.
These are prone to peak charging, which can produce output
voltages much higher than expected by the turns ratio of the
transformer output. The degree of this peak charging is
strongly influenced by the loads on the other outputs.
The output in question can simply be clamped with a Zener
diode between the output and secondary return. However, a
lower cost and more efficient solution is to provide some low
pass filtering that will reject the short voltage spikes from
leakage inductance to prevent charging of the output capacitors.
The introduction of a resistor in series with D5 in Figure 4 will
provide this function. Values from 10 to 100 ohms should be
tested to determine the optimum. See R6 in Figure 1.
Negative Outputs
Negative outputs are often required in a system for
operational amplifiers or other analog circuitry. Two simple
configurations generally used to provide these outputs are
shown in Figure 11.
Figure 11(a) shows the most usual configuration, where the
direction of the output diode is reversed such that that diode's
cathode is connected to the transformer’s output pin. The other
end of the negative winding is connected to the common
secondary return using the same dot convention as the other
output windings. An alternative technique connects the anode
of the output diode to the return end of the winding with the
cathode connected to the common secondary return as shown
in Figure 11(b). The alternate, however, is not available with
stacked windings.
The calculation of the number of output turns is identical to that
for positive outputs, and the same transformer construction
techniques are used to optimize cross regulation. Since
negative outputs are often lightly loaded, the techniques to
improve regulation in lightly loaded outputs detailed above are
often useful. Alternatively, the output can simply be post
regulated with a linear regulator.
C
5/98
17
AN-22
Appendix A
Key Spreadsheet Variables.
The following key variables in the transformer design
spreadsheet of Figure 2 should be checked before a transformer
design can be deemed acceptable:
DMAX — Must be less than the TOPSwitch data sheet
minimum value of 64% (0.64).
IP — To allow for thermal effects, this should be no
greater than 90% of the data sheet minimum
current limit specification for the chosen
TOPSwitch at 25 °C. In this example, the
minimum current limit for the TOP223Y is
specified as 0.9 A, so the spreadsheet value of
0.78 meets the above criterion.
BP — This must be below the recommended value of
4200 gauss to avoid excessive core saturation at
the peak TOPSwitch current limit. Here the value
of 3767 gauss is well within this requirement.
LG — Although the guidance of transformer vendors
should be sought, airgaps of <0.051mm are not
recommended because such small gaps make
it difficult to hold a reasonable tolerance on the
specified primary inductance.
CMA — Values between 200 and 500 allow reasonable
temperature rise in the windings. Smaller
values indicate higher temperatures from
greater losses in the copper. The value of 219
circular mils per amp in Figure 2 meets the
recommended lower limit of 200.
Again, AN-17 should be consulted for full details on the use of
the spreadsheet of Figure 2.
18
C
5/98
AN-22
Appendix B
3.3 V and 5 V Outputs
An increasing number of applications require that both 3.3 V
and 5 V outputs in multiple output power supplies, both
requiring ±5% regulation to supply digital control circuitry.
Several commonly used techniques to achieve this
performance are described below.
the volts per turn provides a solution where 4 turns are used
with a Schottky diode for the 5 V output.
The disadvantage of this technique is reduced power supply
efficiency, although it simplifies the transformer construction
and reduces the number of output pins.
VO = 3.3 V
VD = 0.7 V
NS = 3 turns
Then from (1) find
VPT = 1.33 V per turn
rearranging (1) to calculate the turns required for the 5 V output
yields:
Transformer Turns Ratio
Two techniques are commonly used to design separate
transformer windings for each output. Each has the required
turns ratio relationship to provide the regulation required.
1. Copper wire
If 3 turns are defined for the 3.3 V output and an ultra fast PN
junction diode is specified for this output, the calculation of
(1)
If
Linear Regulator
The simplest, though least efficient technique, is to design
only a 5 V output winding with wire capable of supplying the
RMS current for both the 5 V and 3.3 V outputs. A linear
regulator is then placed on this 5 V output, regulating down to
3.3 V as shown in Figure 1. Integrated 3.3 V regulators are now
available from a number of suppliers with varying current
capabilities. A simple emitter follower regulator could also be
employed using discrete components.
(VO + VD )
NS
VPT =
NS =
VO + VD
VPT
(2)
If
VS = 5 V
VD = 0.4 V
5V
Linear Regulator
3.3 V
RTN
PI-2133 -121597
Figure 1. Derivation of 3.3 V Output from 5 V with Linear Regulator.
C
5/98
19
AN-22
Insulated
Backing
Wrapped to
Provide
Creepage
Distance
Foil
Prepared
to Exact
Bobbin
Width
Return
Termination
Point
3.3 V Output
Termination
Point
5 V Output
Termination
Point
PI-2134 -121897
Figure 2. Preparation of Foil Windings for 5 V and 3.3 V Outputs.
VPT = 1.33 V per turn
From (2), the turns required on the 5 V output are:
NS = 4.06 turns
This result demonstrates that this choice of turns and output
diodes yields an almost perfect integer turns ratio between the
3.3 V and 5 V outputs. It is a very popular solution for this
reason.
The coupling between the output windings is still a crucial
factor to insure that the turns ratio calculated above does
indeed result in the required output cross regulation. Since so
few turns are involved in these outputs, it is usual for multiple
parallel wire strands to be used on each output winding, and for
the 3.3 V and 5 V outputs to be constructed as separate
windings. Stacked windings are not appropriate in this case.
As discussed in the body of the application note, windings
should be constructed in 2 layers and interleaved across the
bobbin width to optimize coupling with the primary winding.
2. Foil windings
An alternative technique is to use foil instead of multiple
strands of copper wire. Using this technique, the turns ratio of
3 turns on the 3.3 V output and 4 turns on the 5 V output is
retained. The foil is cut to the required length with appropriate
termination points included prior to winding. The foil is then
20
C
5/98
wound as a single operation. Termination to the transformer
pins is performed afterwards. Figure 2 illustrates this
technique.
The foil is prepared to fit the bobbin width of the chosen
transformer exactly, and is backed with insulation material
which is wrapped around the foil to provide creepage
distances appropriate to the required isolation requirements of
the application.
Although this technique may add some cost to the transformer
construction, the fact that the foil is prepared to the exact
bobbin width provides excellent coupling with the primary
winding. In addition, the 3.3 V and 5 V windings have very
good mutual coupling that improves cross regulation. This
mutual coupling makes the stacked winding construction the
preferred technique when using foil windings.
As shown in Figure 3, subsequent output windings can be
stacked on the foil windings, though the total RMS current
requirements must accounted for in the choice of the foil.
Independent of whether copper wire or foil winding
techniques are used, the output feedback configuration must be
determined according to the load and regulation requirements.
Figure 4 shows the use of a TL431 where the feedback is
derived from both the 3.3 V and 5 V outputs. The proportion
of feedback from each output can be adjusted as required, and
is discussed in detail in the body of the Application Note.
AN-22
Additional
Secondary
Windings
Foil
Foil
Wrapped
Insulation
Primary
PI-2136 -121997
Figure 3. Winding Arrangement with Foil and Wire for Multiple Outputs.
5V
3.3 V
RTN
PI-2138 -121997
Figure 4. Use of Feedback from Both Outputs with TL431 to Improve Regulation on 3.3 V Output.
C
5/98
21
AN-22
Appendix C
Transformer Construction Details
MARGIN WOUND TRANSFORMER
1
7
13
1
6
1
7
13
13 T #27 AWG
77 T
#30 AWG
PIN
1
3
5
6
7, 8
9, 10
11
12
13
12
5 T #27 AWG x2
11
10
9
3
5
9T
3x #27 AWG
4 T #27 AWG x6
8
7
6
CORE# - ETD29 (Philips)
GAP FOR AL OF 225 nH/T2
BOBBIN# 4322 021 3438 (Philips)
FUNCTION
HIGH-VOLTAGE DC BUS
TOPSwitch DRAIN
VBIAS
PRIMARY-SIDE COMMON
RETURN
+5 V OUTPUT
+5 V OUTPUT CONNECTION
+12 V OUTPUT
+30 V OUTPUT
ELECTRICAL SPECIFICATIONS
Electrical Strength
60 Hz, 1 minute,
from pins 1-6 to pins 7-13
3000 VAC
Creepage
Between pins 1-6 and pins 7-13
5.0 mm (min)
Primary Inductance
All windings open
1340 µH, –10%
Resonant Frequency
All windings open
1 MHz (min)
Primary Leakage Inductance
Pins 7 through 13 shorted
34 µH (max)
NOTE: All inductance measurements should be made at 100 kHz
PI-2140-121997
PARTS LIST FOR TRANSFORMER DESIGN EXAMPLE
Item Amt.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
1pr.
1ea.
A/R
A/R
A/R
A/R
A/R
A/R
Description
Part #
Manufacturer
Core, ETD29
Bobbin, ETD29-1S-13P, 13 pin
Wire, 30 AWG Heavy Nyleze
Wire, 27 AWG Heavy Nyleze
Tape, Epoxy 2.5 mm wide
Tape, Polyester 14 mm wide
Tape, Polyester 19 mm wide
Varnish
4312 020 3750*
4322 021 3438
Philips
Philips
#10
#1298
#1298
3M
3M
3M
*Gap for AL of 225 nH/T2 ± 5%
22
C
5/98
PI-2154-020598
AN-22
MARGIN WOUND TRANSFORMER CONSTRUCTION
TAPE
13
+30 V
TAPE MARGINS
(4 PLACES)
+5, +12 V
TAPE
TAPE
TAPE
7
12
8
11
10
12
6
5
9
BIAS
1
3
PRIMARY
WINDING INSTRUCTIONS
Primary and Bias Margins
Tape Margins with item [5]. Match height with Primary and Bias windings.
Double Primary Layer
Start at Pin 3. Wind 39 turns of item [3] from left to right. Wind in a single
layer. Apply 1 layer of tape, item [6], for basic insulation. Wind remaining
38 turns in the next layer from right to left. Finish on Pin 1.
Basic Insulation
Bias Winding
Reinforced Insulation
Output Margins
+5 V and +12 V Winding
1 Layer of tape [6] for insulation.
Start at Pin 5. Wind 9 Parallel Trifilar turns of item [4] from left to right. Wind
uniformly, in a single layer, across entire width of bobbin. Finish on Pin 6.
3 Layers of tape [7] for insulation.
Tape Margins with item [5]. Match height with all output windings
Start with two sets each containing three wires item [4], and one pair of
wires item [4]. Terminate first set of three wires to pin 9 and the second set
of three wires to pin 10. Terminate the pair of wires to pin 12. Wind the
combination of eight wires in parallel right to left evenly across the bobbin,
with the pair of wires closest to the right side of the bobbin. After four turns
of the combination of eight wires, terminate the first set of wires to pin 8 and
the second set of wires to pin 7. Continue to wind the pair of wires one
more turn for five turns total. Finish at pin 11.
Basic Insulation
1 Layer of tape [6] for basic insulation.
+30 V Winding
Start at Pin 13. Wind 13 turns of item [4] from right to left. Wind uniformly,
in a single layer, across entire width of bobbin. Finish on Pin 12.
Outer Assembly
3 Layers of tape [7] for insulation.
Final Assembly
Assemble and secure core halves. Impregnate uniformly with varnish.
PI-2152-020498
C
5/98
23
AN-22
For the latest updates, visit our Web site: www.powerint.com
Power Integrations reserves the right to make changes to its products at any time to improve reliability or manufacturability.
Power Integrations does not assume any liability arising from the use of any device or circuit described herein, nor does it
convey any license under its patent rights or the rights of others.
The PI Logo, TOPSwitch, TinySwitch and EcoSmart are registered trademarks of Power Integrations, Inc.
©Copyright 2001, Power Integrations, Inc.
WORLD HEADQUARTERS
AMERICAS
Power Integrations, Inc.
5245 Hellyer Avenue
San Jose, CA 95138 USA
Main:
+1 408-414-9200
Customer Service:
Phone:
+1 408-414-9665
Fax:
+1 408-414-9765
e-mail: [email protected]
EUROPE & AFRICA
Power Integrations (Europe) Ltd.
Centennial Court
Easthampstead Road
Bracknell
Berkshire, RG12 1YQ
United Kingdom
Phone:
+44-1344-462-300
Fax:
+44-1344-311-732
e-mail: [email protected]
TAIWAN
Power Integrations
International Holdings, Inc.
17F-3, No. 510
Chung Hsiao E. Rd.,
Sec. 5,
Taipei, Taiwan 110, R.O.C.
Phone:
+886-2-2727-1221
Fax:
+886-2-2727-1223
e-mail: [email protected]
CHINA
Power Integrations
International Holdings, Inc.
Rm# 1705, Bao Hua Bldg.
1016 Hua Qiang Bei Lu
Shenzhen, Guangdong 518031
China
Phone:
+86-755-367-5143
Fax:
+86-755-377-9610
e-mail: [email protected]
KOREA
Power Integrations
International Holdings, Inc.
Rm# 402, Handuk Building
649-4 Yeoksam-Dong,
Kangnam-Gu,
Seoul, Korea
Phone:
+82-2-568-7520
Fax:
+82-2-568-7474
e-mail: [email protected]
JAPAN
Power Integrations, K.K.
Keihin-Tatemono 1st Bldg.
12-20 Shin-Yokohama 2-Chome
Kohoku-ku, Yokohama-shi
Kanagawa 222-0033, Japan
Phone:
+81-45-471-1021
Fax:
+81-45-471-3717
e-mail: [email protected]
INDIA (Technical Support)
Innovatech
#1, 8th Main Road
Vasanthnagar
Bangalore, India 560052
Phone:
+91-80-226-6023
Fax:
+91-80-228-9727
e-mail: [email protected]
APPLICATIONS HOTLINE
World Wide +1-408-414-9660
24
C
5/98
APPLICATIONS FAX
World Wide +1-408-414-9760